- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Rent: Ricardian theory, quasi-rent and the modern theory
Explain the Ricardian theory of rent with grades of land, work out economic rent from yields, and use the formulas for quasi-rent and modern (transfer-earnings) rent.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Tell the everyday meaning of rent from economic rent.
- State the assumptions of the Ricardian theory and calculate rent on intra-marginal land.
- Distinguish rent from quasi-rent and calculate quasi-rent.
- Calculate rent as actual earnings minus transfer earnings.
In daily speech, rent is what a tenant pays for a house, a shop or even a machine. Economists use the word more narrowly. This lesson follows the textbook through three ideas of rent: Ricardo's classical theory, Marshall's quasi-rent and the modern theory.
Meaning
Rent in ordinary use is the payment for the use of land, a house or a machine. In economics, rent or economic rent is that part of the payment by a tenant to the landlord for the use of land only, not for buildings or improvements on it.
Ricardian Theory of Rent
David Ricardo's theory is the classical theory of rent. Ricardo described rent as payment for the 'original and indestructible powers of the soil'. Its central idea is that rent is a differential surplus: the extra yield of better land over the poorest land in use.
Assumptions
- Land differs in fertility.
- The law of diminishing returns operates in agriculture.
- Rent depends on fertility and location of land.
- Perfect competition.
- Long period.
- There is marginal (no-rent) land.
- Land has original and indestructible powers.
- Land is used only for cultivation.
- The most fertile land is cultivated first.
How rent arises
Rent arises as poorer land is brought under cultivation
- Settlers cultivate the best land While best land is free and plentiful, no rent is paid.
- Population grows Demand for food rises; diminishing returns limit the best land.
- Next-best land is cultivated Same labour and capital give a smaller yield there.
- Surplus appears on better land Yield of better land minus yield of the poorest land in use = economic rent.
- Poorest land in use earns nothing This is marginal or no-rent land; the rest is intra-marginal land.
Marginal (no-rent) land is land where the cost of production just equals the price of the produce, so it yields no surplus. Land that yields rent is intra-marginal land. Rent therefore shows the differential advantage of superior land over marginal land. In the book's diagram the shaded top part of each land's yield bar is its rent.
Worked example 1: rent from yields (made-up data)
With the same labour and capital, one acre yields: grade P land 60 bags, grade Q land 45 bags, grade R land 35 bags. All three are cultivated.
| Grade | Yield (bags) | Rent = yield − yield of marginal land |
|---|---|---|
| P | 60 | 60 − 35 = 25 |
| Q | 45 | 45 − 35 = 10 |
| R (marginal) | 35 | 35 − 35 = 0 |
Now suppose even poorer grade S land yielding 28 bags is brought under cultivation. Working: S becomes the marginal land, so rent on P = 60 − 28 = 32, Q = 45 − 28 = 17, R = 35 − 28 = 7, S = 0. Answer: every intra-marginal land's rent rises by 7 bags, and R, which earned nothing before, now earns 7 bags.
Criticisms
- The order of cultivation, from most fertile to least fertile, is historically wrong.
- The theory assumes that rent does not enter into price; critics argue that in reality rent does enter into price.
Quasi-rent
Alfred Marshall introduced quasi-rent. Man-made appliances such as plant and machinery are fixed in supply in the short period. When demand rises they earn a surplus, but it is temporary: in the long run more machines are made and the surplus disappears. Marshall described it as the income from machines and other appliances made by man.
Quasi-rent = Total Revenue − Total Variable Cost
| Basis | Rent | Quasi-rent |
|---|---|---|
| Earned by | Land | Man-made appliances |
| Supply | Fixed for ever | Fixed only in the short period |
| Relation to price (as the textbook puts it) | Enters into price | Does not enter into price |
Worked example 2: quasi-rent (made-up data)
In a busy festival season a printing press earns total revenue of ₹1,00,000 in a month. Its variable costs (paper, ink, wages) are ₹70,000. Working: QR = TR − TVC = 1,00,000 − 70,000 = ₹30,000. Answer: ₹30,000. Once more presses are set up, prices fall and this surplus shrinks.
The Modern Theory of Rent
Modern economists such as Mrs Joan Robinson and E. Boulding argued that land is not special: any factor can earn rent. Transfer earnings are the minimum payment needed to keep a factor in its present use. Whatever a factor earns above this is rent.
Rent = Actual earnings − Transfer earnings
Example (made up): a software engineer earns ₹50,000 a month. The best offer she has elsewhere is ₹40,000, so ₹40,000 is her transfer earning. Working: rent = 50,000 − 40,000 = ₹10,000 a month.
Key takeaways: economic rent is payment for land only. Ricardo saw it as the surplus of better land over marginal (no-rent) land. Quasi-rent is the short-period surplus of man-made appliances (TR − TVC). The modern theory treats rent as any earning above transfer earnings.
Check your understanding
-
1. Ricardo described rent as payment for the use of:
- the original and indestructible powers of the soil
- buildings on the land
- machines made by man
- the entrepreneur's skill
Show answer
Answer: A. Ricardo's definition links rent to the original and indestructible powers of the soil, so the theory deals with land only.
-
2. Yields per acre for the same outlay: land X 50 bags, land Y 38 bags, land Z 30 bags. If Z is the marginal land, the rent of Y is:
- 12 bags
- 20 bags
- 8 bags
- 0 bags
Show answer
Answer: C. Rent of intra-marginal land = its yield − yield of marginal land = 38 − 30 = 8 bags.
-
3. A machine owner's total revenue is ₹2,40,000 and total variable cost is ₹1,90,000 for a short period. The quasi-rent is:
- ₹4,30,000
- ₹1,90,000
- ₹2,40,000
- ₹50,000
Show answer
Answer: D. QR = TR − TVC = 2,40,000 − 1,90,000 = ₹50,000.
-
4. Which economist is associated with the concept of quasi-rent?
- David Ricardo
- Alfred Marshall
- J.M. Keynes
- F.A. Walker
Show answer
Answer: B. Marshall introduced quasi-rent to describe the short-period surplus earned by man-made appliances.
-
5. A farm worker earns ₹18,000 a month; his transfer earning is ₹15,500. According to the modern theory his rent is:
- ₹2,500
- ₹33,500
- ₹15,500
- ₹18,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Rent = actual earnings − transfer earnings = 18,000 − 15,500 = ₹2,500.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.