- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
State, nation and the social, economic and political challenges of nation building
Distinguish between a state and a nation, explain nationality and Renan's idea of a nation, and describe the economic, political and social challenges of nation building that the textbook identifies.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Distinguish a state from a nation and explain the idea of nationality.
- Summarise the textbook's account of planning, liberalisation and economic challenges in agriculture and industry.
- Explain the political and social challenges: inter-state inequality, Union-state relations, communalism, caste and gender discrimination, and inclusive growth.
Uniting territory is only the first step. A nation is built when people feel they belong together and when development reaches everyone. This lesson asks what a nation is, and then looks at the challenges the textbook sees in making India one.
State and nation
| State | Nation |
|---|---|
| Exists where there is a territory, a people, a government and sovereignty | Emphasises a consciousness of unity among a people |
| May exist even without a feeling of oneness among the people | In the older view, a nation need not be a state |
| A legal-political organisation | From the Latin 'nasci' (to be born): first suggested common birth or descent |
Nationality is hard to define because no single factor explains it. It is a sentiment of unity produced by many forces: common race and language, geographical unity, common religion, shared political aspirations and, above all, historical development. Some thinkers stress common economic life, language and territory. The French thinker Ernest Renan described a nation as a 'soul' or spiritual principle with two parts: a shared legacy of memories from the past, and present-day consent, the desire to go on living together.
The textbook also refers to a letter by Nehru to Chief Ministers in 1953, after the first ascent of Everest. In his own words, Nehru warned against a petty, narrow nationalism that argued over whether Tenzing or Hillary reached the top first; great achievements, he said, come from the combined efforts of many people.
Economic challenges
The textbook says the task was not only to increase production but to reduce disparities. Nehru preferred a planned, mixed economy to build a self-reliant modern nation. Five-year plans brought irrigation, basic industries, electrification and infrastructure, and helped control diseases such as malaria, reach self-sufficiency in food and develop science and technology. Signs of recession in the late 1960s and early 1970s, and wars with China and Pakistan, added to difficulties. Bank nationalisation and the electronics revolution brought positive change, and around 1991 India adopted a market-oriented New Economic Policy of Liberalisation, Privatisation and Globalisation (LPG).
- Agriculture: the textbook describes a decline since the mid-1990s, farmers' distress (it names cotton growers in Vidarbha) and falling public investment, and warns of a second agrarian crisis (the first being in the early 1960s).
- Industry: according to the textbook, the Industrial Disputes Act protects less than 10 per cent of the workforce, so most workers are in the unorganised sector; industry is capital-intensive, and work is becoming informal and casual.
- Land acquisition: industry needs more land, causing displacement of tribal people. The textbook argues that acquisition should be based on the consent of local people and preceded by compensation and welfare measures.
Political and social challenges
- Inter-state inequality: after 1991, as central funding of states fell, states had to attract private investment; some succeeded and some did not, so development became uneven.
- Union-state relations: as more states came to be ruled by parties different from the one at the Centre, the textbook says states asked for more autonomy, a greater role for the Inter-State Council and a larger share of finances.
- Poverty and human development: poverty declined, but primary education and health lag behind, and the textbook argues that inclusive growth would have reduced poverty faster.
- Communalism: communal violence since partition, fed by 'narratives of hatred'; minorities often suffer loss of property and livelihood.
- Caste discrimination: untouchability persists despite strict laws, and so-called honour killings strike at inter-caste marriages.
- Gender discrimination: women's political representation is low and violence against women is a concern; the textbook notes that one-third reservation for women in legislatures had not yet come into effect when it was written.
The textbook concludes that the greatest challenge is inclusive growth: the gains of growth have gone more to the middle and richer classes than to the poor, and reforms in telecom, banking, markets and airlines were not matched by progress in agriculture and human development.
Challenges of nation building (textbook's grouping)
-
Economic
- Reducing disparities
- Agrarian distress
- Unorganised labour
- Land acquisition
-
Political
- Inter-state inequality
- Union-state relations
- Regional demands for autonomy
-
Social
- Communalism
- Caste discrimination
- Gender discrimination
- Health and education
A state needs territory, people, government and sovereignty; a nation needs a shared feeling of unity. Renan: a nation rests on shared memories and the present will to live together.
Worked example 1: state, nation or both?
(a) A made-up people share a language, history and festivals, but are spread over three countries and have no government of their own. (b) A made-up country has territory, a government and sovereignty, but its regions feel no common bond. Working: (a) has the consciousness of unity but no sovereignty: a nation, not a state. (b) has all four elements of a state but lacks the sentiment of nationality: a state that is not yet a nation.
Worked example 2: classify the challenge
Sort these made-up news items. (a) Farmers in a district cannot get formal loans. (b) Two states quarrel over their share of central taxes. (c) A village refuses water to a family of another caste. Working: (a) is an economic (agrarian) challenge; (b) is political (Union-state financial relations); (c) is social (caste discrimination).
Key takeaways: a state is a legal-political unit with territory, people, government and sovereignty; a nation is a people conscious of unity. Renan stressed shared memory and present consent. India's nation-building challenges, in the textbook's account, are economic (disparities, agriculture, informal work, land acquisition), political (uneven development, Union-state relations) and social (communalism, caste and gender discrimination), with inclusive growth as the central task.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of the following can exist even without a feeling of oneness among its people, according to the textbook?
- A nation
- A nationality
- A state
- A community of memories
Show answer
Answer: C. A state exists where there is territory, people, government and sovereignty; it may lack the feeling of nationality and still remain a state.
-
2. The word 'nation' comes from the Latin 'nasci', which means
- to rule
- to be born
- to unite
- to vote
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says 'nation' derives from the past participle of 'nasci', to be born, so it first conveyed common birth or blood ties.
-
3. According to Ernest Renan, what two things make up the 'soul' of a nation?
- A shared legacy of memories and the present consent to live together
- A common army and a common currency
- One religion and one language
- A king and a parliament
Show answer
Answer: A. Renan said one part is in the past (a rich legacy of shared memories) and one in the present (actual consent, the desire to live together).
-
4. What does the textbook see as the major challenge for India's development?
- Increasing the number of states
- Restoring the princely states
- Ending all industry
- Inclusive growth
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook says the major challenge is inclusive growth, because the gains of growth have gone more to the middle and richer classes than to the poor.
-
5. The textbook argues that land acquisition for industry should be
- carried out by force for speed
- based on the consent of local people and preceded by compensation and welfare measures
- left entirely to private companies
- banned completely
Show answer
Answer: B. The textbook says industrial land acquisition needs the consent of local people and should be preceded by compensation and welfare measures, noting that forced acquisition has caused unrest.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.