• Practice
  • About 26 min
  • 5 practice questions

Second law of thermodynamics, heat engines, the Carnot engine and the refrigerator

State the Clausius and Kelvin-Planck forms of the second law, find heat-engine efficiency, follow the four steps of the Carnot cycle and derive η = 1 − T_L/T_H, explain entropy, and use the coefficient of performance of a refrigerator.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State the Clausius and Kelvin-Planck statements of the second law.
  • Describe the parts of a heat engine and calculate η = 1 − Q_L/Q_H.
  • Describe the four steps of the Carnot cycle and derive η = 1 − T_L/T_H.
  • Explain entropy and the second law in terms of entropy.
  • Calculate the coefficient of performance of a refrigerator.

A gas released from a bottle spreads through a room and never collects back into the bottle. A drop of ink spreads through water and never gathers again. A falling stone stops on hitting the ground, its energy shared among countless molecules, and never jumps back up. The first law would allow all these to run backwards; nature never does. The rule that sets the direction is the second law of thermodynamics.

The Clausius statement

Clausius statement of the second law: heat always flows spontaneously from a hotter object to a colder object, never the other way on its own. If 5 J flowed from cold to hot, total energy would still be conserved, so the first law does not forbid it; the second law does.

Heat engines

A reservoir is a system with such a large heat capacity that taking heat from it or giving heat to it does not change its temperature: a lake, or the atmosphere. A heat engine is a device that takes in heat and converts part of it into work by going through a cyclic process. It has three parts. (1) The hot reservoir or source, at a high temperature T_H, supplies heat Q_H. (2) The working substance (a gas, or water and steam) does the work; in an old steam locomotive, water is turned into steam by burning coal, and the steam drives the wheels. (3) The cold reservoir or sink, at a lower temperature T_L, receives the rejected heat Q_L; for a car this is the surrounding air, reached through the silencer.

After each cycle the working substance is back in its initial state, so ΔU = 0 and Q_H = W + Q_L, giving W = Q_H − Q_L (all three taken as positive amounts). The efficiency is the work output divided by the heat input: η = W/Q_H = 1 − Q_L/Q_H. Since Q_L is never zero, η is always less than 1. Kelvin-Planck statement: it is impossible to construct a heat engine that operates in a cycle and whose sole effect is to convert heat completely into work. (An isothermal expansion turns heat completely into work, but it is a single process, not a cycle, so there is no contradiction.)

Energy flow in a heat engine

  1. Hot reservoir at T_H Supplies heat Q_H to the working substance.
  2. Working substance in a cycle Converts part of Q_H into work W = Q_H − Q_L.
  3. Cold reservoir at T_L Receives the rejected heat Q_L.

Worked example 1: efficiency of an engine

In each cycle an engine absorbs 800 J from a hot reservoir and rejects 600 J to the surroundings. Step 1: W = Q_H − Q_L = 800 − 600 = 200 J. Step 2: η = W/Q_H = 200/800 = 0.25, or 25%. Three-quarters of the heat taken in is rejected.

Carnot's ideal engine

In 1824 the young French engineer Sadi Carnot showed that a certain reversible engine working between two temperatures has the greatest possible efficiency. The Carnot engine has: a source at constant T_H, from which any amount of heat can be drawn; a sink at constant T_L, which can absorb any amount of heat; an insulating stand; and the working substance, an ideal gas in a cylinder with perfectly insulating walls, a perfectly conducting bottom and an insulating, frictionless piston. The gas goes through four reversible, quasi-static steps, the Carnot cycle.

  1. A → B, isothermal expansion at T_H: the cylinder stands on the source; heat Q_H flows in and the gas expands slowly from V₁ to V₂. Q_H = W_AB = μRT_H ln(V₂/V₁).
  2. B → C, adiabatic expansion: the cylinder is moved to the insulating stand; the gas expands from V₂ to V₃ and cools from T_H to T_L. W_BC = μR(T_H − T_L)/(γ − 1).
  3. C → D, isothermal compression at T_L: the cylinder stands on the sink; the gas is compressed from V₃ to V₄ and heat Q_L = μRT_L ln(V₃/V₄) flows out to the sink. Work is done on the gas.
  4. D → A, adiabatic compression: on the insulating stand again, the gas is compressed back to V₁, warming from T_L to T_H. W_DA = −μR(T_H − T_L)/(γ − 1) = −W_BC.

The two adiabatic works cancel, so the net work per cycle is W = W_AB − |W_CD|, the area enclosed by ABCD on the PV diagram. Efficiency. η = 1 − Q_L/Q_H = 1 − [T_L ln(V₃/V₄)]/[T_H ln(V₂/V₁)]. The adiabatic steps give T_H V₂^(γ−1) = T_L V₃^(γ−1) and T_H V₁^(γ−1) = T_L V₄^(γ−1); dividing, (V₂/V₁)^(γ−1) = (V₃/V₄)^(γ−1), so V₂/V₁ = V₃/V₄ and the logarithms cancel. Hence Q_L/Q_H = T_L/T_H and η = 1 − T_L/T_H, with both temperatures in kelvin.

  • η < 1, because T_L > 0 K; 100% would need a sink at absolute zero, which cannot be reached.
  • η depends only on the two temperatures, not on the working substance.
  • If T_H = T_L, η = 0: no engine can run with source and sink at the same temperature.
  • Carnot's theorem: between two given reservoirs no engine is more efficient than a Carnot engine. Real petrol, diesel and steam engines are not reversible, so their efficiency is always lower.

Worked example 2: Carnot efficiencies

(a) Source 527 °C (800 K), sink 27 °C (300 K): η = 1 − 300/800 = 1 − 0.375 = 0.625, or 62.5% at most. (b) An engine works between 600 K and 300 K: η = 1 − 300/600 = 50%. Lowering the sink by 50 K to 250 K gives 1 − 250/600 = 58.3%; raising the source by 50 K to 650 K gives 1 − 300/650 = 53.8%. Lowering the sink helps more, because η depends on the ratio T_L/T_H, not on the difference.

Entropy and the second law

For the Carnot engine Q_H/T_H = Q_L/T_L. The quantity Q/T is the change in entropy, a state variable. The engine takes entropy Q_H/T_H from the source and gives Q_L/T_L to the sink; for a reversible engine these are equal, so the total entropy does not change. For real, irreversible engines Q_L/T_L > Q_H/T_H: entropy increases. Second law in terms of entropy: in every natural (irreversible) process the total entropy increases; in a reversible process it stays the same. Entropy is often called a measure of disorder: gas spread through a room, or ink spread through water, is more disordered than gas in a bottle or a single drop, and the reverse would lower entropy, so it does not happen. Heat flows from hot to cold because that flow increases the total entropy.

The refrigerator

A refrigerator is a heat engine run backwards. The working substance takes heat Q_L from the cold space inside (at T_L); a compressor does work W on it; and it rejects heat Q_H to the warmer kitchen (at T_H) through the coils at the back, which is why the air near them feels warm. By the first law, Q_L + W = Q_H. Its performance is measured by the coefficient of performance: β = Q_L/W = Q_L/(Q_H − Q_L) = 1/(Q_H/Q_L − 1). For an ideal (Carnot) refrigerator Q_H/Q_L = T_H/T_L, so β = T_L/(T_H − T_L). The textbook gives about 5 to 6 as a typical value. The smaller the temperature difference between inside and outside, the larger β. Heat moves from cold to hot only because work is done, and the entropy of the refrigerator plus its surroundings still increases, so the second law is obeyed.

Worked example 3: a refrigerator

An ideal refrigerator keeps its freezer at −13 °C (260 K) in a room at 27 °C (300 K). Step 1: β = T_L/(T_H − T_L) = 260/(300 − 260) = 260/40 = 6.5. Step 2: to remove 1300 J from the freezer, W = Q_L/β = 1300/6.5 = 200 J. Step 3: heat given to the room Q_H = Q_L + W = 1300 + 200 = 1500 J. A refrigerator with its door open therefore warms the kitchen.

Two notes. An earthen pot cools drinking water, but it is not a refrigerator: there is no cycle; the water cools because some of it seeps through the pores and evaporates, and the escaping vapour never returns. And the Earth stays warm because carbon dioxide and water vapour in the atmosphere absorb part of the infrared radiation the Earth gives off (the greenhouse effect); burning fossil fuels adds carbon dioxide and strengthens this effect, which leads to global warming.

Clausius: heat flows by itself only from hot to cold. Kelvin-Planck: no cyclic engine turns heat wholly into work. Engine: η = 1 − Q_L/Q_H; Carnot: η = 1 − T_L/T_H. Refrigerator: β = Q_L/W = T_L/(T_H − T_L) (ideal). Natural processes increase entropy.

Key takeaways

  • The second law gives the direction of natural processes, which the first law cannot.
  • A heat engine needs a source and a sink; some heat is always rejected.
  • The Carnot cycle is two isotherms and two adiabats; η = 1 − T_L/T_H is the upper limit for any engine.
  • Entropy increases in all natural processes and is unchanged in reversible ones.
  • A refrigerator moves heat from cold to hot using work; β = Q_L/W.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A heat engine takes 1000 J from its source and rejects 700 J to its sink in each cycle. Its efficiency is:

    1. 70%
    2. 43%
    3. 30%
    4. 100%
    Show answer

    Answer: C. η = 1 − Q_L/Q_H = 1 − 700/1000 = 0.30, or 30%. The work per cycle is 300 J.

  2. 2. The efficiency of a Carnot engine working between 127 °C and 27 °C is:

    1. 25%
    2. 79%
    3. 100%
    4. 21%
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Convert to kelvin: T_H = 400 K, T_L = 300 K. η = 1 − 300/400 = 0.25, or 25%. Using Celsius (1 − 27/127 ≈ 79%) is a common error.

  3. 3. Which statement is the Kelvin-Planck form of the second law?

    1. Energy can neither be created nor destroyed
    2. Heat flows only from cold to hot
    3. The entropy of a reversible engine always increases
    4. No engine working in a cycle can convert heat completely into work
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Kelvin-Planck: it is impossible to build a cyclic engine whose sole effect is to turn heat entirely into work. 'Energy can neither be created nor destroyed' is the first law; heat flows by itself from hot to cold (Clausius); and a reversible process leaves entropy unchanged.

  4. 4. An ideal refrigerator keeps its inside at 0 °C in a room at 27 °C. Its coefficient of performance is about:

    1. 0.10
    2. 10.1
    3. 1.1
    4. 27
    Show answer

    Answer: B. β = T_L/(T_H − T_L) = 273/(300 − 273) = 273/27 ≈ 10.1.

  5. 5. A refrigerator with a coefficient of performance of 4 removes 800 J of heat from its inside. The work done by its compressor is:

    1. 200 J
    2. 3200 J
    3. 800 J
    4. 1000 J
    Show answer

    Answer: A. β = Q_L/W, so W = Q_L/β = 800/4 = 200 J. The heat given to the room is Q_L + W = 1000 J.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery