- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Electoral reforms, anti-defection law, state funding and NOTA
Name the committees on electoral reform and the main reforms made, explain the anti-defection law, the Indrajit Gupta Committee's idea of state funding, NOTA, and the difference between open and secret ballots.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Name the committees on electoral reform and list major reforms such as the 61st Amendment.
- Explain the anti-defection law: disqualification, exceptions, deciding authority and evaluation.
- Explain state funding of elections, NOTA, negative voting under Rule 49(O), and open versus secret ballot.
The challenges in lesson 4 led to many proposals for change. This lesson covers the reforms that followed, the law against defection, the idea of state funding and the voter's right to reject all candidates.
Committees on electoral reform
| Committee or report | Year (textbook) |
|---|---|
| Tarkunde Committee | 1974 |
| Dinesh Goswami Committee | 1990 |
| Vohra Committee | 1993 |
| Indrajit Gupta Committee | 1998 |
| Law Commission of India Report | 1999 |
| National Commission (Venkatachaliah) | 2002 |
| Election Commission of India Report | 2004 |
| Veerappa Moily Commission | 2007 |
| Tanka Committee | 2010 |
Some reforms introduced
- Voting age lowered from 21 to 18 by the 61st Amendment Act, 1988.
- 1989: provision for electronic voting machines and for adjourning the poll in case of booth capturing.
- Proposers for nomination raised to 10% of the electors or 10 electors, whichever is less; candidates listed as recognised-party, registered-unrecognised-party and independent.
- No sale of liquor in a polling area for 48 hours ending with the close of poll; a paid holiday for voters on polling day; prohibition of arms.
- If a contesting candidate of a party dies, the party may propose another within 7 days.
- 1999: postal ballot for certain classes of persons; 2003: proxy voting for service voters of the armed forces.
- 2003: declaration of criminal antecedents and assets; Rajya Sabha reforms (domicile requirement removed, open ballot introduced).
- 2009: restrictions on exit polls; 2010: voting rights for citizens living abroad; 2011: ceiling on election expenditure raised.
The anti-defection law
The 52nd Amendment Act, 1985 added the Tenth Schedule to the Constitution to disqualify members of Parliament and state legislatures who defect from one party to another.
The Tenth Schedule at a glance
-
Disqualification
- A party member who voluntarily gives up membership
- Or votes or abstains against the party's direction without prior permission
- An independent who joins a party after election
- A nominated member who joins a party after six months
-
Exceptions
- Merger of the party with another party
- A member elected Presiding Officer who leaves the party, and may rejoin after leaving office
-
Deciding authority
- The Presiding Officer of the House
-
Rule-making
- The Presiding Officer frames rules, laid before the House for 30 days
The 91st Amendment Act, 2003 changed the law on splits. Note for exam answers: the established position is that this amendment removed the exception for a split (one-third of a legislature party), so a split no longer protects members; only a merger supported by two-thirds of the legislature party is exempt. (The textbook's sentence on this point is worded differently; check it with your teacher.)
Evaluation, as the textbook gives it: the law is designed to prevent defections motivated by the lure of office or material benefit; to strengthen parliamentary democracy by curbing unprincipled defections; to give greater stability by checking legislators' tendency to change parties; to allow democratic realignment through mergers; and to give clear constitutional recognition to political parties.
State funding of elections
State funding means paying for elections from public money instead of private donations, to reduce corruption. The Indrajit Gupta Committee (1998) supported it in principle, so that parties with modest means could compete with richer ones, with two limits: funds only for recognised national and state parties, not independents; and, in the short term, funding in kind (facilities), not cash. The textbook also reports its proposal of a separate Election Fund, and that parties should have filed income tax returns to be eligible.
NOTA and the secret ballot
Before NOTA, a voter who wished to reject all candidates used Rule 49(O) of the Conduct of Election Rules, 1961: he entered his serial number in Form 17A and recorded a negative vote, so the choice was not secret. The Supreme Court (in 2013) upheld the right to reject all candidates and directed that 'None Of The Above' (NOTA) be placed as the last option on electronic voting machines. An open ballot is voting in public, for example by raising hands; a secret ballot is voting that no one else sees, in a ballot box or on an EVM.
Worked example 1: does the member lose the seat?
(a) A made-up MLA elected as an independent joins a party a year later: disqualified, since independents may not join a party after election. (b) A member votes against his party's direction without permission: disqualified (subject to the party's power to condone, which the Tenth Schedule also allows). (c) A member elected Speaker gives up party membership: not disqualified, an exception.
Worked example 2: why NOTA protects secrecy
Under 49(O) a voter's rejection was recorded in a register, so officials knew who rejected. With NOTA on the EVM the rejection is pressed like any other choice, so it stays secret. That is why the textbook calls NOTA a step towards electoral reform.
52nd Amendment (1985): Tenth Schedule, anti-defection. 61st Amendment (1988): voting age 21 to 18. Article 324: Election Commission.
Key takeaways: many committees from Tarkunde (1974) to Tanka (2010) shaped reforms such as the 18-year voting age, EVMs and disclosure of candidates' records. The Tenth Schedule disqualifies defectors, with the Presiding Officer deciding. The Indrajit Gupta Committee backed limited state funding. NOTA lets a voter reject all candidates in secret.
Check your understanding
-
1. The voting age in India was lowered from 21 to 18 by the:
- 42nd Amendment
- 73rd Amendment
- 61st Amendment
- 91st Amendment
Show answer
Answer: C. The 61st Amendment Act of 1988 lowered the voting age from 21 to 18.
-
2. Under the anti-defection law, who decides questions of disqualification on the ground of defection?
- The Presiding Officer of the House
- The Election Commission
- The President
- The Supreme Court in the first instance
Show answer
Answer: A. The Tenth Schedule makes the Presiding Officer (Speaker or Chairman) the deciding authority.
-
3. A nominated member of a House becomes disqualified if he joins a political party:
- on the day he takes his seat
- after six months from taking his seat
- only after one year
- at any time
Show answer
Answer: B. A nominated member may join a party within six months of taking his seat; joining after six months leads to disqualification.
-
4. Which committee (1998) supported state funding of elections in principle?
- Tarkunde Committee
- Vohra Committee
- Tanka Committee
- Indrajit Gupta Committee
Show answer
Answer: D. The Indrajit Gupta Committee on State Funding of Elections, 1998, backed the idea, with limits such as funding in kind to recognised parties only.
-
5. What was the main weakness of negative voting under Rule 49(O) that NOTA removed?
- It could be used only in Rajya Sabha elections
- The voter's rejection was recorded openly, so it was not secret
- It counted as a vote for the winner
- It required the voter to be 25 years old
Show answer
Answer: B. Under 49(O) the voter wrote his serial number in Form 17A, so the rejection was known. NOTA on the EVM keeps it secret.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.