- Practice
- About 20 min
- 5 practice questions
Interest: meaning and theories
Explain gross and net interest and the abstinence, agio, loanable funds and Keynes' liquidity preference theories, and solve simple numerical problems on the supply of loanable funds and the equilibrium rate of interest.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define interest and split gross interest into its parts.
- State the abstinence (waiting) and agio (time preference) theories.
- Add up demand and supply of loanable funds and find the equilibrium.
- Explain Keynes' three motives and solve for the rate of interest from a money demand equation.
When you deposit money in a bank or a firm borrows to buy machines, interest is paid. But why should anyone pay for the use of money? The textbook gives four answers, from the classical economists to Keynes.
Meaning and kinds of interest
Interest is the reward paid by the borrower to the lender for the use of capital. Marshall called it the price paid for the use of capital in any market.
Gross interest is the total amount a creditor receives from a debtor. Net interest is only the payment for the use of capital; the textbook's example of net interest is the interest on government securities.
Gross interest = Net interest + reward for inconvenience + insurance against risk of non-repayment + payment for managing the loan
Example (made up): a moneylender charges 15% a year. If 7% is the pure payment for capital, 3% covers inconvenience, 4% covers the risk of non-repayment and 1% covers the work of managing the loan, then gross interest = 7 + 3 + 4 + 1 = 15%, of which net interest is 7%.
1. Abstinence or waiting theory
Put forward by N.W. Senior: capital comes from saving, and saving means abstinence from present consumption, which involves sacrifice. Interest is the reward for this sacrifice. Marshall accepted the idea but used the word waiting: saving means waiting, people dislike waiting, so they must be paid to wait. Criticism: for rich people saving may involve no suffering at all.
2. Agio or time preference theory
First stated by John Rae (1834), given its final shape by the Austrian economist Böhm-Bawerk, and modified by Irving Fisher as the time preference theory. People prefer present goods to future goods because the present is more certain (a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush). Whoever postpones present enjoyment by saving must be paid a premium, an agio; that premium is interest.
3. Loanable funds theory (neo-classical)
Developed by Swedish economists such as Wicksell, Ohlin, Myrdal and also Viner. Interest is the price paid for the use of loanable funds, and the rate of interest is set where the demand for loanable funds equals their supply.
Demand for and supply of loanable funds
-
Demand (LD = I + C + H)
Varies inversely with the rate of interest.
- I: investment by firms buying capital goods (the largest part)
- C: borrowing for consumption
- H: hoarding, from the preference for liquidity
-
Supply (LS = S + BC + DH + DI)
Varies directly with the rate of interest.
- S: savings (planned ex-ante and unplanned ex-post)
- BC: bank credit created by commercial banks
- DH: dishoarding, bringing hoarded money into use
- DI: disinvestment, not providing enough funds for replacing worn-out equipment
In the book's Diagram 6.4, LS slopes upward and LD downward; they cross at E, giving OR as the rate of interest and OM as the quantity of loanable funds.
Worked example 1: loanable funds (made-up data, ₹ crore)
At a given rate of interest: savings 300, bank credit 100, dishoarding 50, disinvestment 50; investment demand 350, consumption borrowing 80, hoarding 70. Working: LS = 300 + 100 + 50 + 50 = 500. LD = 350 + 80 + 70 = 500. Answer: LS = LD = ₹500 crore, so this rate of interest is the equilibrium rate. If LD were larger than LS, the rate would have to rise.
Criticism: the textbook notes that real-world factors such as asymmetric information and moral hazard are left out, that the theory is indeterminate unless the income level is known, and that it mixes real factors (saving, investment) with monetary ones (bank credit, hoarding).
4. Keynes' liquidity preference theory
J.M. Keynes set out this monetary theory in The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money (1936). To Keynes interest is purely monetary: it is the reward for parting with liquidity for a specified period. Liquidity preference is the desire to hold wealth as cash rather than as bonds, land, gold or other non-liquid assets.
| Motive | Why cash is held | Depends on |
|---|---|---|
| Transaction motive (Mt) | Day-to-day expenses | Income: Mt = f(Y) |
| Precautionary motive (Mp) | Unexpected expenses: illness, accident, fire, theft | Income: Mp = f(Y) |
| Speculative motive (Ms) | To gain from future changes in bond prices | Rate of interest, inversely: Ms = f(i) |
The supply of money (coins, currency notes and bank deposits) is fixed by the government and the central bank and is taken as constant in the short run. The rate of interest is set where liquidity preference (the demand for money) meets the money supply. If liquidity preference rises with supply unchanged, the rate rises; if the money supply rises with liquidity preference unchanged, the rate falls (Diagrams 6.5 and 6.6).
Worked example 2: equilibrium rate (made-up figures)
Suppose speculative demand for money is Ms = 500 − 50i (₹ crore, i in per cent) and the money available for speculative holding is ₹300 crore. Working: at equilibrium 500 − 50i = 300, so 50i = 500 − 300 = 200, and i = 200 ÷ 50 = 4. Check: 500 − 50 × 4 = 300. Answer: the equilibrium rate of interest is 4%. If the money supply rose to ₹350 crore: 500 − 50i = 350 gives i = 3%, so more money means a lower rate.
Criticism: it cannot explain why different interest rates exist in the market at the same time, and it explains interest only in the short run.
Key takeaways: net interest is the pure payment for capital; gross interest adds charges for risk, inconvenience and management. Senior and Marshall saw interest as the reward for abstinence or waiting, Böhm-Bawerk as the premium for present over future goods, the loanable funds theory as the price that balances LD = I + C + H with LS = S + BC + DH + DI, and Keynes as the reward for parting with liquidity.
Check your understanding
-
1. Keynes' theory of interest is popularly known as the:
- Abstinence theory
- Agio theory
- Liquidity preference theory
- Loanable funds theory
Show answer
Answer: C. Keynes explained interest as the reward for parting with liquidity, so his theory is the liquidity preference theory.
-
2. Savings ₹420 crore, bank credit ₹130 crore, dishoarding ₹30 crore and disinvestment ₹20 crore. The supply of loanable funds is:
- ₹550 crore
- ₹600 crore
- ₹570 crore
- ₹450 crore
Show answer
Answer: B. LS = S + BC + DH + DI = 420 + 130 + 30 + 20 = ₹600 crore.
-
3. Holding cash to meet an unexpected illness is, according to Keynes, the:
- precautionary motive
- transaction motive
- speculative motive
- business motive
Show answer
Answer: A. The precautionary motive is the desire to hold cash for unforeseen expenses such as sickness, accidents, fire and theft.
-
4. If Ms = 600 − 80i and the money available for speculation is ₹360 crore, the equilibrium rate of interest is:
- 4.5%
- 7.5%
- 2%
- 3%
Show answer
Answer: D. 600 − 80i = 360, so 80i = 240 and i = 3. Check: 600 − 80 × 3 = 360. The rate is 3%.
-
5. Marshall accepted Senior's theory of interest but replaced the word 'abstinence' with:
- liquidity
- waiting
- agio
- risk
Show answer
Answer: B. Marshall argued that saving implies waiting, so interest is the reward for waiting.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.