- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Socio-cultural equality, discrimination and affirmative action around the world
Explain socio-cultural and economic equality and Periyar's views on caste and patriarchy, the social-psychological view of discrimination, and how affirmative action works in the USA, the UN framework, South Africa and elsewhere.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain socio-cultural and economic equality and why the textbook treats basic needs as part of an egalitarian society.
- Describe Periyar's views on caste and on the subordination of women, as the textbook reports them, and the idea of proportional justice.
- Explain affirmative action and give examples from the USA, the UN, South Africa, China and the former USSR.
Equality is not only about the law. It also concerns culture, social practice and economic conditions. This lesson follows the textbook from these wider forms of equality to the policies that countries around the world use to correct long-standing discrimination.
Socio-cultural and economic equality
In a diverse society, every individual should have a fair opportunity to practise his or her culture and develop talents. The textbook argues that at the very least unequal conditions must be reduced: good health care, education, nutritious food and minimum wages should be available to all without discrimination, or a society cannot be called egalitarian. It names practices based on caste and religion, and the denial of education, employment and property rights to women in many places, as obstacles to the nation's progress.
Economic equality is measured by income and property, by the gap between rich and poor, and by the number of people below the poverty line. The textbook notes that culture-based and historical discrimination can make economic inequality worse.
Periyar on equality
The textbook quotes E.V. Ramasamy (Periyar) of Tamil Nadu as condemning the practice of respecting people according to the caste they belong to as inhuman thinking, and as holding that the best society is one free of caste, religious and gender-based oppression and of oppressive customs. He also opposed patriarchy, the subordination of women through history. The textbook adds that many saints, seers and philosophers also worked for an egalitarian society, and that judging ability by birth is the main feature of an unequal society.
Proportional justice
The textbook recalls that ideas of justice are old, from dharma and adharma in Indian tradition to the debates of Socrates and Plato, who held that justice which favours only some is not justice. It infers that reservation is fair justice for groups long discriminated against, and that because caste hierarchy is the main source of inequality in India, policies are graded by category: backward classes, most backward classes, Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.
Why discrimination happens: a social-psychological view
Social psychologists, the textbook says, find that people identify with their own group and feel valued when recognised as part of it. Discrimination means excluding others from the group or barring them from resources. Studies show that people with a low sense of social recognition tend to devalue outsiders, and that negative attitudes towards different groups (ethnic and religious minorities, women, disabled or homeless people) tend to go together.
Affirmative action
Affirmative action (also called positive discrimination) promotes equality through preferential treatment of socially and economically disadvantaged people, often disadvantaged for historical reasons such as oppression or slavery. Its aims include closing gaps in jobs and pay, widening access to education, bringing every section of society into leadership, and redressing past wrongs.
| Where | What the textbook describes |
|---|---|
| United States | After civil rights movements against colour discrimination, President John F. Kennedy's Executive Order 10925 (1961) asked employers not to discriminate by race, creed, colour or national origin; Executive Order 11246 (1965) committed the federal government to a positive programme of equal employment opportunity; extended to women in 1967; linked to the Civil Rights Act of 1964. |
| United Nations | The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination allows special measures to correct systematic discrimination, but these must not lead to permanently unequal or separate rights once their aims are achieved. |
| South Africa | After the transition to democracy in 1994, laws required employers to hire from previously disadvantaged groups; firms above a size limit must plan and report on their workforce. |
| China and the former USSR | Preferences in education for minority nationalities (China); quotas for ethnic minorities, women and workers in universities and offices (USSR). |
Goals of affirmative action
- Bridge inequalities in jobs and pay
- Widen access to education
- Bring all sections into leadership
- Redress past wrongs
- Correct imbalance left by historic oppression
Worked example 1: affirmative action or not?
(a) A made-up university reserves some seats for students from communities historically denied education: affirmative action (preferential treatment to correct historical disadvantage). (b) The same university admits students only by a fee few can afford: not affirmative action; it widens inequality.
Worked example 2: the UN's time limit
A made-up country keeps separate, permanently unequal rights for two racial groups 'for balance', long after the gap has closed. Reasoning: the UN convention permits special measures only to correct discrimination and forbids unequal or separate rights after the aims are met. Conclusion: this would breach the convention.
Affirmative action: preferential treatment of historically disadvantaged groups to achieve real equality, not permanent separate rights.
Key takeaways: the textbook links socio-cultural and economic equality to basic needs for all. It reports Periyar's opposition to caste-based status and patriarchy. Discrimination grows from in-group and out-group feelings. Affirmative action, found in the USA, under the UN framework, in South Africa, China and the former USSR, uses preferential treatment to correct historical disadvantage.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, which of these is a basic need that must be available to all for a society to be called egalitarian?
- A private car
- Nutritious food
- Foreign travel
- Luxury housing
Show answer
Answer: B. The book lists good health care, education, nutritious food and minimum wages as basic needs for all.
-
2. Periyar, as reported in the textbook, opposed both caste-based status and:
- patriarchy, the subordination of women
- the use of machines
- local government
- elections
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook notes that Periyar was against patriarchal domination that subjugated women throughout history.
-
3. Executive Order 10925, asking employers not to discriminate by race, creed, colour or national origin, was issued in the USA by:
- Abraham Lincoln
- Franklin Roosevelt
- John F. Kennedy
- Lyndon Johnson
Show answer
Answer: C. The textbook names President John F. Kennedy and Executive Order 10925 in the 1960s. Order 11246 followed in 1965.
-
4. Under the UN Convention on racial discrimination, special measures of affirmative action:
- must create permanent separate rights
- are forbidden
- apply only to women
- must not continue as unequal or separate rights after their aims are achieved
Show answer
Answer: D. The Convention allows special measures but says they must not lead to unequal or separate rights once the objectives are met.
-
5. The textbook explains that policies in India are graded by categories such as backward classes, most backward classes, SCs and STs because:
- caste hierarchy is the main source of inequality
- all groups are equally placed
- the UN requires it
- it is based on income only
Show answer
Answer: A. Under 'proportional justice' the book says caste hierarchy is the primary reason for inequality, so measures follow those categories.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.