- Practice
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Integration of the princely states
Explain what princely states were, how the gun salute system ranked them, and how Sardar Patel and V. P. Menon integrated them, including the cases of Junagadh, Hyderabad, Jodhpur and Kashmir as the textbook describes them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
By the end of this lesson you can
- Define a princely state and explain the difference between salute and non-salute states.
- Describe the roles of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel and V. P. Menon in integration.
- Summarise the textbook's account of Junagadh, Hyderabad, Jodhpur and Kashmir.
In August 1947 India became free, but its map was not yet one piece. Hundreds of territories ruled by princes stood between and inside the British provinces. Bringing them together peacefully was one of the first and greatest challenges of nation building. This lesson follows the Tamil Nadu textbook's account of how it was done.
What was a princely state?
A princely state (or native state) was a political unit ruled by a monarchic family, or one bound in a subsidiary alliance with a more powerful monarchic government. These smaller pockets reflected local political, cultural, linguistic and geographical conditions. Some were ruled by Rajput princes, some by Nawabs and Nizams, and some by native dynasties such as Mysore, Travancore and Pudukottai. All the monarchical states subordinate to British India were called princely states; the textbook notes that the word 'princely' was kept deliberately to show the rulers' subordination to the British Crown. The textbook also reminds us that earlier rulers, from the Magadhan and Mauryan kings to the Guptas, had tried to unite many small kingdoms, but lasting consolidation under one rule was never achieved.
The gun salute system
According to the textbook there were 565 princely states before independence. The British gun salute system openly signalled each state's rank and its closeness to the British. About 117 to 120 were salute states, whose rulers were greeted with gun salutes: a 21-gun salute was the highest honour (for example the rulers of Gwalior, Baroda, Jammu and Kashmir, Mysore, and the Nizam of Hyderabad), and the lowest was 9 guns. The rest were non-salute states: some were not recognised as salute states, some were considered of lower prestige, and some had become obsolete though their rulers kept royal entitlements and pensions.
| Salute states | Non-salute states |
|---|---|
| About 117-120 of the 565 states | The large majority of the 565 states |
| Rulers greeted with 9 to 21 guns, showing rank and honour | No gun salute |
| 21 guns for the highest rank, such as Mysore and Hyderabad | Lower prestige, unrecognised, or obsolete states with pensioned rulers |
Patel, Menon and integration
Many princes enjoyed British patronage and did not want to lose their privileges; some hoped to become independent. Negotiations to merge the states began in April 1947, amid partition, communal riots and a refugee crisis. After independence, Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister, led the work with his secretary V. P. Menon, an experienced civil servant who had served the last three viceroys and did the groundwork. They persuaded rulers to join the Indian Constituent Assembly and promised that their personal assets would not be taken over. Most states agreed. The textbook names Junagadh, Hyderabad and Kashmir as states that wanted to remain independent, and also describes Jodhpur.
Four difficult cases in the textbook
-
Junagadh
- Majority of people non-Muslim
- Ruler's side declared for Pakistan on 15 August 1947
- People protested and asked India to take over
- Dewan Shah Nawaz Bhutto left for Karachi
-
Hyderabad
- Large state in the heart of India
- Nizam wanted independence; told it could not be a dominion
- Razakars of Kasim Razvi's organisation caused violence
- Indian troops entered in September 1948
-
Jodhpur
- Maharaja Hanvant Singh leaned towards Pakistan
- Patel offered arms imports, a rail link and famine grain
- Maharaja agreed to join India
-
Kashmir
- Maharaja Hari Singh proposed a standstill agreement
- Asked India for military help
- Signed the Instrument of Accession on 26 October 1947
- Indian army reached Srinagar on 27 October 1947
Two further points from the textbook: the Telangana peasant uprising against landlords in Hyderabad formed the background to the Bhoodan ('gift of land') movement started by Vinoba Bhave, a disciple of Gandhi, who urged landowners to give land voluntarily to the landless. And in Kashmir, Lord Mountbatten advised that under international law India could send troops only after the state signed the Instrument of Accession; the textbook states that once it was signed, the army reached Srinagar and pushed the invading forces out of the Kashmir valley.
The Instrument of Accession was the legal document by which a ruler joined India. Patel and Menon used persuasion, guarantees to the rulers and, where necessary, firmness to bring about integration.
Worked example 1: salute or non-salute?
A made-up ruler receives an 11-gun salute when he visits the Viceroy. Another made-up state has no gun salute and its ruler draws a British pension. Working: the first is a salute state; 11 guns lies between the minimum of 9 and the highest honour of 21, so he holds a middle rank. The second is a non-salute state of the third type in the textbook: obsolete, but with royal entitlements and a pension.
Worked example 2: why did Jodhpur choose India?
Reasoning from the textbook: the Maharaja was tempted by an offer from Pakistan. Patel answered with a better offer (arms imports, a rail link between Jodhpur and Kathiawar, and grain for farmers during famine). The Maharaja also feared communal violence because most of his people were Hindus. So both a practical offer and concern for the people's wishes shaped his decision.
Key takeaways: princely states were monarchic units subordinate to the British Crown; of 565, about 117 to 120 were salute states ranked from 9 to 21 guns. Patel and V. P. Menon integrated them through negotiation and guarantees. Junagadh, Hyderabad, Jodhpur and Kashmir were difficult cases; Kashmir acceded through the Instrument of Accession signed on 26 October 1947.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to the textbook, how many princely states were there in pre-independence India?
- 117
- 14
- 600
- 565
Show answer
Answer: D. The textbook gives 565 princely states, of which about 117 to 120 were salute states. About 600 is the textbook's figure for all administrative units in colonial India.
-
2. What did a 21-gun salute indicate?
- The ruler had the largest army
- The state had no ruler
- The highest honour and prestige granted to a ruler by the British
- The ruler had joined Pakistan
Show answer
Answer: C. The number of guns showed the honour and prestige granted to a ruler; 21 was the highest and 9 the lowest.
-
3. Who was the secretary who did the groundwork for integrating the princely states with Sardar Patel?
- Hridayanath Kunzru
- K. M. Panikkar
- V. P. Menon
- Kasim Razvi
Show answer
Answer: C. V. P. Menon, a civil servant who had served the last three viceroys, worked with Patel. Panikkar and Kunzru were members of the States Reorganisation Commission; Razvi led the Razakars.
-
4. On what date did Maharaja Hari Singh sign the Instrument of Accession, according to the textbook?
- 15 August 1947
- 1 November 1956
- September 1948
- 26 October 1947
Show answer
Answer: D. He signed on 26 October 1947 and the army reached Srinagar the next day, 27 October 1947. September 1948 is when Indian troops entered Hyderabad.
-
5. The Bhoodan movement started by Vinoba Bhave aimed at
- abolition of the gun salute system
- forcible seizure of princely palaces
- creation of linguistic states
- voluntary gifting of land by landowners to the landless
Show answer
Answer: D. Bhoodan means 'gift of land'. The textbook links it to the Telangana uprising and describes it as promoting voluntary redistribution of land in favour of the landless.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.