- Practice
- About 24 min
- 5 practice questions
Vibrations of air columns, the resonance column and the Doppler effect
Find the harmonics of closed and open organ pipes, measure the speed of sound and the end correction with a resonance air column, and calculate the frequency heard when source, listener or both move.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Show that a closed pipe gives only odd harmonics (1 : 3 : 5 ...) and an open pipe all harmonics (1 : 2 : 3 ...).
- Use the resonance air column to find the speed of sound, v = 2f(L₂ − L₁), and the end correction e = (L₂ − 3L₁)/2.
- Derive the Doppler formulas for a moving listener and a moving source.
- Apply the general formula f′ = f(v + v_L)/(v − v_S) with its sign convention.
Wind instruments such as the flute, the clarinet and the nathaswaram make music from vibrating columns of air. The simplest such instrument is the organ pipe, a wooden or metal tube. Whether its ends are open or closed decides which notes it can produce. The same ideas of standing waves let a school laboratory measure the speed of sound, and the motion of a source or listener shifts the pitch heard: the Doppler effect.
Closed organ pipe
A closed pipe (such as a clarinet) has one end closed and one open. Air at the closed end cannot move, so a node forms there; an antinode forms at the open end. In the fundamental mode the pipe holds one quarter of a wavelength: L = λ₁/4, so f₁ = v/4L. Blowing harder gives the next modes: L = 3λ/4 (frequency 3f₁, the first overtone or third harmonic) and L = 5λ/4 (frequency 5f₁, the second overtone or fifth harmonic).
Closed pipe: f = (2n − 1)v/4L, n = 1, 2, 3, ...; only odd harmonics, f₁ : f₂ : f₃ ... = 1 : 3 : 5 : ...
Open organ pipe
An open pipe (such as a flute) is open at both ends, so antinodes form at both ends, with a node in the middle for the fundamental mode: L = λ₁/2, so f₁ = v/2L. The next modes are L = λ (2f₁, first overtone, second harmonic) and L = 3λ/2 (3f₁, second overtone, third harmonic).
Open pipe: f = nv/2L, n = 1, 2, 3, ...; all harmonics, f₁ : f₂ : f₃ ... = 1 : 2 : 3 : ...
Closed and open organ pipes
-
Closed pipe (clarinet)
- Node at closed end, antinode at open end
- Fundamental: L = λ/4, f₁ = v/4L
- Only odd harmonics: 1 : 3 : 5
- Lower fundamental for the same length
-
Open pipe (flute)
- Antinodes at both ends
- Fundamental: L = λ/2, f₁ = v/2L
- All harmonics: 1 : 2 : 3
- Fundamental twice that of a closed pipe of equal length
The resonance air column
This apparatus is a one-metre glass tube, open at the top and joined at the bottom by a rubber tube to a water reservoir, so the water level and hence the length of the air column can be adjusted. The water surface acts as the closed end. A vibrating tuning fork held over the open end sends sound down the tube; it reflects from the water and forms standing waves. When the air column's natural frequency matches the fork's, a loud sound is heard: resonance.
The antinode actually forms a small distance e above the open end, the end correction. So the first resonance occurs when λ/4 = L₁ + e, and the second when 3λ/4 = L₂ + e. Subtracting removes e: λ/2 = L₂ − L₁, so λ = 2(L₂ − L₁) and
Speed of sound: v = fλ = 2f(L₂ − L₁); end correction e = (L₂ − 3L₁)/2
Measuring the speed of sound with a resonance column
- Strike a tuning fork of known frequency f Hold it over the open end of the tube.
- Lower the water from the top Find the first loud resonance; note the column length L₁.
- Lower the water further Find the second resonance; note L₂.
- Calculate v = 2f(L₂ − L₁); e = (L₂ − 3L₁)/2.
The Doppler effect
A train whistle sounds higher in pitch as the train approaches and lower as it moves away. Whenever there is relative motion between a source of sound and a listener, the frequency heard differs from the frequency emitted. This is the Doppler effect, first studied by the Austrian physicist Christian Doppler (1803-1853). It occurs for all waves, including light.
Moving listener, stationary source. The source emits frequency f and wavelength λ = v/f, where v is the speed of sound in still air. A listener moving towards the source at v_L meets the waves at relative speed v + v_L, with λ unchanged, so f′ = (v + v_L)/λ = f (v + v_L)/v. Moving away, f′ = f (v − v_L)/v.
Moving source, stationary listener. In one period T = 1/f, a compression travels vT = λ while the source, moving towards the listener at v_S, moves v_S T. The compressions ahead are squeezed to λ′ = λ − v_S T = (v − v_S)/f. The listener hears f′ = v/λ′ = f v/(v − v_S). For a source moving away, f′ = f v/(v + v_S).
General formula: f′ = f (v + v_L)/(v − v_S), with v_L and v_S positive when each moves towards the other and negative when moving away
| Situation | Frequency heard |
|---|---|
| Listener moves towards stationary source | f (v + v_L)/v |
| Listener moves away from stationary source | f (v − v_L)/v |
| Source moves towards stationary listener | f v/(v − v_S) |
| Source moves away from stationary listener | f v/(v + v_S) |
| Source and listener move towards each other | f (v + v_L)/(v − v_S) |
| Source and listener move away from each other | f (v − v_L)/(v + v_S) |
| Source chases listener (source behind, both moving the same way) | f (v − v_L)/(v − v_S) |
| Listener chases source (listener behind, both moving the same way) | f (v + v_L)/(v + v_S) |
| Approaching each other, medium (wind) moving at v_m in the direction of sound | f (v + v_m + v_L)/(v + v_m − v_S) |
A moving listener changes the speed of the waves relative to the ear; a moving source changes their wavelength. That is why the effect in sound is asymmetric: a source approaching at a given speed and a listener approaching at the same speed give different frequencies, because sound travels relative to its medium. For light, which needs no medium, the effect is symmetric. If a source moves faster than sound, these formulas fail; a listener ahead hears nothing until the waves, piled up behind the source, arrive together as a sonic boom or shock wave.
Worked example 1: pipes
Take v = 340 m s⁻¹. (a) A closed pipe 25 cm long: f₁ = v/4L = 340/1.0 = 340 Hz; its overtones are 3f₁ = 1020 Hz and 5f₁ = 1700 Hz. (b) An open pipe 50 cm long: f₁ = v/2L = 340/1.0 = 340 Hz; its overtones are 680 Hz and 1020 Hz. The two pipes share a fundamental, but the open one is twice as long and has twice as many harmonics.
Worked example 2: resonance column
With a 512 Hz fork, the first and second resonances occur at 16.0 cm and 49.5 cm. Step 1: L₂ − L₁ = 33.5 cm = 0.335 m. Step 2: v = 2fΔL = 2 × 512 × 0.335 ≈ 343 m s⁻¹. Step 3: e = (L₂ − 3L₁)/2 = (49.5 − 48.0)/2 = 0.75 cm.
Worked example 3: a passing car's horn
A car horn of 500 Hz; sound travels at 340 m s⁻¹. (a) The car approaches a stationary listener at 20 m s⁻¹: f′ = 500 × 340/(340 − 20) = 500 × 340/320 ≈ 531 Hz. (b) The car moves away at 20 m s⁻¹: f′ = 500 × 340/360 ≈ 472 Hz. (c) The car is still and the listener drives towards it at 20 m s⁻¹: f′ = 500 × 360/340 ≈ 529 Hz, not quite the same as (a), showing the asymmetry. (d) Listener at 10 m s⁻¹ and car at 20 m s⁻¹ approach each other: f′ = 500 × (340 + 10)/(340 − 20) = 500 × 350/320 ≈ 547 Hz.
Key takeaways
- Closed pipe: f₁ = v/4L, odd harmonics only; open pipe: f₁ = v/2L, all harmonics.
- Resonance column: v = 2f(L₂ − L₁), e = (L₂ − 3L₁)/2.
- Doppler: f′ = f(v + v_L)/(v − v_S), speeds positive towards each other.
- The Doppler effect in sound is asymmetric because sound moves relative to its medium.
Check your understanding
-
1. A pipe closed at one end has a fundamental frequency of 200 Hz. Which of these frequencies can it NOT produce?
- 600 Hz
- 1000 Hz
- 1400 Hz
- 400 Hz
Show answer
Answer: D. A closed pipe produces only odd harmonics: 200, 600, 1000, 1400 Hz, .... 400 Hz is the second harmonic, an even one, so it is missing.
-
2. An open pipe and a closed pipe have the same length. The ratio of the fundamental frequency of the open pipe to that of the closed pipe is:
- 1 : 2
- 2 : 1
- 1 : 1
- 4 : 1
Show answer
Answer: B. Open: f = v/2L; closed: f = v/4L. Ratio = (v/2L)/(v/4L) = 2 : 1.
-
3. In a resonance column experiment with a 480 Hz fork, successive resonances occur at 17.0 cm and 52.5 cm. The speed of sound is about:
- 341 m s⁻¹
- 170 m s⁻¹
- 504 m s⁻¹
- 326 m s⁻¹
Show answer
Answer: A. v = 2f(L₂ − L₁) = 2 × 480 × (0.525 − 0.170) = 960 × 0.355 ≈ 341 m s⁻¹. Using f(L₂ − L₁) without the factor 2 gives 170 m s⁻¹.
-
4. A source of 660 Hz moves towards a stationary listener at 30 m s⁻¹. If sound travels at 330 m s⁻¹, the frequency heard is:
- 600 Hz
- 720 Hz
- 726 Hz
- 605 Hz
Show answer
Answer: C. f′ = f v/(v − v_S) = 660 × 330/300 = 726 Hz. Using the moving-listener formula, 660 × 360/330 = 720 Hz, is the wrong case; 605 Hz is for a source moving away.
-
5. Why is the Doppler effect for sound called asymmetric?
- Sound waves are longitudinal
- A moving source and a moving listener with the same speed give different frequencies, because sound travels relative to its medium
- The frequency heard is always lower than the source frequency
- It works only for approaching sources
Show answer
Answer: B. A moving listener changes the relative speed of the waves, while a moving source changes their wavelength. Because sound's speed is fixed relative to the medium, these two cases give different results even for the same relative speed.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.