- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Modern approaches and the relationship with other social sciences
Explain the sociological, psychological, economic, behavioural and Marxist approaches with their criticisms, and relate Political Science to history, economics, ethics, sociology, psychology and public administration.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe the five modern approaches, their exponents and criticisms.
- Explain how Political Science is related to history, economics, ethics, sociology, psychology and public administration.
- Interpret the sayings of Freeman, Seeley and Barker on these relationships.
- Sum up what makes Political Science distinct among social sciences.
The traditional approaches asked what the State ought to be. In the 20th century scholars began to look outward, to society, the mind, the economy and observed behaviour. This lesson covers those modern approaches, and then shows how Political Science borrows from and gives to its neighbouring subjects.
The modern approaches
| Approach | Main idea | Exponents | Criticism |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sociological | Explains political behaviour through its social context; the State is a social organism | MacIver, Gabriel Almond | Too much stress on society can weaken the autonomy of Political Science |
| Psychological | Explains political and social institutions through psychological laws; studies the minds of leaders | Graham Wallas, David Truman | Ignores sociological, legal and economic factors |
| Economic | The State regulates production and distribution, so economic life is tied to politics | Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels | Considers only economic factors and ignores social and psychological ones |
| Behavioural | Studies the attitudes and preferences of people in political situations, moving away from formal and normative study | David Easton, Robert A. Dahl | Rests on a false idea of scientific method |
| Marxist | The State is an inevitable result of class contradictions; political and economic forces cannot be separated | V. I. Lenin, Antonio Gramsci | Gives undue weight to economic factors |
The textbook describes the Marxist approach as basically different from the other modern approaches, because it treats the State itself as a product of class conflict. Its overall verdict is that each approach has its own relevance and its own limitations; no single approach explains every political event.
Political Science and other social sciences
Political Science and its neighbours
-
History
- Institutions grow slowly over time
- History supplies facts for general principles
-
Economics
- Once called Political Economy
- Both aim at the best possible life
-
Ethics
- Science of moral order vs science of political order
- Both aim at a noble, righteous life
-
Sociology
- Origin and evolution of State and institutions
- Social needs shape policy
-
Psychology
- Why people and groups behave as they do
- Behaviour of parties and groups
-
Public Administration
- Political Science: policy formulation
- Public Administration: policy implementation
History. The State and its institutions are products of slow historical growth, and Political Science uses historical facts to find general principles. Political history is the narrative of political events and movements. Freeman summed up the link by calling history past politics and politics present history; John Seeley added that history without Political Science bears no fruit, and Political Science without history has no root.
Economics. Economics was once treated as a branch of Political Science, and the textbook notes that the Greeks called the subject Political Economy. Political economy studies how political institutions, the political environment and the economy influence one another; groups with shared economic interests use politics to win changes in their favour. Both subjects aim at the best possible life for people.
Ethics. Ethics deals with morality and the rules of good conduct. The textbook calls ethics the science of moral order and Political Science the science of political order; both aim at a noble and righteous human life.
Sociology. Sociology supplies basic information on how the State and political institutions began and evolved. Political Science is also called a policy science, and State policy cannot be made without studying people's social needs. In return, Political Science tells sociology how the State is organised and how its policies affect society.
Psychology. Psychology studies all human behaviour; Political Science studies only political behaviour. Psychology helps explain why parties and groups act as they do. Barker remarked that applying psychology to human puzzles had become the fashion, and that where earlier thinkers thought biologically, his age thought psychologically.
Public Administration. Here 'public' mainly means government, though non-governmental organisations are also studied. Political Science deals with forming policy, Public Administration with implementing it, and both aim at the best use of resources and social welfare.
Political Science borrows heavily from the other social sciences, but its focus on power sets it apart.
The textbook's closing summary describes Political Science as the systematic study of governance using empirical and scientific methods. It rarely produces precise predictions. It examines the State and its organs, and the social, cultural, economic and psychological factors that influence government; it also covers comparative politics, international relations, political theory, public law and public policy. Above all it helps citizens understand the political process and how government affects their lives.
Worked example 1: choosing an approach
A researcher explains a leader's decisions by studying the leader's childhood, fears and ambitions. Reasoning: the explanation rests on the mind of a leader, using psychological laws. Answer: the psychological approach. A critic would say it ignores the legal, social and economic setting in which the leader acted.
Worked example 2: formulation or implementation?
A state legislature debates and passes a law to provide free bicycles to school students; district officers then buy the bicycles and distribute them in schools. Reasoning: the debate and decision are policy formulation, studied by Political Science; buying and distributing are implementation, studied by Public Administration. Answer: the first stage belongs to Political Science, the second to Public Administration.
Key takeaways: the modern approaches are sociological, psychological, economic, behavioural and Marxist; each has a limitation, and none is complete alone. Political Science is closely related to history, economics, ethics, sociology, psychology and public administration, but its focus on power marks it out.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which approach sees the State as an inevitable consequence of class contradictions?
- Sociological approach
- Behavioural approach
- Marxist approach
- Institutional approach
Show answer
Answer: C. The Marxist approach, with exponents such as Lenin and Gramsci, treats the State as a product of class contradictions and holds that political and economic forces cannot be separated.
-
2. 'History is past politics and politics is present history' is a saying of:
- John Seeley
- Barker
- Harold Lasswell
- Freeman
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook attributes this saying to Freeman. Seeley's saying is about fruit and root.
-
3. Which statement correctly distinguishes Political Science from Public Administration, as the textbook describes them?
- Political Science deals with policy formulation; Public Administration with implementation
- Political Science deals with implementation; Public Administration with formulation
- Both deal only with non-governmental organisations
- Public Administration studies only ethics
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook says Public Administration is the implementation of government policies, while Political Science deals with how policy is formulated.
-
4. Which pair are named in the textbook as exponents of the behavioural approach?
- Graham Wallas and David Truman
- David Easton and Robert A. Dahl
- MacIver and Gabriel Almond
- Cicero and John Austin
Show answer
Answer: B. Easton and Dahl are named for the behavioural approach. Wallas and Truman are psychological, MacIver and Almond sociological, and Cicero and Austin legal.
-
5. According to the textbook, what most distinguishes Political Science from the other social sciences it borrows from?
- Its use of laboratory experiments
- Its focus on power
- Its study of all human behaviour
- Its refusal to use history
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says Political Science borrows heavily from other social sciences but its focus on power differentiates it. Psychology, not Political Science, studies all human behaviour.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.