• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Evidences of evolution: anatomy, embryology and molecules

Use homologous, analogous and vestigial organs, connecting links, atavism, embryology and molecular data as evidence for common ancestry, and tell divergent from convergent evolution.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Tell homologous from analogous structures and link them to divergent and convergent evolution.
  • Give examples of vestigial organs, connecting links and atavism.
  • State the biogenetic law and its limitation.
  • Explain what a molecular clock is.

Fossils are one line of evidence. Living organisms carry more: in the bones of their limbs, in the stages of their embryos and in the sequences of their molecules. When several independent lines of evidence point the same way, scientists can be confident about common ancestry.

Homologous structures and divergent evolution

The forelimbs of a human, cat, whale, bat, horse and bird do very different jobs (grasping, walking, swimming, flying, running), yet all are built from the same set of bones: humerus, radius, ulna, carpals, metacarpals and phalanges. Structures that are similar in origin but perform different functions are homologous. They arise when descendants of one ancestor adapt to different ways of life, which is divergent evolution. In plants, the thorn of Bougainvillea (used for defence) and the tendril of Cucurbita (used for climbing) are both modified stems, so they are homologous.

Analogous structures and convergent evolution

The wing of a bird has bones; the wing of an insect is a thin fold of body wall with no bones. Both are used for flight. Structures with different structure and origin but similar function are analogous. They arise when unrelated organisms adapt to similar needs, which is convergent evolution. Other examples from the textbook: the eyes of Octopus and of mammals, the flippers of penguins and dolphins, and the storage root of sweet potato compared with the storage stem (tuber) of potato.

Homology versus analogy

  • Homologous organs
    • Same basic structure and origin
    • Different functions
    • Result of divergent evolution
    • Forelimbs of human, whale, bat, bird
    • Bougainvillea thorn and Cucurbita tendril
  • Analogous organs
    • Different structure and origin
    • Same function
    • Result of convergent evolution
    • Wings of bird and insect
    • Sweet potato root and potato tuber

Vestigial organs, connecting links and atavism

Vestigial organs are structures of no use to the possessor, remnants of organs that were functional in ancestors. The human vermiform appendix is the reduced remnant of the caecum, which digests cellulose in herbivores such as the rabbit; as the human diet held less cellulose, the caecum lost its role. Other human examples: the coccyx, wisdom teeth, ear muscles, body hair, the nictitating membrane of the eye and mammae in males.

Connecting links are organisms with characters of two different groups. Peripatus links Annelida and Arthropoda; Archaeopteryx links reptiles and birds. Atavism is the sudden reappearance of an ancestral or vestigial feature in a highly evolved organism, for example a tail in a human baby.

Embryological evidence

All vertebrate hearts begin as a pair of tubes. They then develop into a two-chambered heart in fishes, three chambers in amphibians and most reptiles, and four chambers in crocodiles, birds and mammals. Embryos of fish, salamander, tortoise, chick and human all start as a zygote, form a blastula and gastrula, are triploblastic, and show pharyngeal pouches and a post-anal tail at an early stage.

Ernst Haeckel proposed the biogenetic law (theory of recapitulation): ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny, meaning the development of an individual repeats the evolutionary history of its race. The law is not universal. Embryos do not pass through the adult stages of their ancestors; a human embryo resembles the embryos of its ancestors (for example in having pharyngeal gill slits and a tail), not their adults.

Molecular evidence

Molecules that control life processes, such as DNA, RNA and proteins, are conserved among species. Small changes accumulate in them at a fairly steady pace over time, so the number of differences works like a molecular clock: the more differences between two species, the longer ago they shared an ancestor. Cytochrome c (respiration) and rRNA (protein synthesis) are much used for this.

Worked reasoning example 1: homologous or analogous?

Classify: (a) flipper of a whale and arm of a human; (b) flipper of a penguin and flipper of a dolphin. Reasoning: (a) both are mammalian forelimbs with the same bones, used differently: homologous. (b) a penguin is a bird and a dolphin a mammal; their flipper shapes evolved separately, in unrelated lines, for the same job of swimming, so the textbook treats them as analogous. Ask always: same origin, or only same job?

Worked reasoning example 2: reading a molecular clock

Made-up data for practice: species X differs from humans at 1 position in a protein, species Y at 12 positions and species Z at 30. Which shared a common ancestor with humans most recently? Reasoning: differences pile up with time since two lines separated, so the fewest differences means the most recent common ancestor. Answer: X, then Y, then Z.

Homologous = same origin, different function (divergent). Analogous = different origin, same function (convergent). Ontogeny recapitulates phylogeny, but only embryo-to-embryo.

Key takeaways: homology points to common ancestry and divergent evolution; analogy to convergent evolution. Vestigial organs, connecting links and atavism are further anatomical clues. Similar embryonic stages show common ancestry, though Haeckel's law holds only for embryonic, not adult, stages. Conserved molecules such as cytochrome c and rRNA act as molecular clocks.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The wings of birds and of butterflies are an example of:

    1. divergent evolution
    2. convergent evolution
    3. adaptive radiation
    4. atavism
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Bird and butterfly wings have different structures and origins but the same function, flight. Such analogous organs result from convergent evolution.

  2. 2. Which of these is a vestigial organ in human beings?

    1. Vermiform appendix
    2. Femur
    3. Small intestine
    4. Lens of the eye
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The appendix is a reduced remnant of the caecum, which digests cellulose in herbivores. It has no essential role in humans, so it is vestigial. The others are fully functional.

  3. 3. Peripatus is considered a connecting link between:

    1. reptiles and birds
    2. fishes and amphibians
    3. Annelida and Arthropoda
    4. Mollusca and Echinodermata
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Peripatus shows characters of both annelids and arthropods. Archaeopteryx is the link between reptiles and birds.

  4. 4. The vertebrate heart begins as a pair of tubes in all vertebrate embryos. In which group does it become four-chambered?

    1. Fishes only
    2. Amphibians and most reptiles
    3. All reptiles
    4. Crocodiles, birds and mammals
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The heart becomes two-chambered in fishes, three-chambered in amphibians and most reptiles, and four-chambered in crocodiles, birds and mammals.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): The biogenetic law is not universal. Reason (R): A human embryo resembles the embryos of its ancestors, not their adult forms.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Haeckel claimed that embryos pass through adult ancestral stages. In fact embryos resemble ancestral embryos, so the law in its original form fails. R is the reason A is true.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery