- Practice
- About 25 min
- 5 practice questions
Dimensional analysis: dimensions, homogeneity and its uses
Write dimensional formulae, classify quantities as dimensional or dimensionless variables and constants, and use the principle of homogeneity to convert units, check equations and derive relations, knowing the method's limits.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Write the dimensional formula of common mechanical quantities in terms of M, L and T.
- Classify quantities as dimensional or dimensionless variables and constants.
- State the principle of homogeneity of dimensions.
- Use n₁[M₁ᵃL₁ᵇT₁ᶜ] = n₂[M₂ᵃL₂ᵇT₂ᶜ] to convert a quantity between unit systems.
- Check equations and derive relations by dimensions, and list the limitations of the method.
Dimensional analysis is the physicist's quick check. In a few lines it can catch a wrong formula, convert a value from c.g.s. to SI, or even suggest how a quantity depends on others. In mechanics every quantity can be written in terms of three base quantities: mass [M], length [L] and time [T].
Dimensions of a physical quantity
The dimensions of a quantity are the powers to which the base quantities must be raised to represent it. We write the dimension of a quantity in square brackets. [length] = M⁰LT⁰ = [L], [area] = [L²], [volume] = [L³]. A pure number like 2 is dimensionless: [M⁰L⁰T⁰].
| Quantity | Relation | Dimensional formula |
|---|---|---|
| Velocity, speed | distance / time | [LT⁻¹] |
| Acceleration | velocity / time | [LT⁻²] |
| Momentum, impulse | mass × velocity; force × time | [MLT⁻¹] |
| Force | mass × acceleration | [MLT⁻²] |
| Work, energy, torque | force × distance | [ML²T⁻²] |
| Power | work / time | [ML²T⁻³] |
| Pressure, stress, elastic modulus | force / area | [ML⁻¹T⁻²] |
| Surface tension, force constant | force / length | [MT⁻²] |
| Frequency, angular velocity | 1 / time | [T⁻¹] |
| Angular momentum, Planck's constant | momentum × distance; energy / frequency | [ML²T⁻¹] |
| Gravitational constant G | force × distance² / mass² | [M⁻¹L³T⁻²] |
| Coefficient of viscosity | force / (area × velocity gradient) | [ML⁻¹T⁻¹] |
Two points to notice. Kinetic energy ½mv² and potential energy mgh both give [ML²T⁻²], and so does every form of energy. Torque also has [ML²T⁻²], yet torque (a vector) and energy (a scalar) are different quantities: equal dimensions do not make quantities the same. Also, the arguments of sin θ, eˣ and ln x must be dimensionless, and so are these functions themselves.
Four kinds of quantity
Classifying quantities by dimensions
-
Dimensional variables
- Have dimensions, values vary
- Length, velocity, acceleration
-
Dimensionless variables
- No dimensions, values vary
- Strain, specific gravity, refractive index
-
Dimensional constants
- Have dimensions, fixed values
- Gravitational constant G, Planck's constant h
-
Dimensionless constants
- No dimensions, fixed values
- π, e, pure numbers
Principle of homogeneity
Principle of homogeneity: every term in a physical equation must have the same dimensions. Only quantities of the same dimension can be added, subtracted or equated.
For v² = u² + 2as, each term has [L²T⁻²]: [u²] = [LT⁻¹]² and [2as] = [LT⁻²][L]. The method of dimensions has three uses.
Use 1: converting units
The product of the numerical value and its unit is constant: n₁[u₁] = n₂[u₂]. For a quantity of dimensions [MᵃLᵇTᶜ], n₂ = n₁ (M₁/M₂)ᵃ (L₁/L₂)ᵇ (T₁/T₂)ᶜ. Worked example 1: convert 1 joule to erg (the c.g.s. unit). Energy is [ML²T⁻²], so a = 1, b = 2, c = −2. n₂ = 1 × (1 kg/1 g)¹ × (1 m/1 cm)² × (1 s/1 s)⁻² = 10³ × (10²)² × 1 = 10³ × 10⁴ = 10⁷. So 1 J = 10⁷ erg. Similarly, mercury's density 13.6 g cm⁻³ ([ML⁻³]) in SI: n₂ = 13.6 × (1 g/1 kg)¹ × (1 cm/1 m)⁻³ = 13.6 × 10⁻³ × (10⁻²)⁻³ = 13.6 × 10⁻³ × 10⁶ = 1.36 × 10⁴ kg m⁻³.
Use 2: checking an equation
Check s = ut + ½at². [s] = [L]; [ut] = [LT⁻¹][T] = [L]; [at²] = [LT⁻²][T²] = [L]. All terms match, so the equation is dimensionally correct. Now test v² = u² + 2at: [2at] = [LT⁻²][T] = [LT⁻¹], which is not [L²T⁻²], so this equation is certainly wrong.
Use 3: deriving a relation
Worked example 2: the frequency f of a mass m vibrating on a spring is thought to depend on m and on the force constant k of the spring. Write f = C mᵃ kᵇ, with C dimensionless. Dimensions: [T⁻¹] = [M]ᵃ [MT⁻²]ᵇ = [Mᵃ⁺ᵇ T⁻²ᵇ]. Compare powers: for T, −2b = −1, so b = ½; for M, a + b = 0, so a = −½. Hence f = C √(k/m). Experiment gives C = 1/(2π). In the same way the centripetal force on a mass m moving at speed v in a circle of radius r comes out as F = C mv²/r.
Deriving a relation by dimensions
- Assume a power law Q = k Q₁ᵃ Q₂ᵇ Q₃ᶜ with k dimensionless.
- Substitute dimensions Write each quantity as M, L and T powers.
- Equate powers Match the powers of M, L and T on both sides.
- Solve and write the relation Find a, b, c; the constant k comes from experiment.
Limitations of dimensional analysis
- It gives no information about dimensionless constants such as ½, 2π or e.
- It cannot tell whether a quantity is a vector or a scalar.
- It cannot derive relations involving trigonometric, exponential or logarithmic functions.
- It cannot derive a relation involving more than three physical quantities (only three equations, for M, L and T, are available in mechanics).
- It shows only that an equation is dimensionally consistent, not that it is correct: s = ut + ⅓at² passes the test but is wrong.
Key takeaways
- Dimensions are the powers of M, L and T that make up a quantity.
- Same dimensions do not mean the same quantity (torque and energy).
- Homogeneity: every term of an equation has the same dimensions.
- Uses: unit conversion, checking equations, deriving relations.
- A true equation is always dimensionally correct, but a dimensionally correct equation need not be true.
Check your understanding
-
1. The dimensional formula of power is:
- [ML²T⁻²]
- [MLT⁻²]
- [ML²T⁻³]
- [ML²T⁻¹]
Show answer
Answer: C. Power = work/time = [ML²T⁻²]/[T] = [ML²T⁻³].
-
2. Which pair of quantities has the same dimensions?
- Torque and work
- Force and power
- Momentum and energy
- Pressure and force
Show answer
Answer: A. Torque = force × distance and work = force × distance, both [ML²T⁻²]. The others differ: force [MLT⁻²] vs power [ML²T⁻³]; momentum [MLT⁻¹] vs energy [ML²T⁻²]; pressure [ML⁻¹T⁻²] vs force [MLT⁻²].
-
3. In the relation x = A sin(ωt), where x is a displacement and t is time, the dimensions of ω are:
- [T]
- [T⁻¹]
- [LT⁻¹]
- [M⁰L⁰T⁰]
Show answer
Answer: B. The argument ωt of a sine must be dimensionless, so [ω] = 1/[T] = [T⁻¹].
-
4. Refractive index is an example of a:
- dimensional constant
- dimensional variable
- dimensionless constant
- dimensionless variable
Show answer
Answer: D. Refractive index is a ratio of two speeds, so it has no dimensions, and its value varies from one medium to another. It is a dimensionless variable.
-
5. A force of 1 N expressed in dyne (the c.g.s. unit) is:
- 10⁵ dyne
- 10³ dyne
- 10⁷ dyne
- 10² dyne
Show answer
Answer: A. Force is [MLT⁻²]: n₂ = 1 × (1 kg/1 g)¹ × (1 m/1 cm)¹ × (1 s/1 s)⁻² = 10³ × 10² = 10⁵. So 1 N = 10⁵ dyne.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.