• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Theories of evolution: Lamarck, Darwin, de Vries and the modern synthesis

Explain Lamarckism and Weismann's objection, Darwin's natural selection and its objections, de Vries' mutation theory, the modern synthetic theory, industrial melanism and adaptive radiation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • State Lamarck's two principles and how Weismann tested them.
  • List the observations behind Darwin's natural selection and the main objections to it.
  • Contrast de Vries' mutation theory with the views of Lamarck and Darwin.
  • Name the five factors of the modern synthetic theory.
  • Explain industrial melanism and adaptive radiation with examples.

Evidence tells us that evolution happened. Theories try to explain how. Each theory in this lesson added something, and each had weaknesses that the next one tried to fix.

Lamarck's theory (1809)

Jean Baptiste de Lamarck put forward the first theory of evolution in his book Philosophie Zoologique (1809). Its two principles: (1) Use and disuse: organs used often grow larger, and unused organs degenerate. The textbook's examples are the long neck of the giraffe (use) and the loss of limbs in snakes (disuse). (2) Inheritance of acquired characters: characters developed during an organism's life are passed to its offspring.

August Weismann tested the second principle by cutting off the tails of mice and breeding them; according to the textbook he did this for twenty generations, and every mouse was still born with a tail. He proposed the germplasm theory: changes in the body cells (somatoplasm) are not passed on, while changes in the germ cells (germplasm) are inherited. Neo-Lamarckists such as Cope, Osborn, Packard and Spencer argued that the environment makes body cells release 'secretions' that reach the sex cells through the blood, but this was never supported.

Darwin's theory of natural selection

Charles Darwin set out his theory in On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection (1859), after observing plants and animals during his voyage around the world. It rests on four points.

  1. Over-production (prodigality of production): organisms produce far more offspring than can survive. A salmon lays millions of eggs in a season; even the slow-breeding elephant would, unchecked, fill the land in a few centuries.
  2. Struggle for existence: food, space and mates are limited, so individuals compete. The struggle is intraspecific (within a species), interspecific (between species) and with the environment (climate, floods, drought).
  3. Universal occurrence of variations: no two individuals are exactly alike, not even identical twins. Useful variations help an individual survive and are passed on.
  4. Natural selection, or survival of the fittest: nature selects individuals with useful variations; they survive, leave more offspring, and over many generations new species arise.

Objections to Darwinism: Darwin could not explain how variations arise or are inherited; his theory explains the survival of the fittest but not the arrival of the fittest; he relied on small fluctuating variations that are mostly not heritable; he did not separate somatic from germinal variations; and he could not explain vestigial organs or over-specialised organs such as the huge tusks of extinct mammoths and the antlers of the extinct Irish deer. Neo-Darwinism reinterpreted natural selection with later discoveries, emphasising change in gene frequencies caused by mutation, variation, isolation and natural selection.

Mutation theory of Hugo de Vries

Hugo de Vries, working on the evening primrose Oenothera lamarckiana, saw new forms appear suddenly. He proposed that mutations, sudden, large, random changes, produce new species in a single step (saltation), whereas Lamarck and Darwin thought new species arose by the gradual build-up of small variations. Key points: mutations (discontinuous variations) are passed to the next generation when they occur in the germ line; they appear from time to time in natural populations; there are no intermediate forms; and mutants are subject to natural selection.

Modern synthetic theory

Scientists including Sewall Wright, R. A. Fisher, Ernst Mayr, Julian Huxley, Theodosius Dobzhansky and G. G. Simpson combined natural selection with genetics. The theory names five basic factors: gene mutation (change in the structure of a gene, also called point mutation), chromosomal mutation (deletion, duplication, inversion or translocation), genetic recombination (crossing over in meiosis), natural selection (which creates no variation itself but favours some variations and rejects others, the driving force of evolution) and reproductive isolation (which stops related groups from interbreeding).

How the five factors of the modern synthesis work together

  1. Variation arises Gene mutation, chromosomal mutation and recombination
  2. Natural selection acts Favourable variants leave more offspring
  3. Populations diverge Gene frequencies change over generations
  4. Reproductive isolation Groups can no longer interbreed: new species

Natural selection seen: industrial melanism

The peppered moth Biston betularia in England occurs in a light (white-winged) form and a dark (black-winged) form. Before industrialisation, tree trunks were covered with pale lichens; light moths were camouflaged and dark moths were eaten more by birds, so light moths were more common. After industrialisation, soot darkened the trunks and pollution killed the lichens. Now dark moths were camouflaged and light ones were picked off, so dark moths became common. Nature gave positive selection pressure to the dark form. Artificial selection, such as the many breeds of the single dog species made by humans, shows how much selection can change a species, and suggests what nature can do over far longer times.

Adaptive radiation

Adaptive radiation is the evolution of many new species from a single ancestor as its descendants spread into different habitats. Darwin's finches of the Galapagos Islands are the classic case: according to the textbook their ancestor arrived about 2 million years ago and gave rise to 14 recognised species that differ in size, beak shape and food (insects, seeds, cactus nectar and even blood of iguanas). Variation in the ALX1 gene is linked with differences in beak shape. Australian marsupials are the second classic case: from a common ancestor they radiated into many forms. Marsupials of Australia and placental mammals elsewhere also show convergent evolution, producing similar-looking forms (for example a marsupial and a placental 'wolf' or 'mole') in similar habitats.

Worked reasoning example 1: Lamarck or Darwin?

Explain the long neck of the giraffe in both ways. Lamarck: ancestors stretched their necks to reach leaves; the slightly longer necks gained in life were passed on. Darwin: ancestors varied in neck length; when food was short, those with longer necks reached more leaves, survived and bred more; over generations the average neck length increased. Difference: Lamarck makes the change happen in the individual and be inherited; Darwin starts with existing heritable variation and lets selection sort it. Weismann's result supports Darwin's form.

Worked reasoning example 2: predicting the moths after clean air laws

Suppose pollution is controlled, lichens grow back and the trunks become pale again. What will happen to the moths? Reasoning: the background is light again, so dark moths become easier for birds to see. Selection now favours light moths, and their proportion should rise over generations. This shows that selection depends on the environment: neither colour is 'better' in every place.

Lamarck: use and disuse + inheritance of acquired characters. Darwin: over-production, struggle, variation, survival of the fittest. De Vries: large sudden mutations (saltation). Modern synthesis: mutation, chromosomal change, recombination, selection, isolation.

Key takeaways: Lamarck's inheritance of acquired characters was disproved by Weismann's germplasm theory. Darwin explained evolution by natural selection acting on variation, but could not explain the source of variation. De Vries proposed sudden large mutations. The modern synthetic theory joins genetics and selection through five factors. Industrial melanism shows selection in action; Darwin's finches and Australian marsupials show adaptive radiation.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who proposed the germplasm theory?

    1. Lamarck
    2. Darwin
    3. August Weismann
    4. Hugo de Vries
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Weismann proposed that only changes in the germplasm (germ cells) are inherited, not changes in the somatoplasm. His tail-cutting experiments on mice were used against Lamarck's inheritance of acquired characters.

  2. 2. Hugo de Vries based his mutation theory on observations of:

    1. Oenothera lamarckiana
    2. Biston betularia
    3. Darwin's finches
    4. garden pea
    Show answer

    Answer: A. De Vries saw new forms appear suddenly in the evening primrose, Oenothera lamarckiana, and proposed that large sudden mutations create new species.

  3. 3. The phenomenon of industrial melanism in the peppered moth demonstrates:

    1. induced mutation
    2. inheritance of acquired characters
    3. geographical isolation
    4. natural selection
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The dark form already existed; when soot darkened the trees, birds removed more light moths, so the dark form increased. This change in frequency through differential survival is natural selection.

  4. 4. Which objection is commonly raised against Darwin's theory?

    1. It explains the arrival of the fittest but not their survival
    2. It explains the survival of the fittest but not the arrival of the fittest
    3. It denies that variations exist
    4. It says organisms produce too few offspring
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Darwin showed how the fittest survive but could not explain how new heritable variations (the fittest) arise in the first place. That gap was filled later by genetics.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Darwin's finches are an example of adaptive radiation. Reason (R): Many species with different beak shapes evolved from a single ancestral form that reached the Galapagos Islands.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Adaptive radiation means many species evolving from one ancestor into different habitats. The finches descended from one ancestor and diversified in beak shape and food, so R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery