• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Is Political Science a science or an art? The traditional approaches

Weigh the arguments on whether Political Science is a science or an art, and explain the philosophical, historical, legal and institutional approaches with their criticisms.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Give the arguments for treating Political Science as an art and as a science, with the thinkers on each side.
  • Use Garner's definition of science to reach a balanced conclusion.
  • Explain what an approach is and how traditional approaches differ from modern ones.
  • Describe the four traditional approaches, their exponents and their weaknesses.

Physics can predict where a ball will land. Can Political Science predict how a nation will vote or whether a government will fall? The answer decides whether the word science in its name is deserved. The textbook treats this as a debate with good points on both sides.

The case that it is an art, not a science

Writers such as Auguste Comte and Maitland argued that social sciences lack a scientific character; some even called Political Science one of the most backward of the arts. Their reasons, as the textbook gives them:

  • Experts do not agree on its nature, methods and approaches.
  • It lacks continuity of development and a basis for precision.
  • It has no universal principles, and observation and experiment as used in laboratories may not apply.
  • Reliability, verifiability, precision and accuracy found in natural sciences are missing.
  • It does not strictly follow cause and effect, and lacks the exactness of physics and chemistry.

The case that it is a science

On the other side, Aristotle was the first to call it a supreme science, and Bodin, Hobbes, Montesquieu and Bluntschli agreed that it is the science of State and government. Dr. Garner defined science as knowledge of a subject gained by systematic study, observation or experience. By that test Political Science qualifies, because its conclusions come from systematic study. The textbook gives its own example: after systematic study of forms of government in ancient, medieval and modern times, it states that democracy is the form best suited to plural societies and to promoting social welfare. It also notes that all political scientists agree that imperialism, colonialism, inequality, illiteracy and poverty harm society, and that some political events do have causes and effects: poverty and unemployment, for instance, can lead to revolution.

Science or art? The two sides

  • An art (Comte, Maitland)
    • No agreement on methods
    • No universal laws
    • Laboratory experiments rarely possible
    • Weak cause and effect, no exact prediction
  • A science (Aristotle, Bodin, Hobbes, Montesquieu, Bluntschli, Garner)
    • Knowledge from systematic study and observation
    • Some proven conclusions
    • Some clear causes and effects
    • Agreement on major social harms

Conclusion in the textbook: Political Science cannot be equated with the natural sciences, but it is a social science dealing with individuals and their relation to the State and government. Whether it looks more like an art or a science depends on the subject matter chosen and the approach used. The textbook also notes that the name Political Science became popular after American scholars brought in empirical methods, yet it cannot claim the status of a pure science like physics, because it deals with human behaviour.

What an approach is

An approach is a way of looking at a political phenomenon and then explaining it. The textbook divides approaches into traditional ones, which are speculative and normative (concerned with what ought to be), and modern ones, which are empirical and scientific (concerned with what is, as observed).

The four traditional approaches
ApproachMain ideaExponents named in the textbookCriticism
Philosophical (speculative, metaphysical or ethical)The oldest approach; studies State and government in search of goals, morals and truths, close to ethicsPlato, Aristotle, Leo StraussToo speculative and abstract
HistoricalTraces the origin and growth of institutions and the role of individuals in the past; uses historical parallels to understand todayMachiavelli, SabineParallels can mislead because resemblances may be superficial
LegalSees the State mainly as a body that makes and enforces law; studies legal and judicial institutionsCicero, Jean Bodin, John AustinNarrow: the State does far more than keep law and order, and law covers only one part of life
Institutional (structural)Studies formal structures such as legislature, executive and judiciary, plus informal ones, and compares governmentsHarold Laski, Arthur Bentley, James BryceStresses structures and ignores the role of the individual

Traditional approaches ask what ought to be (normative); modern approaches ask what is, as observed (empirical).

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: testing a claim with Garner's definition

Claim: 'Political Science is not a science because it cannot do laboratory experiments.' Reasoning: under Garner's definition, science is knowledge gained by systematic study, observation or experience, not only by experiment. Political scientists observe many governments over long periods and draw tested conclusions. So the claim uses too narrow a definition. But the critics' point stands that the subject lacks exact prediction. Answer: by Garner's definition it is a science, though a social science and not an exact one.

Worked example 2: naming the approach

A scholar studies how the office of a monarch's chief adviser developed over centuries and asks what this suggests for present-day cabinets. Reasoning: the study traces the origin and development of an institution and draws parallels with the present. Answer: the historical approach; the critic would warn that the parallel with modern cabinets may be only superficial.

Key takeaways: critics such as Comte and Maitland deny Political Science scientific status; Aristotle, Bodin, Hobbes, Montesquieu, Bluntschli and Garner defend it. The balanced view is that it is a social science. Traditional approaches (philosophical, historical, legal, institutional) are normative; each has a recognised weakness.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who, according to the textbook, was the first to call Political Science a 'supreme science'?

    1. Auguste Comte
    2. Maitland
    3. Aristotle
    4. John Austin
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Aristotle called it the supreme science. Comte and Maitland are on the other side of the debate, and Austin is an exponent of the legal approach.

  2. 2. Garner defines science as knowledge gained by:

    1. Laboratory experiments alone
    2. Systematic study, observation or experience
    3. Religious revelation
    4. Agreement among all experts
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Garner's definition is knowledge relating to a subject gained by systematic study, observation or experience. On that basis Political Science can be called a science.

  3. 3. Which approach is criticised for being too narrow because the State does much more than enforce law?

    1. Philosophical approach
    2. Historical approach
    3. Institutional approach
    4. Legal approach
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The legal approach sees the State mainly as a maker and enforcer of law; critics say law deals with only one part of life and the State has many other functions.

  4. 4. The oldest approach to the study of politics, also called speculative, metaphysical or ethical, is the:

    1. Philosophical approach
    2. Behavioural approach
    3. Legal approach
    4. Sociological approach
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The philosophical approach is the oldest; it links the study of the State with the search for goals, morals and truths. Plato, Aristotle and Leo Strauss are its named exponents.

  5. 5. The textbook gives which example of cause and effect in politics?

    1. Higher literacy causes lower rainfall
    2. Poverty and unemployment can lead to revolution
    3. Elections cause earthquakes
    4. Laws cause population growth
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The textbook says that although Political Science does not strictly follow cause and effect, poverty and unemployment can result in revolution.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery