- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
India after reorganisation: borders, resources, regional parties and new states
Explain the problems India faced after reorganising its states: balancing the Centre and the states, sharing resources, language and border disputes, the rise of regional parties, and how Parliament forms new states under Article 3.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Explain why Nehru and Patel were cautious about further division after partition.
- Describe the challenges of resources, language minorities, borders and regional parties after reorganisation.
- Outline the procedure for forming a new state under Article 3 of the Constitution.
Redrawing the map did not end the story. New states brought new questions: who gets which river, which language is used in a district office, and how much power should a state have against the Centre? This lesson looks at India after reorganisation, as the textbook presents it.
From colonial units to a new map
During colonial rule there were about 600 administrative units, including the princely states, according to the textbook. The present units were formed between 1947 and 1950, and some, such as Mysore, Hyderabad and Bhopal, at first kept their British-era boundaries. Colonial provinces had ignored local language, history and culture; the new map tried to give states cultural identity, linguistic individuality, economic viability and administrative convenience. The textbook notes that the many agitations made it clear that the Centre was stronger than the states.
Nehru and Patel, having seen the pain of partition, did not want the country divided further on religion, language or ethnicity. They had a vision of a plural yet unified nation. So their caution about reorganisation came, the textbook says, from past experience.
Challenges after reorganisation
- Resources: states differed in size and power. Smaller states feared that larger ones would control resources, so the Centre tried to balance developed and underdeveloped states through capital, development projects and jobs.
- Language and minorities: language alone could not be the only criterion, because it privileged some languages over others. The textbook names the Bodos in Assam and the Coorgis in Karnataka as examples of communities raising questions of identity. Dominant linguistic groups sometimes imposed their language in administration, education, employment and courts, and states had to protect linguistic minorities.
- Recognised languages: the textbook notes that the number of languages recognised in the Constitution grew over time; the Eighth Schedule began with 14 and now lists 22, showing growing demands for recognition.
- Borders: boundaries had to be negotiated, for example between Karnataka and Maharashtra, Maharashtra and Gujarat, Haryana and Punjab, Odisha and West Bengal, and Andhra Pradesh and parts of the Madras Presidency.
- Regional parties: region-based identity movements and regional loyalty gave rise to regional parties. Because grassroots problems differ across the country, the textbook says this posed new challenges for the Centre.
- Two cultures: despite efforts at uniformity, the textbook says an elite culture and a mass culture emerged.
The textbook concludes that the undercurrent of the demand for new states lies in access to resources and, more importantly, in asserting identity.
How a new state is formed: Article 3
Under Article 3 of the Constitution, Parliament may by law form a new state by separating territory from a state or uniting states or parts of states, increase or reduce the area of a state, and alter its boundaries or name. The procedure is:
Forming a new state under Article 3
- President's recommendation A bill can be introduced in Parliament only on the President's recommendation
- Reference to the state The President refers the bill to the legislature of the state concerned to express its views within a fixed period
- State's views The state legislature gives its views; Parliament is not bound to accept them
- Parliament passes the law By a simple majority in both Houses
- Assent and new state The President gives assent and the change takes effect
The textbook's own description of this procedure differs in detail (it speaks of the state assembly 'passing' the bill first); the order shown above follows the text of Article 3, and your teacher will confirm what the board expects. The textbook's example is the bifurcation of Andhra Pradesh by an Act of Parliament in 2014, which created Telangana.
Article 3: Parliament can form new states and alter areas, boundaries or names, on the President's recommendation and after hearing the views of the state legislature concerned.
Worked example 1: name the challenge
Match each made-up headline to a challenge. (a) 'Two neighbouring states argue over a border village.' (b) 'Speakers of a small language demand schooling in their mother tongue.' (c) 'Small hill state says big neighbour takes most river water.' Working: (a) is a border dispute; (b) concerns linguistic minorities; (c) concerns access to resources, the fear of smaller states that the textbook describes.
Worked example 2: can a state block its own division?
A made-up state assembly opposes a bill to split the state. Is the bill dead? Reasoning: under Article 3 the state's views must be sought, but Parliament is not bound by them. Parliament can still pass the law by simple majority. This shows why the textbook says the Centre is stronger than the states in matters of reorganisation.
Key takeaways: after reorganisation India faced questions of resource sharing between large and small states, linguistic minorities, border disputes and the rise of regional parties. Nehru and Patel favoured a plural but united India. Under Article 3 Parliament can create new states and change boundaries and names, after hearing the state concerned, as with Telangana in 2014.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, what lies at the root of the continuing demands for new states?
- Only the wish for more holidays
- Access to resources and, more importantly, asserting identity
- Foreign pressure
- The gun salute system
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says the undercurrent of the strife for a separate state lies in access to resources and, more importantly, in asserting identity.
-
2. Which body has the power to form a new state under Article 3?
- The state legislature concerned
- The Supreme Court
- Parliament
- The Election Commission
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 3 gives Parliament power, by law, to form new states and change areas, boundaries and names. The state legislature only expresses its views.
-
3. Which of these communities does the textbook mention when discussing the tension between national and linguistic-cultural identity?
- Bodos in Assam
- Rajputs in Gwalior
- Nawabs of Loharu
- Razakars of Hyderabad
Show answer
Answer: A. The textbook names the Bodos in Assam and the Coorgis in Karnataka as communities raising questions of linguistic-cultural identity.
-
4. A state legislature rejects a bill that would change its boundary. What follows under Article 3?
- The bill automatically lapses
- The Governor decides the matter
- A national referendum is held
- Parliament may still pass the law, since the state's views are not binding
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 3 requires the President to refer the bill to the state legislature for its views, but those views do not bind Parliament.
-
5. Why were Nehru and Patel cautious about reorganising states on linguistic lines soon after independence?
- They wanted to keep the gun salute system
- After the pain of partition they did not want further division on the basis of identity
- They wanted to return provinces to the British
- They preferred a single state for the whole country
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says the experience of partition made them wary of dividing the country further on religion, language or ethnicity; they wanted a plural, unified nation.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.