• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Negotiability, assignability and the bill of exchange

Distinguish negotiability from assignability, define a bill of exchange under section 5 of the Act and explain its characteristics and parties.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain negotiability and assignability and compare them on four bases.
  • Define a bill of exchange as section 5 of the Act does.
  • Identify the drawer, drawee and payee and list the characteristics of a bill.

A debt can be transferred in two very different ways. A negotiable instrument passes freely and can even give the new holder a better title than the old one had. An ordinary debt or property is assigned, and the new owner gets only what the old owner had. Knowing the difference explains why businesses prefer negotiable instruments.

Negotiability and assignability

Negotiability is the transfer of all rights in an instrument by delivery, or by endorsement and delivery, so that a bona fide transferee for value can get an even better title than the transferor had. This is the special feature of negotiable instruments. Assignability is the transfer of personal property or rights (for example a debt) from one person to another as a gift, sale or security. The assignee gets only as much title as the assignor had.

Negotiability and assignability compared (based on the textbook)
BasisNegotiabilityAssignability
Legal ownershipPasses by delivery (bearer) or by endorsement and delivery (order)Needs formalities: a written, stamped deed signed by the transferor or his agent
NoticeNo notice to the debtor is needed to claim paymentNotice of the assignment must be given to the debtor
Nature of titleA holder in due course gets a better title than the transferorThe assignee's title is subject to the assignor's defects
ConsiderationPresumedThe assignee must prove it

Bill of exchange: definition

Section 5 of the Act defines a bill of exchange as an instrument in writing containing an unconditional order, signed by the maker, directing a certain person to pay a certain sum of money only to, or to the order of, a certain person or to the bearer of the instrument. A seller (creditor) usually draws a bill on a buyer (debtor), who signs it to show acceptance.

Parties to a bill of exchange

  • Drawer The maker of the bill, usually the creditor, who orders payment
  • Drawee The person ordered to pay, usually the debtor; becomes the acceptor when he signs his acceptance
  • Payee The person who receives the money; may be the drawer himself or someone else

Characteristics of a bill of exchange

  1. It must be in writing.
  2. It must contain an order to pay, not just a request or a promise.
  3. The order must be unconditional.
  4. It must be signed by the drawer.
  5. The drawee must be named in the bill.
  6. Drawer, drawee and payee must all be certain. A bill cannot be drawn on two drawees in the alternative, because there must be no doubt about who is liable; alternative payees are allowed.
  7. The amount must be certain and stated.
  8. It may be payable on demand or after a stated period.
  9. It must comply with formalities of date, consideration and stamp.

The textbook adds a limit: a bill may be payable on demand to a person, or after a fixed period, but it cannot be payable to bearer on demand. Section 31 of the Reserve Bank of India Act reserves bearer-on-demand paper (like currency notes) for the RBI and, in the case of cheques, for orders drawn on a bank.

Negotiability gives a better title, needs no notice and presumes consideration; assignability gives the same title, needs notice and needs proof of consideration.

Worked example 1: assignment or negotiation?

Made-up case: Farida is owed ₹50,000 by Gopal on an ordinary loan agreement. She transfers the debt to Hari. Separately she endorses and delivers to Hari a cheque for ₹20,000 drawn by another customer. Reasoning: the loan debt is assigned, so Hari must give Gopal notice, must prove consideration if challenged, and takes it subject to any defence Gopal had against Farida. The cheque is negotiated, so Hari, if a holder in due course, needs no notice and takes it free from earlier defects.

Worked example 2: is it a valid bill?

Made-up drafts: (a) 'Pay Jaya ₹10,000 if the goods arrive safely' signed by Kumar; (b) 'Three months after date pay Jaya or order ₹10,000' signed by Kumar, addressed to Latha or Mani. Reasoning: (a) fails because the order is conditional. (b) fails because it is drawn on two drawees in the alternative, so it is not certain who is liable. A valid version would name Latha alone as drawee and give an unconditional order.

Key takeaways: negotiability gives a better title and is free of formalities, while assignability passes only the assignor's title and needs notice and proof of consideration; a bill of exchange is a written, unconditional, signed order on a named drawee to pay a certain sum; it has three parties and cannot be payable to bearer on demand.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Under assignability, the title of the transferee is:

    1. better than the transferor's
    2. the same as the transferor's, with its defects
    3. always free from defects
    4. decided by the bank
    Show answer

    Answer: B. An assignee gets only as much title as the assignor had, so any defect in the assignor's title passes on. A better title is a feature of negotiability.

  2. 2. Which section of the Negotiable Instruments Act defines a bill of exchange?

    1. Section 4
    2. Section 6
    3. Section 5
    4. Section 13
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Section 4 defines a promissory note, section 5 a bill of exchange, section 6 a cheque and section 13 a negotiable instrument.

  3. 3. A bill is drawn 'on Ravi or Sundar'. Why is this not valid?

    1. Alternative drawees make liability uncertain
    2. Alternative payees are not allowed
    3. A bill must have only two parties
    4. A bill must be payable on demand
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Drawees must be certain, so a bill cannot be drawn on two drawees in the alternative. Alternative payees, by contrast, are permitted.

  4. 4. For which kind of transfer must notice be given to the debtor?

    1. Negotiation of a bearer cheque
    2. Negotiation of an order bill
    3. Transfer by blank endorsement
    4. Assignment of an actionable claim
    Show answer

    Answer: D. In an assignment of an actionable claim such as a debt, notice to the debtor is necessary. Negotiation of an instrument needs no such notice.

  5. 5. In a bill of exchange, the person who is directed to pay is the:

    1. drawee
    2. drawer
    3. payee
    4. endorsee
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The drawer gives the order, the drawee is ordered to pay (and becomes the acceptor on signing), and the payee receives the money.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → The cheque and the promissory note

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery