• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Origin of life: theories and the Urey-Miller experiment

Compare the main ideas about how life began (special creation, abiogenesis, biogenesis, chemical evolution), explain the Oparin-Haldane view and describe what the Urey-Miller experiment showed.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Define evolution and name the three kinds of evolution that shaped mankind.
  • Distinguish special creation, abiogenesis, biogenesis and chemical evolution.
  • Explain the Oparin-Haldane idea of a prebiotic soup and coacervates.
  • Describe the set-up and the result of the Urey-Miller experiment.

Nobody was present when life began, so biologists cannot simply look it up. Instead they collect indirect clues from geology, chemistry and the fossil record and fit them together like pieces of a jigsaw puzzle. This first lesson of Unit II sets out the main explanations that have been proposed and the famous laboratory experiment that tested one of them.

What evolution means

Evolution is the heritable change in one or more characteristics of a population from one generation to the next. Notice two words: heritable (passed on through genes, not just changes in one lifetime) and population (individuals do not evolve; populations do). The Tamil Nadu textbook describes the present state of mankind as the result of three kinds of evolution: chemical evolution (formation of the molecules of life), organic or biological evolution (change in living forms) and social or cultural evolution (change in human ways of life).

Radiometric dating of meteorites gives the age of the solar system and of the Earth as about 4.5 to 4.6 billion years. The young Earth was far too hot for life: collisions of the small bodies (planetesimals) that came together to form it released enough heat to melt the planet. Later the surface cooled into a crust, and water vapour released from the interior condensed to form the oceans.

Four explanations compared

Main ideas about the origin of life
IdeaWhat it saysPoint to remember
Special creationLife was created by a supernatural powerA belief found in many religions; it cannot be tested by experiment
Spontaneous generation (abiogenesis)Living things arose from non-living matterThe term abiogenesis was coined by Thomas Huxley
BiogenesisLife arises only from pre-existing lifeThe textbook credits the term to Henry Bastian
Chemical evolutionThe first organisms formed step by step from inorganic substances, driven by energy sources such as lightning, UV rays and volcanic heatProposed by Oparin (1924) and Haldane (1929)

The Oparin-Haldane view

The Russian biochemist A. I. Oparin (1924) suggested that simple organic compounds on the early Earth reacted to form more complex molecules, which then gathered into colloidal droplets called coacervates in water. Coacervates could take in organic compounds from their surroundings. The British scientist J. B. S. Haldane (1929) independently proposed that the early sea acted as a huge chemical laboratory powered by sunlight. With an atmosphere that had no free oxygen, gases such as CO₂ and NH₃ under UV radiation formed organic compounds, turning the sea into a hot, dilute prebiotic soup of monomers and polymers. Haldane coined that phrase.

Both scientists agreed on two conditions: the early atmosphere had to be reducing (no free O₂), and there had to be a supply of energy such as lightning or UV light. Under these conditions many organic compounds could form without any living thing.

Chemical evolution in the Oparin-Haldane view

  1. Simple gases Methane, ammonia, hydrogen and water vapour in a reducing atmosphere
  2. Energy input Lightning, UV radiation, volcanic heat
  3. Simple organic molecules Monomers such as amino acids and sugars collect in the sea
  4. Polymers Monomers join into larger molecules in the prebiotic soup
  5. Coacervates Colloidal droplets that absorb compounds from the water
  6. First cells Pre-cells gain a membrane and become living cells

Testing the idea: the Urey-Miller experiment (1953)

Stanley Miller, working with Harold Urey, built a closed glass apparatus to imitate the early Earth. A large chamber held a mixture of methane, ammonia and hydrogen. A small flask of water was kept boiling so that steam mixed with these gases, imitating water vapour. Electric sparks from tungsten electrodes imitated lightning. A condenser cooled the gases so that water and dissolved products collected in a U-shaped tube, imitating rain falling into the sea. The system ran continuously for about a week.

When the liquid was analysed it contained amino acids, among them glycine, alanine, beta-alanine and aspartic acid. The only carbon source in the apparatus was methane, so these organic molecules must have formed from simple gases. Later experiments of the same type produced many more amino acids and also nitrogen bases.

Urey-Miller: CH₄ + NH₃ + H₂ + H₂O, energy from electric sparks, about one week, amino acids formed. Organic molecules can arise from inorganic gases without life.

Worked reasoning example 1: matching the apparatus to the early Earth

Match each part of the apparatus to what it represents. (1) Boiling water flask: the evaporating early ocean. (2) Gas chamber with CH₄, NH₃, H₂: the reducing primitive atmosphere. (3) Electrodes giving sparks: lightning as the energy source. (4) Condenser and U-tube: cooling, rain and the collecting sea. Conclusion: every part copies one condition that Oparin and Haldane said was needed.

Worked reasoning example 2: what if oxygen had been added?

Suppose a student repeats the experiment but adds plenty of free oxygen to the gas chamber. Would we expect the same result? Reasoning: Oparin and Haldane stressed a reducing atmosphere. Free oxygen oxidises methane and ammonia (for example to CO₂ and water), so the building blocks would be destroyed rather than built up into amino acids. Conclusion: the absence of free oxygen was an essential condition, which is why the original experiment used none.

Key takeaways: evolution is heritable change in a population. The Earth is about 4.5 to 4.6 billion years old. Abiogenesis says life came from non-living matter; biogenesis says life comes from life. Oparin and Haldane proposed chemical evolution in a reducing atmosphere with an energy supply, forming a prebiotic soup and coacervates. Urey and Miller (1953) produced amino acids from CH₄, NH₃, H₂ and water vapour with electric sparks.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which gas was NOT part of the gas mixture in the Urey-Miller experiment?

    1. Methane
    2. Ammonia
    3. Oxygen
    4. Hydrogen
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The apparatus imitated a reducing atmosphere, so it used methane, ammonia, hydrogen and water vapour. Free oxygen was deliberately left out because it would oxidise the starting gases.

  2. 2. The phrase 'prebiotic soup' was coined by:

    1. Oparin
    2. Haldane
    3. Huxley
    4. Miller
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Haldane (1929) pictured the early sea as a hot dilute soup of organic monomers and polymers and called it the prebiotic soup. Oparin proposed coacervates; Huxley coined abiogenesis; Miller did the 1953 experiment.

  3. 3. Coacervates are best described as:

    1. the first true bacteria
    2. fossils of early cells
    3. gases of the primitive atmosphere
    4. colloidal droplets in water that could take in organic compounds
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Oparin described coacervates as colloidal aggregates formed in water that could absorb and assimilate organic compounds. They are considered pre-cells, not true cells or fossils.

  4. 4. Which theory states that life arises only from pre-existing life?

    1. Biogenesis
    2. Abiogenesis
    3. Special creation
    4. Chemical evolution
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Biogenesis means life from life. Abiogenesis is life from non-living matter, special creation invokes a supernatural power, and chemical evolution is the stepwise formation of life from inorganic substances.

  5. 5. Assertion (A): Miller's experiment supports the possibility of chemical evolution. Reason (R): Amino acids were formed in the apparatus although methane was the only source of carbon.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true. Amino acids appeared from simple gases with methane as the only carbon source, showing organic molecules can form without living things. That is exactly why the experiment supports chemical evolution, so R explains A.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery