• Practice
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Evolution of the judiciary in modern India: from Company courts to the Supreme Court

Trace the development of courts under the East India Company in Madras, Bombay and Calcutta, the reforms of Warren Hastings and Cornwallis, the High Courts of 1861, the Federal Court of 1937 and the birth of the Supreme Court in 1950.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Describe the early judicial arrangements in Madras, Bombay and Calcutta.
  • Explain the significance of the Regulating Act of 1773, the Cornwallis Code and the Indian High Courts Act of 1861.
  • Explain the role of the Federal Court and the Privy Council.
  • Place the key dates in order.

The present court system did not appear all at once. It grew over three centuries from the courts of a trading company. Madras, the forerunner of Chennai, played an early part in this story.

Madras

  • The East India Company was incorporated in 1600 by a charter of Queen Elizabeth I to regulate its trade.
  • The Charter of 1661 led to a Governor and Council in each settlement, empowered to decide civil and criminal cases by English law; disputes only among Indians continued under local traditions, as the Company preferred non-interference.
  • 1665: the first trial by jury in Madras, in the case of Mrs Ascentia Dawes, during the governorship of Foxcroft.
  • 1678: Governor Streynsham Master reorganised the system; the court of the Governor and Council became the High Court of Judicature, and English became the court language.
  • Charter of 1683: Courts of Admiralty to try crimes on the high seas.
  • Charter of 1687: the Corporation of Madras with a Mayor's Court, a court of record for the town. This charter applied only to Madras.

Bombay and Calcutta

  • Bombay: the Charter of 1668 gave the Company judicial authority; a proclamation of 1672 introduced English law (for Europeans and their interests) and a Court of Judicature for civil, criminal and testamentary cases, with Justices of the Peace for criminal matters. After the attack of the Mughal admiral Sidi Yakub, the courts were dissolved in 1690; the Court of Judicature was revived in 1718 and was respected for speedy, impartial trials although it met only once a week.
  • Calcutta: the Governor and Council had judicial powers, and the Company used the existing Mughal system. The Faujdari court under the English Collector tried criminal cases; the Collector referred civil cases to arbitrators and handled civil, criminal and revenue matters.

Charters, plans and codes

  • Charter of 1726: a Mayor's Court in each of the three Presidencies; the Charter of 1753 reformed it and organised the courts of requests, the Mayor's courts, the courts of the President and Council, and appeals to the King-in-Council.
  • Warren Hastings' Plan of 1772 regulated judicial administration; in 1780 he reorganised the provincial adalats. Under Hastings, Hindu law was codified for use in courts, and Islamic law was also codified.
  • Regulating Act of 1773: empowered the Crown to set up the Supreme Court of Judicature at Calcutta; the Charter of 1774 set out its jurisdiction. Supreme Courts followed at Madras in 1801 and Bombay in 1824.
  • Cornwallis Code, 1793: a set of regulations covering civil and criminal justice; Cornwallis reorganised the civil courts, abolished court fees and reformed the criminal courts.
  • Later Governors-General carried reform forward: Minto (from 1807) widened the courts' powers, Lord Hastings (from 1813) reduced red tape, and Bentinck abolished the provincial courts of appeal and transferred their work to district diwani adalats.
  • From 1834 to 1861 the King's courts and the Company's courts formed a dual system with separate jurisdictions.

High Courts, Federal Court and Supreme Court

  • Indian High Courts Act, 1861: the Crown set up High Courts at Calcutta, Madras and Bombay and the Supreme Courts were abolished, a landmark in the history of the High Courts.
  • Government of India Act, 1935: the shift from a unitary to a federal structure needed a federal court. The Federal Court was inaugurated in 1937, with provision for a Chief Justice and up to six judges. It was the first court with all-India jurisdiction, and its traditions of independence passed to the Supreme Court.
  • In 1921, Sir Hari Singh Gour first argued for an all-India court of final appeal in place of the Privy Council in London, which had long been the final court of appeal from India and laid down principles of Indian law that courts still follow.
  • After the Indian Independence Act, 1947, the Federal Court's jurisdiction was enlarged, and the Abolition of Privy Council Jurisdiction Act, 1949 made it the highest court in the country.
  • Between independence and 1950, new High Courts were set up, including for Punjab, Assam, Orissa, Rajasthan, Travancore, Mysore and Jammu and Kashmir. The Constitution recognised all existing High Courts and allowed Parliament to create High Courts for states or common High Courts for two or more states and union territories.
  • 26 January 1950: Article 124 established the Supreme Court of India, which succeeded the Federal Court and began sitting on 28 January 1950, in the Chamber of Princes in the Parliament building, before moving to its present building in 1958.

Milestones in the evolution of the courts

  1. 1661 Governor and Council given judicial powers
  2. 1665 First jury trial in Madras
  3. 1726 Mayor's Courts in all three Presidencies
  4. 1773 Regulating Act: Supreme Court at Calcutta
  5. 1793 Cornwallis Code
  6. 1861 High Courts at Calcutta, Madras, Bombay
  7. 1937 Federal Court inaugurated
  8. 1950 Supreme Court of India

Regulating Act 1773 = Supreme Court at Calcutta; Indian High Courts Act 1861 = three High Courts; Government of India Act 1935 = Federal Court (1937); Constitution 1950 = Supreme Court (Article 124).

Worked example: put in order

Question: arrange: (a) Federal Court inaugurated, (b) Cornwallis Code, (c) Mayor's Court in all three Presidencies, (d) Privy Council jurisdiction abolished. Working: (c) 1726, (b) 1793, (a) 1937, (d) 1949. So the order is c, b, a, d.

Worked example: which law did it?

Question: which law led to the abolition of the Supreme Courts at Calcutta, Madras and Bombay? Working: the Indian High Courts Act of 1861, which replaced them with High Courts. Do not confuse it with the Regulating Act of 1773, which created the first Supreme Court at Calcutta.

Key takeaways: Company justice began with Governors and Councils (Madras 1661, Bombay 1668), with Madras holding the first jury trial in 1665 and getting a Mayor's Court in 1687. Mayor's Courts spread to all Presidencies in 1726. The Regulating Act of 1773 created the Supreme Court at Calcutta; the Cornwallis Code (1793) reformed justice; the 1861 Act set up High Courts. The Federal Court (1937), freed from the Privy Council in 1949, was succeeded by the Supreme Court in 1950.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which Charter authorised the East India Company to exercise judicial authority over Bombay?

    1. The Charter of 1661
    2. The Charter of 1687
    3. The Charter of 1726
    4. The Charter of 1668
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Charter of 1668 gave the Company judicial authority over Bombay. The Charter of 1661 concerned the Governor and Council generally, and 1687 the Madras Corporation.

  2. 2. Which law empowered the Crown to establish the Supreme Court of Judicature at Calcutta?

    1. The Regulating Act of 1773
    2. The Charter of 1774
    3. The Cornwallis Code
    4. The Indian High Courts Act of 1861
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Regulating Act of 1773 empowered the Crown to set up the Supreme Court at Calcutta; the Charter of 1774 then set out its jurisdiction.

  3. 3. In which year was the Federal Court of India inaugurated?

    1. 1935
    2. 1947
    3. 1937
    4. 1950
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The Government of India Act, 1935 provided for it, and the Federal Court was inaugurated in 1937. It was succeeded by the Supreme Court in 1950.

  4. 4. Which Charter set up a Mayor's Court in each of the three Presidencies?

    1. The Charter of 1687
    2. The Charter of 1726
    3. The Charter of 1753
    4. The Charter of 1683
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Charter of 1687 applied only to Madras; the Charter of 1726 created Mayor's Courts in all three Presidencies; 1753 reformed them; 1683 created Admiralty courts.

  5. 5. Who first proposed, in 1921, an all-India court of final appeal in place of the Privy Council?

    1. Sir Hari Singh Gour
    2. Lord Cornwallis
    3. Warren Hastings
    4. Harilal J. Kania
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The textbook credits Sir Hari Singh Gour (1921) as the first to argue for an all-India court of final appeal to replace the Privy Council.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery