- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Comparing the three instruments and crossing of cheques
Compare bills of exchange, cheques and promissory notes on the textbook's bases, and explain general and special crossing under sections 123 and 124 and why crossing protects the payee.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish a bill of exchange from a cheque and from a promissory note.
- Distinguish a cheque from a promissory note.
- Explain general and special crossing and their significance.
Board questions often ask for differences between the three instruments, and many differences follow from two facts: a cheque is always drawn on a bank and payable on demand, and a promissory note is a promise by the debtor rather than an order by the creditor. If you remember those two facts, most rows of the tables below can be worked out rather than memorised.
Bill of exchange and cheque
| Basis | Bill of exchange | Cheque |
|---|---|---|
| Drawn on | Any person, including a banker | Only a specified banker |
| Payable | On demand or after a period | On demand only |
| Bearer on demand | Void (section 31 of the RBI Act) | Valid |
| Acceptance | Needed for a time bill | Not needed |
| Days of grace | Three days for a time bill | None |
| Notice of dishonour | Necessary | Not necessary |
| Sets | Foreign bills are drawn in sets of three | Not so |
| Discounting | Can be discounted with a bank | Cannot be discounted |
| Stamp | Must be stamped | Need not be stamped |
| Crossing | Cannot be crossed | Can be crossed |
| Noting and protest | Practised on dishonour | Not done |
Cheque and promissory note; bill and promissory note
| Basis | Cheque | Promissory note |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | An order to pay | An undertaking (promise) to pay |
| Parties | Three: drawer, drawee, payee | Two: maker, payee |
| Payable | On demand only | On demand or after a period |
| Crossing | Can be crossed | Cannot be crossed |
| Stamp | Not needed | Must be stamped |
| Discounting | Not possible | Possible with a banker |
| Days of grace | None | Three days |
| Bearer | May be payable to bearer | Cannot be payable to bearer |
| Basis | Bill of exchange | Promissory note |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Unconditional order | Unconditional promise |
| Who makes it | The creditor draws it on the debtor | The debtor makes it in favour of the creditor |
| Drawer as payee | Drawer and payee may be the same person | Maker cannot be the payee |
| Liability of maker | Drawer's liability is secondary (arises if the acceptor fails) | Maker's liability is primary |
| Acceptance | A time bill must be accepted | Not needed: the debtor made it |
| Notice of dishonour | Must be given to drawer and endorsers | Not needed to the maker |
Crossing of cheques
Crossing is drawing two parallel transverse lines across the face of a cheque, with or without the words 'and Co.'. Its effect is that the bank will not pay the cheque in cash across the counter; it pays only to a banker, that is, into a bank account. An 'X' mark is not a crossing, and the lines must be on the face, not the back.
Types of crossing
-
General crossing (section 123)
Two parallel transverse lines, with or without 'and Co.' or 'not negotiable'
- Lines are essential
- Paid only through some banker
-
Special crossing (section 124)
The name of a banker added across the face, with or without 'not negotiable'
- The banker's name is essential; lines are not
- Paid only to the named banker or its collecting agent
Significance: even if the payee is well known, a crossed cheque is paid only through a bank. If it is stolen and collected for the wrong person, that person can be traced through the collecting bank's records, so crossing protects against payment into wrong hands. Special crossing is safer than general crossing because payment can go only to the one named bank.
General crossing: two parallel lines are a must. Special crossing: the banker's name is a must. Both stop payment across the counter.
Worked example 1: which instrument?
Made-up facts: an instrument has three parties, is drawn on SBI's Madurai branch, is payable on demand and carries no stamp. Reasoning: three parties rule out a promissory note; a specified banker as drawee and payment only on demand point to a cheque; the absence of a stamp is consistent, since cheques need none. It is a cheque.
Worked example 2: general or special?
Made-up cheques: (a) two parallel lines with 'A/c Payee' written between them; (b) 'Indian Bank' written across the face without lines; (c) an 'X' drawn on the face. Reasoning: (a) is a general crossing, because the lines are present and no banker is named. (b) is a special crossing, because the banker's name is the essential part and lines are not needed. (c) is not a crossing at all.
Key takeaways: a cheque differs from a bill because it is drawn only on a bank, payable on demand, needs no acceptance, stamp or grace days and can be crossed; a promissory note is a debtor's promise with two parties and primary liability; general crossing needs two parallel lines and sends payment through any bank, special crossing names a bank and is safer.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which instrument can be crossed?
- Bill of exchange
- Promissory note
- Cheque
- Currency note
Show answer
Answer: C. Only a cheque can be crossed, generally or specially, to make sure payment reaches the rightful owner through a bank.
-
2. Days of grace are allowed for:
- a cheque
- a time bill of exchange
- a demand cheque crossed specially
- a currency note
Show answer
Answer: B. Three days of grace are added when finding the maturity of a time bill or a promissory note payable after a period. A cheque is payable on demand, so no grace days apply.
-
3. The essential part of a special crossing is:
- the words 'and Co.'
- the words 'not negotiable'
- two parallel lines
- the name of a banker
Show answer
Answer: D. Under section 124, the addition of a banker's name makes the crossing special; parallel lines are not essential, unlike a general crossing.
-
4. Whose liability is primary?
- The maker of a promissory note
- The drawer of a bill of exchange
- An endorser of a bill
- The payee of a cheque
Show answer
Answer: A. The maker of a promissory note is the debtor himself, so his liability is primary. The drawer of a bill is liable only if the acceptor dishonours it.
-
5. A bill of exchange payable to bearer on demand is:
- valid if stamped
- void under section 31 of the RBI Act
- a cheque
- valid if accepted
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook states that a bill payable to bearer on demand is void by virtue of section 31 of the RBI Act, whereas a cheque payable to bearer on demand is valid.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.