- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Reservation after independence: the First Amendment, Tamil Nadu's 69 per cent and the Mandal Commission
Explain how the First Amendment protected reservation, how reservation in Tamil Nadu grew to 69 per cent with Ninth Schedule protection, and the Kalelkar and Mandal Commissions and the Indra Sawhney judgment.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the Champakam Dorairajan case and why the First Amendment added Article 15(4).
- Trace the growth of reservation in Tamil Nadu from 41 per cent to 69 per cent and the role of the 76th Amendment.
- Describe Article 340, the Kalelkar and Mandal Commissions and the Indra Sawhney judgment, and the textbook's view that reservation is one method among others.
When the Constitution came into force in 1950, the communal representation system of the Madras Presidency faced its first legal test. This lesson follows how reservation was defended, expanded and reviewed by the courts.
The 1951 case and the First Amendment
In 1951 a candidate denied a medical college seat challenged the Madras government's communal order. In State of Madras v. Champakam Dorairajan (the textbook names the petitioner differently), the High Court and then the Supreme Court held the order to be against the Constitution. The textbook records statewide protests in Tamil Nadu and says that through the efforts of Periyar, K. Kamaraj, Jawaharlal Nehru and B.R. Ambedkar, Parliament passed the First Amendment (1951), which added Article 15(4), allowing special provisions for socially and educationally backward classes and for SCs and STs. Article 16(4), on reservation in posts, was already in the original Constitution. (The textbook says both clauses were added; check this point with your teacher.)
Reservation in Tamil Nadu
| Year | Backward classes | SC/ST | Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| From 1951 | 25% | 16% | 41% |
| 1971 (after the Sattanathan Commission) | 31% | 18% | 49% |
| 1980 | 50% | 18% | 68% |
| 1989 onwards | 30% BC + 20% MBC | 18% SC + 1% ST | 69% |
Check the totals: 25 + 16 = 41; 31 + 18 = 49; 50 + 18 = 68; 30 + 20 + 18 + 1 = 69. The textbook adds that a 1979 order fixed an annual family income limit of ₹9,000 for backward classes; it was withdrawn and replaced by the increase to 50%.
The 50 per cent ceiling and the Ninth Schedule
After the Supreme Court's 50% ceiling (below), a petition challenged Tamil Nadu's 69%, and the Court directed that seats in professional colleges should not exceed 50% reservation. In response, the textbook says, the state legislature passed a bill on 30 December 1993, which received the President's assent on 19 July 1994. Parliament then passed the 76th Amendment (1994), which placed the Tamil Nadu law in the Ninth Schedule of the Constitution, giving it protection against challenge in the courts.
How Tamil Nadu's 69% gained protection
- Supreme Court's 50% ceiling (1992)
- Challenge to 69% in Tamil Nadu
- State reservation law (1993)
- President's assent (1994)
- 76th Amendment: Ninth Schedule
Backward Classes Commissions
Article 340 lets the President appoint a commission to investigate the conditions of socially and educationally backward classes and recommend measures.
- Kaka Kalelkar Commission (1953): the first Backward Classes Commission, appointed on 29 January 1953; its report was placed before Parliament but not adopted.
- Mandal Commission: set up by the Morarji Desai government (announced December 1978, constituted in 1979) under B.P. Mandal. It identified 3,743 castes as backward using 11 indicators, estimated backward classes at about 52% of the population and recommended 27% reservation in central government jobs, so that total reservation with SCs and STs stays within 50%. The report was submitted in December 1980. In its preface Mandal described Madras as a pioneer of communal representation.
- Implementation: the V.P. Singh government issued an order on 13 August 1990 for 27% reservation in central services.
The Indra Sawhney judgment (1992)
In Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, a bench of nine judges of the Supreme Court upheld the 27% reservation by majority, but held that total reservation should not normally exceed 50%, allowing exceptions only in extraordinary situations, and that the well-to-do among backward classes (the 'creamy layer') should be excluded. A revised office memorandum followed on 8 September 1993. (The textbook's box speaks of eleven judges; the bench that decided the case had nine.)
Promoting social justice
The textbook stresses that reservation is one method of achieving social justice, not the only one. Social justice rests on the egalitarian idea that no one is superior or inferior by birth. It describes reservation as a temporary means of sharing power, suggests that weakening caste hierarchy, for example through inter-caste marriages, is a way to lasting equality, and argues that being modern means a consciousness of equality with everyone, not owning the latest gadgets.
Worked example 1: totals and the ceiling
Under the 1989 arrangement Tamil Nadu reserved 30% (BC) + 20% (MBC) + 18% (SC) + 1% (ST) = 69%. That is 69 − 50 = 19 percentage points above the ceiling set in Indra Sawhney, which is why Ninth Schedule protection was sought.
Worked example 2: which body?
(a) Recommended 27% reservation for backward classes in central services: Mandal Commission. (b) First commission under Article 340: Kaka Kalelkar Commission. (c) Upheld 27% but fixed a 50% ceiling and the creamy layer rule: Supreme Court in Indra Sawhney.
First Amendment 1951: Article 15(4). Mandal: 27% for backward classes. Indra Sawhney 1992: 50% ceiling, creamy layer. 76th Amendment 1994: Tamil Nadu's 69% in the Ninth Schedule.
Key takeaways: the 1951 court verdict against the communal order led to the First Amendment and Article 15(4). Tamil Nadu's reservation rose from 41% to 69%, protected by the 76th Amendment. Article 340 commissions under Kalelkar and Mandal studied backward classes; Mandal's 27% was upheld in Indra Sawhney with a 50% ceiling. The textbook treats reservation as one tool within a wider aim of an equal society.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which clause was added by the First Amendment (1951) after the court verdict on the Madras communal order?
- Article 16(4)
- Article 15(4)
- Article 29(2)
- Article 340
Show answer
Answer: B. The First Amendment added Article 15(4). Article 16(4) was part of the original Constitution; Article 340 concerns backward classes commissions.
-
2. Under the 1989 arrangement in Tamil Nadu, total reservation was 30% BC + 20% MBC + 18% SC + 1% ST. What is the total?
- 68%
- 50%
- 69%
- 49%
Show answer
Answer: C. 30 + 20 + 18 + 1 = 69 per cent.
-
3. The Mandal Commission recommended reservation of what share of central government jobs for backward classes?
- 27%
- 52%
- 18%
- 50%
Show answer
Answer: A. It recommended 27%. The 52% figure was its estimate of the backward classes' share of the population.
-
4. Which amendment placed Tamil Nadu's reservation law in the Ninth Schedule?
- First Amendment
- 73rd Amendment
- 61st Amendment
- 76th Amendment
Show answer
Answer: D. The 76th Amendment (1994) placed the Tamil Nadu law in the Ninth Schedule.
-
5. Which statement about the Indra Sawhney judgment is correct?
- It struck down all reservation
- It upheld 27% for backward classes and set a normal ceiling of 50%
- It made reservation compulsory in private firms
- It was delivered in 1951
Show answer
Answer: B. The Supreme Court in 1992 upheld the 27% reservation, set a 50% ceiling except in extraordinary situations, and excluded the creamy layer.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.