• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Free and fair elections and the Election Commission of India

Explain why free and fair elections matter and the challenges they face, and describe the Election Commission's constitutional basis, structure, powers and the officers who run elections on the ground.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain the textbook's idea of free and fair elections and list the challenges it identifies.
  • Describe Article 324, the structure of the Election Commission and its main powers and functions.
  • Name the officers from the Chief Electoral Officer to the Presiding Officer and say what each does.

The textbook calls the ability to ensure a free and fair electoral process the true test of any election system. For democracy to be real on the ground, the system must be impartial and transparent, so that the voter's wishes find legitimate expression in the result.

How fair are Indian elections?

The textbook's judgement is that elections in India are basically free and fair: the party that forms the government does so because people chose it, and the overall verdict reflects popular preference, even if a few candidates win in some places by money power or unfair means. It then lists challenges that it says are found in many established democracies too:

  • Candidates and parties with a lot of money enjoy a big and unfair advantage over smaller parties and independents.
  • Candidates with criminal connections have pushed others out and secured tickets from major parties.
  • Some families dominate parties, and tickets go to relatives.
  • Elections sometimes offer little real choice when the major parties are alike in policy and practice.
  • Smaller parties and independents suffer a huge disadvantage.

Hence citizens and organisations demand reforms. The textbook links this to the right to know: Article 19(1)(a) guarantees freedom of speech and expression, and casting a vote is the voter's expression, so the voter must have information about candidates in order to avoid electing law-breakers as law-makers.

The Election Commission of India

Article 324 provides for a single Election Commission entrusted with the superintendence, direction and control of all elections to Parliament, the state legislatures, and the offices of the President and Vice-President. Its purpose is a permanent, independent election machinery, free from pressure by the party in power or the executive of the day.

Structure of the Election Commission
FeatureAs described in the textbook
CompositionA multi-member body: the Chief Election Commissioner and two other Election Commissioners
AppointmentBy the President of India
Term6 years or until 65 years of age, whichever is earlier
RemovalThe Chief Election Commissioner only in the manner of a Supreme Court judge (the book calls it impeachment); other Commissioners only on the recommendation of the Chief Election Commissioner

Powers and functions

  • Preparing and revising electoral rolls; allotting seats; conducting elections and controlling all matters relating to them.
  • Recognising political parties and allotting symbols; deciding symbol disputes when a party splits.
  • Advising the President or the Governor on electoral matters, including disqualification of members; settling disputes referred by them.
  • Fixing ceilings on election expenses; collecting affidavits on candidates' assets; disqualifying a candidate who fails to file election expense returns in time.
  • Issuing a notification after the election that the House is duly constituted.

The officers in the field

From the Commission to the polling booth

  1. Election Commission of India Superintendence, direction and control
  2. Chief Electoral Officer (CEO) Supervises election work in a state or union territory
  3. District Election Officer (DEO) Supervises election work in a district
  4. Returning Officer (RO) Conducts the election in a parliamentary or assembly constituency
  5. Presiding Officer (PO) With polling officers, conducts the poll at a polling station

Beside this chain, the Electoral Registration Officer (ERO) prepares the electoral roll for a constituency, and Election Observers (general and expenditure observers), who are government officers nominated by the Commission, report directly to it. The DEO appoints presiding and polling officers (in union territories, the returning officer does).

Worked example 1: who is responsible?

(a) A voter's name is missing from the roll of her assembly constituency: the Electoral Registration Officer prepares that roll. (b) Ballots at one polling station must be sealed at the close of poll: the Presiding Officer. (c) The result of a Lok Sabha constituency is declared: the Returning Officer, who conducts the election in that constituency.

Worked example 2: a landmark verdict

The textbook reports that on 10 July 2013 the Supreme Court held that sitting MPs, MLAs and MLCs convicted of offences are disqualified at once, and struck down Section 8(4) of the Representation of the People Act, which had given convicted members three months to appeal. Reasoning: this removed a protection that applied only to sitting members, supporting the aim of keeping law-breakers out of law-making.

Article 324: one independent Election Commission, with superintendence, direction and control of elections to Parliament, state legislatures, and the offices of President and Vice-President.

— Key idea, in our own words

The textbook also recalls India's first general election of 1951-52, held over about four months between October 1951 and February 1952, which elected the first Lok Sabha.

Key takeaways: free and fair elections are the test of an electoral system; India's are basically fair but face money power, criminalisation, family domination and disadvantages for small parties. Article 324 creates an independent, multi-member Election Commission with wide powers, which works through CEOs, DEOs, ROs, EROs, presiding officers and observers.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which Article provides for the Election Commission of India?

    1. Article 324
    2. Article 326
    3. Article 352
    4. Article 280
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 324 vests superintendence, direction and control of elections in the Election Commission. Article 326 is about adult suffrage.

  2. 2. The Chief Election Commissioner is appointed by:

    1. the Prime Minister
    2. the Chief Justice of India
    3. the President of India
    4. the Lok Sabha Speaker
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The textbook states that the Chief Election Commissioner and other Commissioners are appointed by the President of India.

  3. 3. Which officer conducts the election in a parliamentary or assembly constituency?

    1. Presiding Officer
    2. Returning Officer
    3. Electoral Registration Officer
    4. Election Observer
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Returning Officer is responsible for conducting the election in the constituency. The Presiding Officer runs a single polling station.

  4. 4. The textbook links a voter's right to information about candidates with which provision?

    1. Article 21
    2. Article 14
    3. Article 32
    4. Article 19(1)(a)
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Casting a vote is treated as the voter's expression under Article 19(1)(a), freedom of speech and expression, so information about candidates is necessary.

  5. 5. Which of these is NOT among the challenges to Indian elections listed in the textbook?

    1. Advantage of candidates with a lot of money
    2. Domination of parties by some families
    3. Use of a single voters' list for all citizens
    4. Disadvantage faced by smaller parties and independents
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A common voters' list is a strength, not a challenge. Money power, family domination and the handicap of small parties are all on the textbook's list.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery