• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

From politics to Political Science: growth of the discipline and its definitions

Explain why the name Political Science was preferred, follow its growth in the United States through behaviouralism and post-behaviouralism, and compare the main definitions.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain why scholars preferred the name Political Science to politics.
  • Trace the growth of the discipline in the United States, from institutions to behaviour.
  • Explain behaviouralism and post-behaviouralism and list the four principles of modern political analysis.
  • Compare definitions of Political Science that centre on the State, government, power and allocation.

Calling a subject a science is a claim about how it is studied. This lesson follows how the study of politics became a separate academic discipline with its own name, its own university departments and its own debates about method.

Why the name changed

In ancient Greece politics meant the affairs of the small city-state. Today, as the textbook notes from Gilchrist, the word politics usually means the current problems of government: a person interested in politics may be involved in elections, laws, labour issues and party work. Politics also differs from country to country. The study of these matters needs a separate name that means the same thing everywhere, so scholars preferred Political Science. Political scientists meeting in Paris in 1948 also found this term more acceptable. The textbook adds that the two words should not be treated as exact synonyms, though some still call the discipline politics.

Growth of the discipline in the United States

The major developments after Political Science became a distinct discipline took place in the United States. Before that it was part of philosophy, law and economics. The textbook dates it as an autonomous discipline to 1880, when John W. Burgess set up a School of Political Science at Columbia University; by the 1920s most leading universities had separate departments. Early work was formal and centred on institutions, and this lasted till about the Second World War. Scholars such as Woodrow Wilson and Frank Goodnow urged the study of social facts rather than static institutions; Arthur Bentley tried to build an objective, value-free analysis; and in the 1920s the University of Chicago, led by Charles E. Merriam, pushed for observation and measurement. Merriam's Political Power and Lasswell's Politics: Who Gets What, When, How made power the central theme.

Stages in the growth of Political Science

  1. Part of other subjects Philosophy, law, history and economics.
  2. Autonomous discipline (1880) Burgess's School of Political Science at Columbia; separate departments by the 1920s.
  3. Institutional phase Formal study of constitutions and institutions, up to the Second World War.
  4. Behaviouralism Study of parties, pressure groups, elites and voting behaviour; objective, measured methods.
  5. Post-behaviouralism (1960s) Relevance over precision; research need not be value-free.

Behaviouralism and post-behaviouralism

The totalitarian regimes of the 1920s and 1930s and the Second World War turned scholars away from institutions and procedures towards political parties, pressure groups, elites and the basis of electoral choices. This focus on behaviour was called behaviouralism, a term borrowed from behaviourism in psychology. In the 1960s came post-behaviouralism, a reaction against the dominance of behavioural methods. The textbook notes the irony that its call was given by David Easton, himself a leading behaviouralist. He argued that behavioural research had lost touch with reality; post-behaviouralists said research need not always be value-free and that relevance matters more than precision. Scholars also drew on sociology, anthropology and psychology, and criticised earlier theorists for studying only formal structures while ignoring how people actually behave.

  1. The search for comprehensive scope
  2. The search for realism
  3. The search for precision
  4. The search for intellectual order

These are the four principles on which, according to the textbook, modern political analysis came to rest.

Definitions of Political Science

Definitions grouped by their focus (paraphrased)
FocusScholarsIdea
The StateGarner; Garris; LaskiPolitical Science begins and ends with the State; it studies the origin, growth and problems of the State and human life in organised states.
GovernmentLeacock; SeeleyIt investigates government, as biology studies life or geometry studies space.
PowerRobson; LasswellIt is the study of power and influence, of how power is shaped and shared.
TimeGettelIt studies the past historically, the present analytically and the future ethically.
AllocationDavid EastonIt studies how scarce human, economic and spiritual resources are allocated within a community to meet human needs.

Some scholars define it simply as the study of the political aspects of organised human society, but the textbook warns that this makes the scope so wide that it includes almost everything. Through most of history the stress was on the State, its institutions, laws and processes; political behaviour joined after the behavioural revolution, and the most recent addition is governance.

State, then government, then power and behaviour, then governance: the focus of Political Science has widened over time.

— Summary to remember

Worked example 1: placing a study

A researcher surveys 2,000 voters (made-up figure) to find how age and income affect whom they vote for. Which phase of the discipline does this belong to? Reasoning: it ignores constitutions and studies electoral choices using measurement. That is the focus that grew after the 1920s-30s and was called behaviouralism. Answer: behaviouralism.

Worked example 2: matching a definition

Statement: 'We study the past to know how institutions grew, the present to understand how they work, and the future to ask how they should be.' Whose definition is this closest to? Reasoning: it divides the subject into historical, analytical and ethical study across time. Answer: Gettel.

Key takeaways: the name Political Science separates the study of politics from day-to-day political activity. The discipline became autonomous in the United States from 1880, moved from institutions to behaviour, and in the 1960s post-behaviouralism stressed relevance. Definitions focus on the State, government, power or allocation; governance is the latest addition.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. According to the textbook, Political Science as an autonomous discipline dates back to 1880, when:

    1. The American Political Science Association was founded
    2. John W. Burgess established a School of Political Science at Columbia University
    3. Political scientists met in Paris
    4. Charles E. Merriam wrote Political Power
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook links 1880 with Burgess's school at Columbia. The Association came in 1903 and the Paris meeting in 1948.

  2. 2. Which pair of ideas best describes post-behaviouralism?

    1. Value-free research and precision above all
    2. Study of formal institutions only
    3. Relevance over precision, and research need not be value-free
    4. Politics as the affairs of the city-state
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Post-behaviouralism reacted against behavioural orthodoxy, saying research had lost touch with reality; it put relevance before precision and accepted that research may carry values.

  3. 3. Who gave the call for post-behaviouralism, though he had been a leading supporter of behaviouralism?

    1. David Easton
    2. Woodrow Wilson
    3. John W. Burgess
    4. Harold Laski
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook notes the irony that David Easton, an advocate of the behavioural revolution, called for post-behaviouralism in the 1960s.

  4. 4. Which is NOT one of the four principles of modern political analysis listed in the textbook?

    1. The search for realism
    2. The search for precision
    3. The search for intellectual order
    4. The search for a single universal law of politics
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The four principles are comprehensive scope, realism, precision and intellectual order. A single universal law is not among them; the textbook later says Political Science has no universal laws like natural science.

  5. 5. For Garner, Political Science 'begins and ends with' which of the following?

    1. Power
    2. The State
    3. Government
    4. Governance
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says that for Garner Political Science begins and ends with the State. Leacock and Seeley stress government, and Robson and Lasswell stress power.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Nature and scope of Political Science

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery