- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Just distribution, theories of justice and John Rawls
Explain the idea of a level playing field, the debate over merit, the theories of equality of resources, common ownership and entitlement, retributive justice, and John Rawls's justice as fairness.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why a law for fair distribution does not by itself ensure just distribution, and what a level playing field means.
- Distinguish equality of resources, common ownership and entitlement theories, and contrast distributive with retributive justice.
- Summarise John Rawls's idea of justice as fairness as the textbook presents it.
Once we agree that opportunity should be equal, the next question is how to distribute resources fairly. The textbook surveys several answers and gives special attention to the American philosopher John Rawls.
A level playing field
Governments can pass laws for the fair distribution of resources, but the textbook argues that where socio-cultural inequalities are deeply entrenched, a law alone will not ensure just distribution. People need basic equality of life conditions and opportunities first: a level playing field. Because the Constitution abolishes untouchability and caste discrimination, the book says the State has a legal, constitutional and moral obligation to create such a field, especially for those historically denied basic rights.
- It is not charity: it is a constitutional obligation, and disadvantaged people may seek legal remedy.
- It is aimed mainly at education and employment, because modern education is the key resource and government jobs a major source of livelihood.
- It means treating people differently in order to treat them justly.
The merit debate
The textbook notes that some people from privileged sections argue that treating people differently is itself discrimination, and invoke merit to claim that reserving seats harms the quality of education and professional skill. It asks students to examine the issue dispassionately: is some intervention needed for the marginalised, and what would happen if the privileged kept all educational and job opportunities even after independence? It frames the choice as one between an inclusive nation and an exclusive one.
Theories of just distribution
| Theory | What counts as just | Weak point to think about |
|---|---|---|
| Equality of resources | Every individual has the same effective resources; the same reward for the same work | Ignores differing needs and circumstances |
| Common ownership | At the start, each person has the same amount of land or other valuable resources | Assumes everyone has equal abilities and similar preferences |
| Entitlement | A holding is just if it is historically justified; resources pass only by voluntary transfer | Past injustices may be carried forward |
The textbook concludes that there is broad agreement that justice in society must be distributive rather than retributive.
Retributive justice
- Those who commit serious wrongs deserve punishment proportionate to the crime.
- Giving the wrongdoer the punishment deserved is treated as a moral good in itself.
- It forbids punishing the innocent intentionally and forbids disproportionately harsh punishment.
The textbook says that features such as proportionality and the justification of suffering are highly contested, and that the framers of the Constitution rejected retribution as a way to establish social justice, believing violent methods bring no lasting solution.
John Rawls: justice as fairness
John Rawls, author of A Theory of Justice (1971), is described as one of the finest political philosophers of the 20th century. As the textbook presents him, he treats personal attributes such as the family one is born into as morally arbitrary, so justice demands equality: social values such as liberty, opportunity, income, wealth and self-respect are to be distributed equally unless an unequal distribution benefits everyone. Injustice is simply inequality that does not benefit all. Fairness, for Rawls, comes from rational thinking about society as a whole, not from generosity. The textbook adds that a society where non-rational identities shape social life must work hard to absorb this idea.
Distributive and retributive justice
-
Distributive
- Concerned with sharing resources and opportunities
- Looks ahead to an equal society
- Basis of the Constitution's approach
-
Retributive
- Concerned with punishing wrongdoing
- Looks back at what was done
- Rejected as a route to social justice
Worked example 1: applying Rawls
A made-up company pays its doctors more than its clerks. Rawlsian test: does the inequality benefit everyone, including the worst off? If higher pay attracts doctors who serve all employees' health, the inequality may be justified. If a manager is paid more only because of family connections, it benefits no one else, so by Rawls's measure it is unjust.
Worked example 2: naming the theory
A made-up scheme gives every family the same plot of land at the start of a new settlement, after which people may sell or buy freely. Reasoning: an equal starting share is the common ownership idea; the free voluntary transfers that follow match the entitlement idea.
Rawls: injustice is inequality that does not benefit all. Social justice is distributive, not retributive.
Key takeaways: law alone cannot ensure just distribution where inequalities are entrenched; a level playing field is a constitutional obligation, not charity. Equality of resources, common ownership and entitlement are three ways to judge distribution; retributive justice concerns punishment and is not the Constitution's route to social justice. Rawls's justice as fairness accepts only inequalities that benefit everyone.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, a 'level playing field' provided by the government is:
- an act of charity
- a constitutional obligation
- applicable only to sports
- a form of punishment
Show answer
Answer: B. The book insists equal opportunity is not charity or philanthropy but an obligation on the government and a right of disadvantaged people.
-
2. Which theory holds that a distribution is just if holdings are historically justified and pass only by voluntary transfer?
- Entitlement theory
- Common ownership theory
- Equality of resources
- Retributive theory
Show answer
Answer: A. Entitlement theory judges a distribution by its history and requires transfers to be voluntary.
-
3. Retributive justice is mainly concerned with:
- redistributing land
- reservation in education
- punishment proportionate to wrongdoing
- economic planning
Show answer
Answer: C. Retributive justice holds that wrongdoers deserve punishment proportionate to their crime.
-
4. For John Rawls, as presented in the textbook, injustice is:
- any difference in income
- inequality that does not benefit all
- the absence of punishment
- the rule of the majority
Show answer
Answer: B. Rawls accepts inequality only when it benefits everyone; inequalities that do not benefit all are unjust.
-
5. John Rawls's best-known book, named in the textbook, is:
- The Social Contract
- Leviathan
- Das Kapital
- A Theory of Justice
Show answer
Answer: D. A Theory of Justice (1971) sets out his idea of justice as fairness.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.