• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Observation tools and fair judgement: checklist, rating scale, anecdotal record and marker errors

Describe the checklist, the rating scale and the anecdotal record, write a record that states facts, and name the common errors that make judgement unfair.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Not everything a teacher wants to assess can be put in a written test. Habits such as sharing, listening and working in a group, or skills such as using a microscope, can only be seen by watching. Teachers use simple tools to record what they see, and they need to guard against errors in their own judgement. This lesson covers both.

Three observation tools

Observation tools
ToolWhat it isExample
ChecklistA list of behaviours or steps, marked yes or no (done or not done)Washes hands before the experiment: yes. Handles the glass carefully: yes. Records the result: no.
Rating scaleA list of behaviours, each marked on a scale of degreesHow often does the child share materials? Never (1), sometimes (2), often (3), always (4).
Anecdotal recordA short, dated, factual note about something the teacher saw10 July: during group work Asha explained the diagram to two classmates without being asked.

A checklist is quick and shows whether something was done. A rating scale shows how much or how often. An anecdotal record adds the detail that neither of them can hold. Used together over time, they give a fuller picture of a child than one test.

Writing an anecdotal record

  • Record what was seen and heard, not the teacher's opinion of the child's character.
  • Give the date, the place and the situation.
  • Keep it short and to one incident.
  • Keep interpretation in a separate note, marked as an opinion.

Compare 'Rohan pushed Amit in the queue at 10:15 on Monday' with 'Rohan is aggressive'. The first is a fact that anyone could check. The second is a judgement that may be unfair, since one incident does not make a character.

Errors in judgement

Common marker errors
ErrorWhat happens
Halo effectOne good (or bad) impression colours judgement of everything else, such as neat handwriting raising marks for weak content
Leniency errorThe marker gives higher marks than the work deserves, to everyone
Severity errorThe marker gives lower marks than the work deserves, to everyone
Central tendency errorThe marker avoids high and low marks and gives middle marks to all
Order or contrast effectA script is marked higher or lower because of the one marked just before it

Remedies are simple: use a rubric or marking scheme with clear criteria, mark one question at a time across all scripts, cover names where possible, take breaks, and re-mark a sample of scripts.

Worked example 1

Situation: a teacher wants to know whether Class 6 children set up a science experiment in the right order: collect materials, arrange them, start, record the result. Step 1: the question is whether each step was done. Step 2: the answers are yes or no. Answer: a checklist is the suitable tool. If the teacher wanted to know how well each step was done, a rating scale would be needed.

Worked example 2

Situation: a teacher marks 20 essays. Because the first essay was excellent, the second, which is average, seems poor and gets a low mark. Step 1: the mark of the second essay was affected by the one before it. Step 2: this is an effect of order or contrast. Answer: order (contrast) effect. Marking one question across all scripts and re-marking a sample would help.

Worked example 3

Situation: a teacher writes 'Neha is lazy and careless' in her notebook after Neha forgot her pencil box once. Step 1: the note is a judgement, not a fact. Step 2: a factual version is '12 March: Neha did not bring her pencil box to class and borrowed a pencil.' Answer: a good anecdotal record states the event, not the character.

Checklist: done or not done. Rating scale: how much or how often. Anecdotal record: dated facts, not opinions. Guard against the halo, leniency, severity, central-tendency and order errors.

Key takeaways

  • A checklist records yes or no; a rating scale records degrees; an anecdotal record notes a dated fact.
  • A good record states what was seen and heard, not an opinion.
  • The halo effect, leniency, severity, central tendency and order effects make judgement unfair.
  • Rubrics, marking one question at a time and re-marking help reduce these errors.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A teacher marks yes or no for each step a child follows in an experiment. The tool is a:

    1. checklist
    2. rating scale
    3. rubric
    4. portfolio
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Marking whether each step was done or not done is the job of a checklist. A rating scale would mark degrees.

  2. 2. A teacher marks how often a child shares: never, sometimes, often or always. The tool is a:

    1. checklist
    2. anecdotal record
    3. rating scale
    4. achievement test
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A scale of degrees such as never to always is a rating scale. A checklist marks only yes or no.

  3. 3. Why is 'Rohan pushed Amit in the queue at 10:15 on Monday' a good anecdotal record?

    1. It states a judgement of Rohan's character
    2. It describes what happened and can be checked
    3. It predicts how Rohan will behave later
    4. It summarises Rohan's whole term
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A good anecdotal record gives dated facts that others could check. Judgements of character or predictions do not.

  4. 4. A marker gives high marks to every part of an essay because the handwriting is beautiful. This is:

    1. a leniency error
    2. a central tendency error
    3. a severity error
    4. the halo effect
    Show answer

    Answer: D. One good impression, the handwriting, colours the judgement of everything else. That is the halo effect.

  5. 5. A teacher gives almost every learner 5 or 6 marks out of 10 to avoid extreme marks. This is:

    1. the halo effect in marking
    2. a central tendency error
    3. an order effect in marking
    4. a leniency error in marking
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Avoiding high and low marks and giving middle marks to all is the central tendency error.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery