• Practice
  • About 20 min
  • 5 practice questions

Judicial review, PIL, judicial activism and the main branches of law

Explain judicial review and the basic structure doctrine, public interest litigation and judicial activism with landmark cases, and distinguish constitutional law, the rule of law, administrative law and the criminal code.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

By the end of this lesson you can

  • Explain judicial review and the basic structure doctrine.
  • Describe public interest litigation, where it is filed and the kinds of cases it covers.
  • Explain judicial activism using Article 21 cases.
  • Distinguish constitutional law from administrative law, and explain the rule of law and the Indian Penal Code.

This last lesson looks at how Indian courts use their powers: to test laws against the Constitution, to open their doors to the poor through public interest litigation, and sometimes to reshape the law through activist interpretation. It ends with the main branches of law the courts apply.

Judicial review

The Supreme Court and High Courts have the power of judicial review: they decide whether laws are constitutional and whether executive actions are legal. Laws of Parliament and of the states that violated the Constitution have been struck down. The courts extended review even to constitutional amendments through the basic structure doctrine (laid down in the Kesavananda Bharati case, 1973): an amendment that destroys or damages an essential feature of the Constitution, such as secularism, democracy or federalism, is unconstitutional. The textbook's example of review of executive action is the 2011 judgment declaring illegal the arming of tribal youths as special police officers against Maoist insurgents in Chhattisgarh.

Public interest litigation (PIL)

Normally only a person whose own right is affected can go to court. PIL relaxes this rule: any public-spirited citizen may approach the court on behalf of people who, because of poverty or disadvantage, cannot do so themselves. A PIL may be filed in the Supreme Court under Article 32, in a High Court under Article 226, or before a magistrate under Section 133 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The textbook describes PIL as an extension of the Supreme Court's jurisdiction under Article 32, not an ordinary adversarial case, and says it is filed against central or state governments and municipal authorities, not private parties.

  • Categories under the guidelines include bonded labour, neglected children, non-payment of minimum wages, complaints from jails, police refusal to register cases or harassment of women, atrocities against Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, and environmental pollution.
  • People's Union for Democratic Rights v Union of India: the Supreme Court allowed PILs by public-spirited citizens to enforce the rights of disadvantaged people.
  • Parmanand Katara v Union of India: in a PIL by a human rights activist, the Court held that every doctor has a paramount duty to give immediate medical aid to an injured person without waiting for procedural formalities.

Judicial activism

Judicial activism means courts interpreting law in its social context and going beyond older precedents to give effect to the Constitution's values. The term was introduced by Arthur Schlesinger Jr. in an article in 1947. The textbook gives two views: Black's Law Dictionary describes it as a philosophy that leads judges to depart from precedent in favour of progressive social policies, while critics use it for rulings thought to rest on judges' personal or political views rather than existing law. Its opposite is judicial restraint, where judges limit their own power. The textbook says the Indian judiciary has been more activist than its US counterpart, often through Article 21 (protection of life and personal liberty).

How judicial activism changed Article 21
CaseWhat the Court held
A. K. Gopalan v State of Madras (1950)Rejected the argument that the procedure for depriving a person of life or liberty must also be fair, just and reasonable; any procedure established by law was enough
Maneka Gandhi v Union of India (1978)Held that the procedure must be fair, just and reasonable, bringing a form of due process into Article 21 by interpretation

Branches of law

  • Constitutional law is the supreme law. It defines the roles, powers and structure of the legislature, executive and judiciary, the rights of citizens and the relationship between the Centre and the states. All other laws must conform to it.
  • Rule of law, introduced in India by the colonial regime from the English tradition, has three features: all are equal before law, nobody is above law, and the same law applies to all. It reduces nepotism, favouritism and arbitrary action, and checks abuse of authority. Procedural laws and fundamental rights enforce it.
  • Administrative law is a branch of public law dealing with the relationship between individuals and the government. It sets the organisation and powers of administrative and quasi-judicial authorities and keeps them within limits. The textbook gives four reasons for its growth in India: India is a welfare state with expanding activity; legislatures lack time to legislate for every changing need; judicial delay created the need for administrative tribunals; and, not being fully codified, it is flexible.

Constitutional law and administrative law

  • Constitutional law
    • Supreme law of the land
    • Structure of the state and its organs
    • Rights, duties, Centre-state relations
  • Administrative law
    • Subordinate to the Constitution
    • Deals only with administration
    • Keeps agencies within their powers

Indian Penal Code (IPC): India's criminal code, covering the substantive criminal law: what acts are crimes and their punishments. It was drafted in 1860 on the recommendation of the first Law Commission (set up in 1834 and associated with Thomas Babington Macaulay) and came into force in 1862. The textbook stresses its impartiality: it applies alike to officials, ordinary people and judicial officers. Note for students: the IPC has since been replaced by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, which came into force on 1 July 2024.

Judicial review tests laws and actions; the basic structure limits even amendments; PIL opens the courts to the voiceless; Article 21 became 'fair, just and reasonable' procedure through Maneka Gandhi (1978).

Worked example 1: review, PIL or activism?

(a) A court strikes down a state law that discriminates by religion. (b) A citizen writes to the Supreme Court about bonded labourers in a quarry, and the Court treats it as a petition. (c) The Court reads the right to life to include living with dignity. Working: (a) judicial review of legislation; (b) public interest litigation, filed on behalf of people unable to approach the court; (c) judicial activism, widening Article 21 by interpretation.

Worked example 2: which branch of law?

(a) A rule that says how a tribunal must hear a pension dispute. (b) The provision that Parliament consists of the President and two Houses. (c) The punishment for theft. Working: (a) administrative law; (b) constitutional law (Article 79); (c) criminal law, formerly in the IPC and now in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita.

Key takeaways: courts review laws, executive actions and even amendments, which may not damage the basic structure. PIL lets public-spirited citizens seek justice for the disadvantaged under Articles 32 and 226 and Section 133 CrPC. Judicial activism, a term from Schlesinger (1947), changed Article 21 from Gopalan to Maneka Gandhi. Constitutional law is supreme; the rule of law means equality before law; administrative law controls the administration; the IPC of 1860 has been replaced by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Under the basic structure doctrine, which of the following can the courts strike down?

    1. Only state laws
    2. Only executive orders
    3. A constitutional amendment that damages an essential feature of the Constitution
    4. Only laws passed before 1950
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Judicial review extends to constitutional amendments: one that destroys an essential feature such as secularism, democracy or federalism is unconstitutional.

  2. 2. A public interest litigation can be filed before a magistrate under which provision?

    1. Article 32
    2. Section 133 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
    3. Article 226
    4. Article 143
    Show answer

    Answer: B. PILs go to the Supreme Court under Article 32, a High Court under Article 226, or a magistrate under Section 133 CrPC. Article 143 is advisory jurisdiction.

  3. 3. Which case held that the procedure for depriving a person of life or liberty must be fair, just and reasonable?

    1. Gopalan v State of Madras
    2. Parmanand Katara v Union of India
    3. Kesavananda Bharati case
    4. Maneka Gandhi v Union of India
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Maneka Gandhi (1978) introduced the 'fair, just and reasonable' requirement into Article 21, reversing the narrow view of A. K. Gopalan (1950).

  4. 4. Which is a feature of the rule of law as described in the textbook?

    1. Nobody is above the law
    2. The ruler's word is final
    3. Punishment depends on status
    4. Courts are controlled by the executive
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The rule of law means all are equal before law, nobody is above law and the same law applies to all.

  5. 5. Who introduced the term 'judicial activism' in 1947?

    1. Thomas Babington Macaulay
    2. Dr B. R. Ambedkar
    3. Arthur Schlesinger Jr.
    4. Harilal J. Kania
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Arthur Schlesinger Jr. introduced the term in a 1947 article on the US Supreme Court. Macaulay is linked with the first Law Commission and the Indian Penal Code.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery