- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Negotiable instruments: meaning, characteristics and presumptions
Explain what a negotiable instrument is under the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, its three characteristics, the idea of a holder in due course and the presumptions the law makes.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the words 'negotiable' and 'instrument' and define a negotiable instrument.
- Describe its three characteristics, including the title of a holder in due course.
- List the presumptions that the law makes about every negotiable instrument.
Traders rarely pay large sums in coins and notes. They write documents that promise or order payment and pass these documents from hand to hand: a cheque given to a supplier, a bill of exchange drawn on a buyer, a promissory note signed by a borrower. Because such papers can travel through many hands before they are paid, the law must make it safe to accept them. In India that law is the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, which deals with three instruments: the promissory note, the bill of exchange and the cheque.
Meaning of a negotiable instrument
The word negotiable means transferable from one person to another in return for consideration (something of value). The word instrument means a written document that creates a right in favour of some person. Put together, a negotiable instrument is a written document that entitles a person to a sum of money and that can be transferred to another person either by mere delivery or by endorsement and delivery.
The Tamil Nadu textbook gives two definitions. Justice K.C. Willis described a negotiable instrument as one whose property is acquired by anyone who takes it in good faith (bona fide) and for value, notwithstanding any defect in the title of the person from whom he took it. Section 13 of the Act defines it more simply as a promissory note, bill of exchange or cheque payable either to order or to bearer.
| Payable to | How it is transferred | Example wording |
|---|---|---|
| Bearer | By mere delivery (handing it over) | 'Pay Kavitha or bearer' |
| Order | By endorsement (signing) and delivery | 'Pay Kavitha or order' |
Characteristics of a negotiable instrument
- Transferability: it passes from one person to another without formalities such as registration or affixing a separate transfer stamp. Ownership passes by delivery (bearer instrument) or by endorsement and delivery (order instrument).
- Title free from defects: a person who takes the instrument in good faith and for value is a holder in due course. His title is not spoiled by a defect in the title of an earlier holder, so he need not return it to the true owner, and defences such as fraud or misrepresentation between earlier parties do not affect him.
- Right to sue in his own name: the transferee can sue on the instrument in his own name if it is dishonoured, without first giving notice to the debtor that he is now the holder.
How a holder in due course gets a clean title
- Defect arises An earlier party has a dispute or a defect in title, for example over faulty goods.
- Instrument transferred It is passed on before maturity by endorsement and delivery.
- Taken in good faith and for value The new holder pays value and knows nothing of the defect.
- Better title The holder in due course can enforce payment; the earlier dispute is no defence against him.
Presumptions about negotiable instruments
Unless the contrary is proved, the law presumes the following about every negotiable instrument, as the textbook lists them:
- It was made, drawn, accepted, endorsed or transferred for consideration.
- If it bears a date, it was made or drawn on that date.
- It was accepted within a reasonable time after its date and before its maturity.
- It was transferred before maturity.
- The endorsements on it were made in the order in which they appear.
- A lost instrument was duly stamped.
- The holder is a holder in due course.
These presumptions shift the burden of proof. A person who claims there was no consideration, or that the holder is not a holder in due course, must prove it.
Negotiable instrument = written document + right to a sum of money + transferable by delivery (bearer) or by endorsement and delivery (order). A holder in due course gets a title better than his transferor's.
Worked example 1: the defence that fails
Made-up case: Arun sells machine parts to Basheer. Basheer accepts a bill of exchange drawn by Arun for the price. Arun endorses the bill to Charles, who pays value and knows nothing of any dispute. Later Basheer claims the parts were faulty and refuses to pay. Reasoning: Charles took the bill in good faith, for value and before maturity, so he is a holder in due course. Basheer's complaint is against Arun; it is no defence against Charles. Charles can sue Basheer in his own name.
Worked example 2: bearer or order?
Made-up case: a cheque reads 'Pay Deepa or bearer'; another reads 'Pay Deepa or order'. Reasoning: the first is a bearer instrument, so Deepa can transfer it simply by handing it over. The second is an order instrument, so Deepa must sign it (endorse it) and then deliver it to transfer it.
Key takeaways: the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 covers promissory notes, bills of exchange and cheques; section 13 calls them instruments payable to order or to bearer; their characteristics are easy transferability, a clean title for a holder in due course and the right to sue in one's own name; the law presumes consideration, correct dates, transfer before maturity, the order of endorsements, stamping and holding in due course.
Check your understanding
-
1. A person who takes a negotiable instrument in good faith and for value, before maturity, is called:
- an assignee
- a holder in due course
- an endorser
- a drawee
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook calls such a person a holder in due course. Good faith and value are the two key conditions, and his title is free from defects of earlier holders.
-
2. Under section 13 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, which three documents are negotiable instruments?
- Share certificate, debenture and bond
- Promissory note, bill of exchange and cheque
- Currency note, bank note and coin
- Invoice, receipt and voucher
Show answer
Answer: B. Section 13 defines a negotiable instrument as a promissory note, bill of exchange or cheque payable either to order or to bearer.
-
3. A cheque reads 'Pay Selvi or order'. How can Selvi transfer it?
- By mere delivery
- Only by registering the transfer
- By endorsement and delivery
- It cannot be transferred
Show answer
Answer: C. An order instrument is transferred by endorsement (the holder's signature) followed by delivery. Mere delivery is enough only for a bearer instrument.
-
4. Which of these is NOT a presumption the law makes about a negotiable instrument?
- It was made for consideration
- It was transferred before maturity
- The holder is a holder in due course
- It was transferred after maturity
Show answer
Answer: D. The law presumes transfer BEFORE maturity, not after. The other three are presumptions listed in the textbook.
-
5. Why can a holder in due course sue the acceptor even though the acceptor had a dispute with the drawer?
- Because the holder's title is free from defects of earlier parties
- Because the dispute was settled in court
- Because the acceptor gave notice to the holder
- Because every bill is registered
Show answer
Answer: A. A holder in due course takes the instrument cured of defects in the title of earlier parties, so defences between the drawer and acceptor do not affect him.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.