• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Formative and summative assessment: for, of and as learning

Tell formative and summative assessment apart by their purpose, and explain assessment for learning, of learning and as learning with classroom examples.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Two pairs of ideas run through almost every question on assessment. The first pair is formative and summative. The second is a set of three phrases: assessment for learning, of learning and as learning. Both pairs are about the same thing: what the information from an assessment is used for. Once you ask that question, they become easy.

Formative assessment

Formative assessment happens during teaching, and its purpose is to improve learning while it is still going on. The teacher uses it to find out what learners understand and to change the next steps. Examples include questions in class, quick exit slips at the end of a lesson, checking notebooks, and short quizzes whose results are used to re-teach. The marks, if any, matter less than the feedback. A good way to remember it: formative assessment helps to form the learning.

Summative assessment

Summative assessment comes at the end of a unit, term or year, and its purpose is to sum up what has been learned. Its results are used to grade, certify, promote or report. A final examination and an end-of-unit test that goes on the report card are summative. Feedback from summative assessment usually comes too late to change the unit it measured.

Formative and summative
FeatureFormativeSummative
WhenDuring teachingAt the end of a unit, term or year
PurposeTo improve learningTo sum up and certify learning
Use of resultsFeedback, re-teaching, changing plansGrades, reports, promotion
Typical toolsQuestions, exit slips, observation, quizzesFinal tests, term examinations

For, of and as learning

Assessment for learning is close to formative assessment: the teacher assesses in order to plan better teaching and give feedback. Assessment of learning is close to summative assessment: it records what has been achieved at a point in time. Assessment as learning puts the learner in charge: students assess their own work or each other's, reflect on their progress and set goals. In assessment as learning the learner is the main user of the information, and the skill being built is the ability to monitor one's own learning.

The same test can play either role. A unit test whose results are used only to re-teach weak topics is acting formatively; the same test whose marks go straight into the report card is acting summatively. That is why the purpose, not the name of the test or the date on which it is given, decides the answer.

Continuous and comprehensive evaluation

The idea of continuous and comprehensive evaluation (CCE) grew from this thinking. Continuous means assessment is spread through the year, mostly formative, rather than squeezed into one final examination. Comprehensive means it covers all sides of development: not only school subjects but also attitudes, values, health, arts and social skills. As an idea, CCE combines formative and summative assessment and looks at the whole child.

Worked example 1

A teacher gives a five-question quiz on decimals on Tuesday. She sees that most students placed the decimal point wrongly when multiplying, so on Wednesday she re-teaches that step. Step 1: when? During the unit. Step 2: what were the results used for? To change teaching. Answer: formative assessment, or assessment for learning.

Worked example 2

At the end of a project, each student fills in a checklist about their own work: 'I included three sources', 'I explained my reasons', and writes one goal for the next project. Step 1: who assesses? The student. Step 2: what is the purpose? Reflection and setting goals. Answer: assessment as learning (self-assessment).

Ask what the information is used for. Used to improve teaching: formative, for learning. Used to sum up and report: summative, of learning. Used by learners to monitor themselves: as learning.

Key takeaways

  • Formative assessment is during learning, to improve it.
  • Summative assessment is at the end, to sum up and certify.
  • For learning helps the teacher plan; of learning records achievement; as learning builds self-monitoring.
  • CCE, as an idea, means assessment spread through the year and covering all sides of development.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A teacher asks questions in class and changes her explanation when students look confused. This is:

    1. Summative assessment
    2. Placement
    3. Certification
    4. Formative assessment
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Assessing during teaching and changing the plan to improve learning is formative assessment.

  2. 2. An end-of-year examination whose result decides promotion is an example of:

    1. Assessment for learning
    2. Assessment as learning
    3. Diagnostic assessment
    4. Assessment of learning
    Show answer

    Answer: D. It sums up learning at the end and is used for promotion, which is assessment of learning.

  3. 3. Students check their own essays against a list of criteria and set a goal for improvement. This is:

    1. Assessment of learning
    2. Summative assessment
    3. Assessment as learning
    4. Norm-referenced testing
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Learners monitoring and directing their own learning is assessment as learning.

  4. 4. In the idea of CCE, 'comprehensive' means that assessment:

    1. Happens only once at the end of the year
    2. Covers all sides of a learner's development, not only school subjects
    3. Uses only written tests
    4. Is done only by the head of the school
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Comprehensive refers to breadth: scholastic and co-scholastic areas such as attitudes, health and arts.

  5. 5. Which feature belongs to summative assessment?

    1. Its results are used for grades and reports at the end of a period
    2. It is mainly used to change tomorrow's lesson
    3. It is always done by the students themselves
    4. It happens only at the start of a unit
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Summative assessment sums up learning for grading and reporting.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery