Revision notes

Unit 13 Social Justice: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

What social justice means and why equality needs special provisions

From hierarchy to social justice (the textbook's argument)

  1. Birth-based hierarchy Status fixed by birth, not by ability
  2. Denial of opportunity Education, land and jobs kept from some groups
  3. Inequality and prejudice Artificial differences passed down generations
  4. Special provisions Constitutional measures for disadvantaged groups
  5. Equal society Shared power, tolerance and equal opportunity
Constitutional provisions named in the textbook
ProvisionWhat it allows (in simple words)
Article 15(4)The State may make special provisions for the advancement of socially and educationally backward classes and for SCs and STs; Article 15 and Article 29(2) do not stand in the way.
Article 16(4)The State may reserve appointments or posts for backward classes that are not adequately represented in its services.
Article 29(2)No citizen shall be denied admission to a State-run or State-aided educational institution on grounds only of religion, race, caste or language. Article 15(4) makes clear this does not block special provisions.

Social justice, as the textbook uses the term: weaker groups' struggle for an equal society, where people are valued for talent and effort, not birth, and opportunity is truly equal.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: the textbook defines social justice as the effort to end domination by one group and build an equal, plural society. It locates the roots of Indian inequality in birth-based hierarchy and untouchability, calls such inequalities artificial prejudices, and explains that Articles 15(4) and 16(4) permit special provisions so that opportunity becomes real.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Just distribution, theories of justice and John Rawls

Three perspectives on distribution described in the textbook
TheoryWhat counts as justWeak point to think about
Equality of resourcesEvery individual has the same effective resources; the same reward for the same workIgnores differing needs and circumstances
Common ownershipAt the start, each person has the same amount of land or other valuable resourcesAssumes everyone has equal abilities and similar preferences
EntitlementA holding is just if it is historically justified; resources pass only by voluntary transferPast injustices may be carried forward

Distributive and retributive justice

  • Distributive
    • Concerned with sharing resources and opportunities
    • Looks ahead to an equal society
    • Basis of the Constitution's approach
  • Retributive
    • Concerned with punishing wrongdoing
    • Looks back at what was done
    • Rejected as a route to social justice

Rawls: injustice is inequality that does not benefit all. Social justice is distributive, not retributive.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: law alone cannot ensure just distribution where inequalities are entrenched; a level playing field is a constitutional obligation, not charity. Equality of resources, common ownership and entitlement are three ways to judge distribution; retributive justice concerns punishment and is not the Constitution's route to social justice. Rawls's justice as fairness accepts only inequalities that benefit everyone.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Socio-cultural equality, discrimination and affirmative action around the world

Affirmative action around the world
WhereWhat the textbook describes
United StatesAfter civil rights movements against colour discrimination, President John F. Kennedy's Executive Order 10925 (1961) asked employers not to discriminate by race, creed, colour or national origin; Executive Order 11246 (1965) committed the federal government to a positive programme of equal employment opportunity; extended to women in 1967; linked to the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
United NationsThe Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination allows special measures to correct systematic discrimination, but these must not lead to permanently unequal or separate rights once their aims are achieved.
South AfricaAfter the transition to democracy in 1994, laws required employers to hire from previously disadvantaged groups; firms above a size limit must plan and report on their workforce.
China and the former USSRPreferences in education for minority nationalities (China); quotas for ethnic minorities, women and workers in universities and offices (USSR).

Goals of affirmative action

  • Bridge inequalities in jobs and pay
  • Widen access to education
  • Bring all sections into leadership
  • Redress past wrongs
  • Correct imbalance left by historic oppression

Affirmative action: preferential treatment of historically disadvantaged groups to achieve real equality, not permanent separate rights.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: the textbook links socio-cultural and economic equality to basic needs for all. It reports Periyar's opposition to caste-based status and patriarchy. Discrimination grows from in-group and out-group feelings. Affirmative action, found in the USA, under the UN framework, in South Africa, China and the former USSR, uses preferential treatment to correct historical disadvantage.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

The social justice movement in the Madras Presidency and the Justice Party

Parallel movements
YearEvent (as in the textbook)
1891Malayali Memorial in Travancore demands fair employment for natives of the state
1896Ezhava Memorial demands opportunities in jobs and education; Sree Narayana Guru organises people affected by the caste system and starts schools
1902Chhatrapati Shahu Maharaj of Kolhapur introduces reservation in government jobs for non-Brahmins, for the first time
Around the same periodIn Mysore the Miller Committee recommends communal distribution of jobs

Steps towards communal representation in Madras (textbook account)

  1. 1916 South Indian Liberal Federation (Justice Party) and the Non-Brahmin Manifesto
  2. 1921-22 Communal representation orders under the Justice Party government
  3. 1925 Periyar's resolution on communal representation at the Kanchipuram Congress conference is not accepted; he leaves the Congress
  4. 1928 Communal representation implemented in all departments under the ministry of S. Muthiah Mudaliar

1916: South Indian Liberal Federation (Justice Party). 1921-22: communal representation orders. 1928: implemented in all departments.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: the textbook links unequal access to education, land and government jobs in the Madras Presidency to the rise of a social justice movement. Panchami lands, the memorials in Travancore, Shahu Maharaj's reservation and the Miller Committee were early steps. The Justice Party (1916) won communal representation orders in the 1920s, and Periyar carried the demand into the Congress and beyond.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Reservation after independence: the First Amendment, Tamil Nadu's 69 per cent and the Mandal Commission

Growth of reservation in Tamil Nadu, from the figures in the textbook
YearBackward classesSC/STTotal
From 195125%16%41%
1971 (after the Sattanathan Commission)31%18%49%
198050%18%68%
1989 onwards30% BC + 20% MBC18% SC + 1% ST69%

How Tamil Nadu's 69% gained protection

  1. Supreme Court's 50% ceiling (1992)
  2. Challenge to 69% in Tamil Nadu
  3. State reservation law (1993)
  4. President's assent (1994)
  5. 76th Amendment: Ninth Schedule

First Amendment 1951: Article 15(4). Mandal: 27% for backward classes. Indra Sawhney 1992: 50% ceiling, creamy layer. 76th Amendment 1994: Tamil Nadu's 69% in the Ninth Schedule.

— Key idea, in our own words

Key takeaways: the 1951 court verdict against the communal order led to the First Amendment and Article 15(4). Tamil Nadu's reservation rose from 41% to 69%, protected by the 76th Amendment. Article 340 commissions under Kalelkar and Mandal studied backward classes; Mandal's 27% was upheld in Indra Sawhney with a 50% ceiling. The textbook treats reservation as one tool within a wider aim of an equal society.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery