- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Electoral systems and minority representation
Explain the five plurality/majority systems, the methods of minority representation, why India adopted First Past The Post, and how the quota is worked out in a Rajya Sabha election.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Describe FPTP, Block Vote, Party Block Vote, Alternative Vote and the Two-Round System.
- Name the five methods of minority representation listed in the textbook.
- Give the textbook's reasons for India's choice of FPTP and calculate a Rajya Sabha quota.
Votes do not turn into seats by magic. An electoral system is the set of rules that translates votes into elected representatives. Two countries with the same votes could get very different parliaments simply because they count differently. This lesson follows the textbook's survey of the main systems.
Plurality/majority systems
The principle is simple: after the votes are counted, the candidates or parties with the most votes win. The textbook identifies five varieties.
| System | How it works | Where the textbook says it is used |
|---|---|---|
| First Past The Post (FPTP) | Single-member districts; voters vote for candidates; the candidate with more votes than any other wins, even without an absolute majority. | UK and countries influenced by Britain, such as India, Canada and the USA |
| Block Vote (BV) | Multi-member districts; each voter has as many votes as there are seats and usually votes for candidates; the highest totals win. | Countries with weak or no parties, such as Kuwait, Laos and the Maldives |
| Party Block Vote (PBV) | Multi-member districts; the voter casts one vote for a party, not for candidates; it can carry a mixed slate to help minority representation. | Djibouti, Singapore, Senegal, Tunisia |
| Alternative Vote (AV) | Single-member districts; voters number candidates in order of preference (preferential voting); ballots are transferred until someone wins. | Australia, Fiji, Papua New Guinea |
| Two-Round System (TRS) | If no candidate gets the required level (usually 50% plus one) in round one, a second round is held, often a week or a fortnight later. | Common for direct election of Presidents; for example Iran and Mali |
FPTP: the candidate with the most votes wins, even without an absolute majority (more than half of the valid votes).
Worked example 1: who wins under FPTP?
A made-up constituency has 1,00,000 valid votes: Arul 38,000, Bhavani 35,000, Chandran 27,000. Check: 38,000 + 35,000 + 27,000 = 1,00,000. Under FPTP Arul wins with the largest number, although 38% is less than half. Under a Two-Round System nobody has crossed 50% plus one (50,001 votes), so Arul and Bhavani would face a second round.
Methods of minority representation
A pure majority rule can shut out smaller groups. The textbook lists five methods used to give minorities a voice:
Methods of minority representation
- Limited vote system
- Cumulative vote system
- Separate electorate system
- Joint electorate with reservation of seats
- Proportional representation
India uses the joint electorate with reservation of seats: all voters of a reserved constituency vote together, but only candidates from the reserved group may contest (lesson 3).
Why did India adopt FPTP?
- Simplicity: the system is easy to understand even for voters with no special knowledge of politics.
- Clear choice: voters simply endorse a candidate or a party, and can weigh the two as they wish.
- A local representative: unlike party-list proportional systems, each area has one member whom voters know and can hold accountable.
- Stable government: the largest party or coalition usually gets some bonus seats beyond its vote share, which helps parliamentary government function smoothly.
- Social coalitions: it encourages voters of different social groups to come together to win in a locality.
Rajya Sabha: the transferable vote
Members of the Rajya Sabha are elected by the elected MLAs of each state, who rank candidates by preference (the single transferable vote). A candidate must reach a quota:
Quota = (total valid votes ÷ (number of seats to be filled + 1)) + 1
Worked example 2: working out a quota
The textbook uses an illustration of 200 MLAs electing 4 members. Step 1: seats + 1 = 4 + 1 = 5. Step 2: 200 ÷ 5 = 40. Step 3: 40 + 1 = 41. A candidate needs 41 first-preference (or transferred) votes. Check: four candidates with 41 each use 164 votes; a fifth could have at most 200 − 164 = 36, below the quota, so only four can reach it. If not enough candidates reach the quota on first preferences, the lowest candidate is eliminated and those ballots go to the second preferences, until all seats are filled.
Key takeaways: plurality/majority systems award seats to whoever has the most votes; FPTP needs only a plurality, TRS usually demands an absolute majority, AV uses preferences. Minority representation can be secured by five methods; India uses joint electorates with reserved seats. India chose FPTP for its simplicity, clear choice, local accountability and stability.
Check your understanding
-
1. Under FPTP the winning candidate is the one who:
- gets an absolute majority of votes
- gets more votes than any other candidate
- is first in the party list
- wins in two rounds
Show answer
Answer: B. FPTP needs only a plurality: more votes than any rival, even if that is below half of the valid votes.
-
2. Which system is also called 'preferential voting', with voters numbering candidates in order?
- Party Block Vote
- Block Vote
- Alternative Vote
- First Past The Post
Show answer
Answer: C. In the Alternative Vote voters mark preferences with numbers, and ballots are transferred until a candidate wins.
-
3. In a Two-Round System a second election is usually needed when:
- no candidate wins an absolute majority (50% plus one) in the first round
- the turnout is below half
- two parties tie for the most seats
- the President dissolves the House
Show answer
Answer: A. TRS holds a second round if nobody reaches the required level, most commonly an absolute majority, in round one.
-
4. If 3 Rajya Sabha seats are to be filled by 160 valid votes, what is the quota?
- 40
- 53
- 54
- 41
Show answer
Answer: D. Quota = (160 ÷ (3 + 1)) + 1 = (160 ÷ 4) + 1 = 40 + 1 = 41.
-
5. Which reason for adopting FPTP is given in the textbook?
- It always gives every party seats in exact proportion to votes
- Voters know their own local representative and can hold him or her accountable
- It removes the need for constituencies
- It is used only in Australia
Show answer
Answer: B. In a constituency system each area has one representative accountable to its voters. FPTP does not give exact proportionality; it tends to give the largest party bonus seats.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.