- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Wages: kinds and theories
Distinguish money, real, piece and time wages and explain the subsistence, standard of living, wage fund, residual claimant and marginal productivity theories of wages with their criticisms.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define wages and name the four kinds the textbook gives.
- Calculate average wage under the wage fund theory.
- Explain each theory of wages and one criticism of it.
A daily-wage mason and a salaried officer both earn wages in the economist's sense. Why do wages rise or fall? Economists have offered many answers over two centuries; the Tamil Nadu textbook takes five of them in order.
Meaning of wages
Wages are the payment for the services of labour, whether intellectual or physical, and may be paid daily, weekly, fortnightly, monthly or yearly, sometimes partly as a bonus. In short, wage is the price paid to the labourer for services rendered. The textbook quotes Benham's definition of a wage as a sum of money paid under contract by an employer to a worker for services rendered.
Kinds of wages
| Kind | Meaning |
|---|---|
| Nominal (money) wages | Wages paid in terms of money |
| Real wages | Wages in terms of the goods and services money can buy: the purchasing power of money wages |
| Piece wages | Paid by the amount of work done |
| Time wages | Paid by the time the worker works |
Worked example 1: money and real wages (made-up data)
Kavitha's monthly money wage rises from ₹12,000 to ₹15,000, a rise of 25%. Over the same period the prices of what she buys rise by 50%. Working: with prices 1.5 times as high, ₹15,000 buys what ₹15,000 ÷ 1.5 = ₹10,000 bought before. Answer: her money wage rose, but her real wage fell from ₹12,000 to the equivalent of ₹10,000 of the old goods. Real wage, not money wage, decides how well off she is.
Theories of wages
Theories of wages in the Tamil Nadu textbook
-
Subsistence theory
- Physiocrats; restated by Ricardo
- Wage = subsistence of worker and family
-
Standard of living theory
- Torrance
- Wage = cost of the accustomed standard of living
-
Wage fund theory
- Adam Smith first; perfected by J.S. Mill
- Wage = wage fund ÷ number of workers
-
Residual claimant theory
- F.A. Walker, 1875
- Wage = what is left after rent, interest and profit
-
Marginal productivity theory
- General theory applied to labour
- Wage = MP of labour at equilibrium
1. Subsistence theory
One of the oldest theories, first explained by the Physiocrats (French economists) and restated by Ricardo. Wages tend to equal subsistence: the minimum food, clothing and shelter a worker and family need to exist. If wages rise above subsistence, families grow, labour supply rises and wages fall back. If wages fall below it, population falls, labour becomes scarce and wages rise. So it is closely linked with the Malthusian theory of population.
Criticism: it ignores trade unions and collective bargaining; it cannot explain different wages in different jobs; and the textbook notes that higher wages often lead to smaller, not larger, families.
2. Standard of living theory
Developed by Torrance as a refined version of the subsistence theory. Wages equal the amount needed to maintain the standard of living to which workers are accustomed: a high standard means high wages. Criticism: in practice it is wages that decide the standard of living, not the other way round.
3. Wage fund theory
First put forward by Adam Smith and perfected by J.S. Mill. Every employer sets aside a fixed amount of capital, the wage fund, for paying workers. Wages vary directly with the fund and inversely with the number of workers.
Average wage per worker = Total wage fund ÷ Number of workers
Worked example 2: wage fund (made-up data)
A firm's wage fund is ₹6,00,000 a month. Working: with 120 workers, average wage = 6,00,000 ÷ 120 = ₹5,000. If the firm employs 150 workers from the same fund, average wage = 6,00,000 ÷ 150 = ₹4,000. Answer: more workers from a fixed fund means a lower wage each.
Criticism: it does not explain wage differences between occupations, ignores trade unions, says nothing about how large the fund is, and in fact capitalists take a large share before paying wages.
4. Residual claimant theory
Put forward by the American economist F.A. Walker in 1875 in his book Political Economy. The wage is what remains after rent, interest and profit have been paid: the worker is the residual claimant. Criticism: it ignores trade unions, which can win higher wages, and it leaves out the demand side of labour.
5. Marginal productivity theory of wages
This is the general theory of lesson 1 applied to labour. At equilibrium the wage equals the marginal product of labour (wage = MPL) under perfect competition. In the real world of imperfect competition, the textbook notes, labour is exploited and the wage is less than MPL.
Key takeaways: real wages, not money wages, measure a worker's welfare. Five theories explain wages by subsistence, standard of living, a fixed wage fund, the residual after other factors, or labour's marginal product; each has its limits, and several ignore trade unions.
Check your understanding
-
1. Real wages are best described as:
- wages paid by the piece
- the purchasing power of money wages
- wages paid in cash only
- wages paid for overtime
Show answer
Answer: B. Real wages are wages in terms of the goods and services money can buy, i.e. the purchasing power of money wages.
-
2. A firm's wage fund is ₹4,80,000 and it employs 160 workers. Under the wage fund theory the average wage is:
- ₹3,000
- ₹2,400
- ₹4,800
- ₹30,000
Show answer
Answer: A. Average wage = wage fund ÷ number of workers = 4,80,000 ÷ 160 = ₹3,000.
-
3. The Residual Claimant Theory of wages was propounded by:
- J.S. Mill
- Torrance
- Ricardo
- F.A. Walker
Show answer
Answer: D. F.A. Walker put it forward in 1875: wages are the residue left after paying rent, interest and profit.
-
4. Which theory of wages is closely associated with the Malthusian theory of population?
- Wage fund theory
- Residual claimant theory
- Subsistence theory
- Marginal productivity theory
Show answer
Answer: C. The subsistence theory says wages above subsistence raise population and labour supply, pushing wages back down, which ties it to Malthus's population theory.
-
5. Assertion (A): A worker whose money wage doubles may be worse off. Reason (R): Welfare depends on real wages, which also depend on prices.
- A is false, but R is true
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- A is true, but R is false
Show answer
Answer: C. If prices more than double, the doubled money wage buys less than before, so A is true; R gives exactly this reason.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.