- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
The Supreme Court of India: organisation, jurisdiction and independence
Explain India's integrated three-tier judiciary and sources of law, the Supreme Court's original, appellate and advisory jurisdiction, how judges are appointed and removed, and the safeguards of judicial independence.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain the three-tier, integrated judicial system and the sources of law.
- Describe the Supreme Court's original, writ, appellate and advisory jurisdiction.
- State the qualifications, appointment, retirement and removal of Supreme Court judges.
- List the factors that protect the independence of the judiciary.
The Supreme Court is the guardian of the Constitution, the arbiter of disputes between the Union and the states, the protector of fundamental rights and the highest court of appeal. This lesson looks at how it is organised and what it can do.
An integrated, three-tier judiciary
The Constitution provides for (1) the Supreme Court, (2) the High Courts in the states, and (3) District and Sessions Courts in each judicial district. Unlike the USA, which has separate federal and state court systems, India has a single integrated judiciary with the Supreme Court at the apex and authority over all other courts. Dr B. R. Ambedkar explained, as the textbook quotes him, that India's federation is a dual polity without a dual judiciary: one system of courts gives remedies under constitutional, civil and criminal law alike, so that procedure is uniform.
Sources of law
- The Constitution: the fountain source of law.
- Statutes made by Parliament and the state and union territory legislatures, as long as they conform to the Constitution.
- Subordinate legislation: rules, regulations and bye-laws of administrative bodies, unless the courts set them aside.
Jurisdiction and powers
| Jurisdiction | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Original | Cases that can begin only in the Supreme Court: disputes between the Government of India and one or more states, or between two or more states |
| Writ (fundamental rights) | Under Article 32 it can issue habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari and quo warranto; in rights cases it has both original and appellate jurisdiction |
| Appellate | Highest court of appeal against High Court judgments in civil and criminal cases |
| Advisory (Article 143) | The President may seek its opinion on a question of law or fact of public importance; the advice is not binding |
| Guardian of the Constitution | Final interpreter; can declare laws, executive actions and lower-court judgments null and void if against the Constitution |
Organisation
- The Supreme Court is set up under Part V, Chapter IV of the Constitution; Articles 124 to 147 deal with its composition and jurisdiction.
- Originally there was a Chief Justice and seven other judges; Parliament may increase the number and has done so several times. According to the textbook, by 2019 the strength was 34 judges including the Chief Justice.
- Appointment: judges are appointed by the President. Under the collegium system, the Chief Justice of India consults the four senior-most judges, and the collegium decides by consensus.
- Qualifications: a citizen of India who has been a High Court judge for at least 5 years, or an advocate of a High Court (or of two or more High Courts in succession) for at least 10 years, or a distinguished jurist in the opinion of the President.
- Tenure: a judge holds office until 65 years of age and may resign by writing to the President.
- Removal: only by an order of the President after an address by each House of Parliament, supported by a majority of the total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting, in the same session, on the ground of proved misbehaviour or incapacity.
The first Chief Justice was Harilal J. Kania; the first bench also included Justices Fazl Ali, M. Patanjali Sastri, Mehr Chand Mahajan, B. K. Mukherjea and S. R. Das. The textbook also notes that in 2007 Justice K. G. Balakrishnan became the first Chief Justice from a Scheduled Caste community.
Independence of the judiciary
Judges can protect rights against the government only if the government cannot pressure them. The Constitution protects their independence in several ways:
- security of tenure: removal only by the difficult parliamentary procedure, on proved misbehaviour or incapacity;
- fixed retirement age (65 for the Supreme Court, 62 for High Courts);
- salaries and allowances charged on the Consolidated Fund, not voted on, and not reduced to a judge's disadvantage except in a financial emergency;
- the conduct of judges cannot be discussed in Parliament or state legislatures except during a removal motion;
- retired Supreme Court judges may not practise before any court in India;
- the power to punish for contempt of court;
- the Directive Principles ask the state to separate the judiciary from the executive.
Supreme Court jurisdiction
-
Original
- Centre vs states
- State vs state
-
Writs
- Article 32
- Five writs for rights
-
Appellate
- Civil
- Criminal
- Constitutional
-
Advisory
- Article 143
- Not binding
Supreme Court judges: appointed by the President on the collegium's recommendation, retire at 65, removed only by an address of both Houses (majority of total membership and two-thirds present and voting).
Worked example 1: which jurisdiction?
(a) Tamil Nadu and Karnataka dispute a matter between them. (b) A person illegally detained by the police petitions the Supreme Court. (c) The President asks the Court whether a proposed law would be valid. (d) A party loses in the High Court and appeals. Working: (a) original; (b) writ jurisdiction under Article 32 (habeas corpus); (c) advisory under Article 143; (d) appellate.
Worked example 2: is the judge removed?
A made-up Lok Sabha of 540 members votes on a motion to remove a judge: 400 present and voting, 280 in favour. Working: (1) majority of total membership: more than 270, and 280 passes. (2) two-thirds of present and voting: 2/3 × 400 ≈ 266.7, so at least 267; 280 passes. The Lok Sabha's address succeeds, but the Rajya Sabha must pass it by the same special majority in the same session before the President can order removal.
Key takeaways: India has one integrated, three-tier judiciary under the Supreme Court; law flows from the Constitution, statutes and subordinate legislation. The Supreme Court has original, writ, appellate and advisory jurisdiction and is the final interpreter of the Constitution. Judges are appointed by the President through the collegium, retire at 65 and are removed only by a special majority of both Houses. Security of tenure, protected salaries and contempt powers keep the judiciary independent.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which Article allows the President to seek the advisory opinion of the Supreme Court?
- Article 32
- Article 226
- Article 124
- Article 143
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 143 gives the Supreme Court advisory jurisdiction; its advice is not binding on the President. Article 32 deals with writs, 226 with High Court writs and 124 establishes the Court.
-
2. A dispute between the Government of India and a state falls under which jurisdiction of the Supreme Court?
- Appellate
- Original
- Advisory
- Writ
Show answer
Answer: B. Disputes between the Union and one or more states, or between states, can begin only in the Supreme Court: its original jurisdiction.
-
3. Until what age does a judge of the Supreme Court hold office?
- 62 years
- 60 years
- 65 years
- 70 years
Show answer
Answer: C. Supreme Court judges retire at 65; High Court judges retire at 62.
-
4. Which is NOT a qualification for appointment as a Supreme Court judge?
- Ten years as a member of Parliament
- Five years as a High Court judge
- Ten years as an advocate of a High Court
- Being a distinguished jurist in the President's opinion
Show answer
Answer: A. The qualifications are citizenship plus five years as a High Court judge, ten years as a High Court advocate, or being a distinguished jurist. Service as an MP is not a qualification.
-
5. How does India's judiciary differ from that of the USA?
- India has separate federal and state courts
- India has a single integrated judiciary with the Supreme Court at the apex
- India has no High Courts
- India's courts cannot review laws
Show answer
Answer: B. The USA has two sets of courts, federal and state. India has one integrated judiciary, as Dr Ambedkar explained, with the Supreme Court over all courts.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.