Revision notes

Unit 4 Indian Judiciary: Foundation

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

The judiciary and justice in ancient and medieval India

The six courts at the capital of the Sultanate, as listed in the textbook
Court at the capitalRole
King's CourtPresided over by the Sultan; original and appellate jurisdiction; highest court of appeal; the Sultan was assisted by muftis (legal experts)
Diwan-al-MazalimHighest court of appeal in criminal matters
Diwan-e-RisalatHighest court of appeal in civil matters
Sadr-e-Jahan's CourtHeaded by the Sadr-e-Jahan, who became the de facto head of the judiciary
Chief Justice's CourtCivil and criminal cases; staffed by a mufti, pandit, mohtasib (prosecutions) and dadbak (administration)
Diwan-e-SiyasatCases of high treason

Old systems and the modern idea

  • Ancient and medieval
    • Judiciary joined to the executive
    • Ruler's word final
    • Punishment varied by status
    • Ordeals as proof
  • Modern constitutional
    • Independent judiciary
    • Constitution is supreme
    • Equality before law
    • Evidence and fair procedure

Key takeaways: the judiciary interprets law, protects rights and the Constitution, and in a federation settles Centre-state disputes. In ancient India the king was the fountain of justice, local bodies and guilds settled most disputes, ordeals were used, and in the textbook's account the smritis tied punishment to caste and gender, while Asoka's rule was more humane. The Sultanate separated civil and criminal justice and had six courts at the capital, headed in practice by the Qazi-ul-Quzat and later the Sadr-e-Jahan.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Evolution of the judiciary in modern India: from Company courts to the Supreme Court

Milestones in the evolution of the courts

  1. 1661 Governor and Council given judicial powers
  2. 1665 First jury trial in Madras
  3. 1726 Mayor's Courts in all three Presidencies
  4. 1773 Regulating Act: Supreme Court at Calcutta
  5. 1793 Cornwallis Code
  6. 1861 High Courts at Calcutta, Madras, Bombay
  7. 1937 Federal Court inaugurated
  8. 1950 Supreme Court of India

Regulating Act 1773 = Supreme Court at Calcutta; Indian High Courts Act 1861 = three High Courts; Government of India Act 1935 = Federal Court (1937); Constitution 1950 = Supreme Court (Article 124).

Key takeaways: Company justice began with Governors and Councils (Madras 1661, Bombay 1668), with Madras holding the first jury trial in 1665 and getting a Mayor's Court in 1687. Mayor's Courts spread to all Presidencies in 1726. The Regulating Act of 1773 created the Supreme Court at Calcutta; the Cornwallis Code (1793) reformed justice; the 1861 Act set up High Courts. The Federal Court (1937), freed from the Privy Council in 1949, was succeeded by the Supreme Court in 1950.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

The Supreme Court of India: organisation, jurisdiction and independence

JurisdictionWhat it covers
OriginalCases that can begin only in the Supreme Court: disputes between the Government of India and one or more states, or between two or more states
Writ (fundamental rights)Under Article 32 it can issue habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari and quo warranto; in rights cases it has both original and appellate jurisdiction
AppellateHighest court of appeal against High Court judgments in civil and criminal cases
Advisory (Article 143)The President may seek its opinion on a question of law or fact of public importance; the advice is not binding
Guardian of the ConstitutionFinal interpreter; can declare laws, executive actions and lower-court judgments null and void if against the Constitution

Supreme Court jurisdiction

  • Original
    • Centre vs states
    • State vs state
  • Writs
    • Article 32
    • Five writs for rights
  • Appellate
    • Civil
    • Criminal
    • Constitutional
  • Advisory
    • Article 143
    • Not binding

Supreme Court judges: appointed by the President on the collegium's recommendation, retire at 65, removed only by an address of both Houses (majority of total membership and two-thirds present and voting).

Key takeaways: India has one integrated, three-tier judiciary under the Supreme Court; law flows from the Constitution, statutes and subordinate legislation. The Supreme Court has original, writ, appellate and advisory jurisdiction and is the final interpreter of the Constitution. Judges are appointed by the President through the collegium, retire at 65 and are removed only by a special majority of both Houses. Security of tenure, protected salaries and contempt powers keep the judiciary independent.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

High Courts, writs and subordinate courts

Writs issued by the Supreme Court (Article 32) and High Courts (Article 226)
WritMeaningWhen it is used
Habeas corpus'Produce the body'A person is said to be illegally detained; the court orders the detained person to be produced and released if detention is unlawful. Protects personal liberty.
Mandamus'We command'An authority, officer, government or even a judicial body fails to perform a public or legal duty; the court orders it to act
Prohibition'To forbid'A higher court stops a lower court or tribunal from exceeding its jurisdiction; only against judicial or quasi-judicial bodies
Certiorari'To be informed'A higher court quashes an illegal order already made by a lower court or quasi-judicial body
Quo warranto'By what authority?'Tests whether a person holding a public office is legally entitled to it

Courts in a state

  • High Court
    • Original and appellate
    • Writs under Article 226
    • Superintendence
  • District and Sessions Court
    • Civil (district judge)
    • Criminal (sessions judge)
  • Lower courts
    • Munsif and magistrate courts
  • Lok Adalat
    • Settlement by agreement
    • Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987

Habeas corpus frees, mandamus commands, prohibition forbids before, certiorari quashes after, quo warranto asks 'by what right?'.

Key takeaways: High Court judges are appointed by the President after consulting the Chief Justice of India and the Governor, need ten years of judicial office or advocacy, and retire at 62. High Courts have original and appellate jurisdiction, superintendence over lower courts and writ powers under Article 226. The five writs are habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari and quo warranto. District and lower courts handle most cases, and Lok Adalats settle disputes by agreement under the 1987 Act.

Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Judicial review, PIL, judicial activism and the main branches of law

How judicial activism changed Article 21
CaseWhat the Court held
A. K. Gopalan v State of Madras (1950)Rejected the argument that the procedure for depriving a person of life or liberty must also be fair, just and reasonable; any procedure established by law was enough
Maneka Gandhi v Union of India (1978)Held that the procedure must be fair, just and reasonable, bringing a form of due process into Article 21 by interpretation

Constitutional law and administrative law

  • Constitutional law
    • Supreme law of the land
    • Structure of the state and its organs
    • Rights, duties, Centre-state relations
  • Administrative law
    • Subordinate to the Constitution
    • Deals only with administration
    • Keeps agencies within their powers

Judicial review tests laws and actions; the basic structure limits even amendments; PIL opens the courts to the voiceless; Article 21 became 'fair, just and reasonable' procedure through Maneka Gandhi (1978).

Key takeaways: courts review laws, executive actions and even amendments, which may not damage the basic structure. PIL lets public-spirited citizens seek justice for the disadvantaged under Articles 32 and 226 and Section 133 CrPC. Judicial activism, a term from Schlesinger (1947), changed Article 21 from Gopalan to Maneka Gandhi. Constitutional law is supreme; the rule of law means equality before law; administrative law controls the administration; the IPC of 1860 has been replaced by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.

Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery