• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Heredity and environment: scenario problems on nature, nurture and twin studies

Solve scenario questions on heredity, environment, genotype and phenotype, twin and adoption studies, and the older views of Locke, Rousseau, Galton, Watson and Gesell.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

'Which matters more, heredity or environment?' is one of the oldest questions in child development. Modern exams do not expect you to pick a side. They test whether you can read a scenario, decide which influence it shows, and name the person or method associated with it. This lesson trains that skill.

Key terms and thinkers

Term or nameMeaning or position
HeredityCharacteristics passed from parents through genes
EnvironmentEverything outside the genes that acts on the child, from before birth
GenotypeThe genetic make-up a person inherits
PhenotypeThe observable result of genotype and environment together
John LockeEarly view that the mind at birth is like a blank slate, shaped by experience
Jean-Jacques RousseauHeld that natural development should be allowed to unfold with little interference
Francis GaltonEarly supporter of the importance of heredity, and the one who popularised the phrase nature and nurture
J. B. WatsonBehaviourist who gave great weight to training and environment
Arnold GesellStressed maturation, the unfolding of inner biological timing

The accepted modern view is interaction: heredity sets a range of possibilities and environment decides where within the range a person ends up. The same genes can produce different outcomes in different environments, which is why the phenotype is not the same as the genotype.

Twin and adoption studies

Identical (monozygotic) twins develop from one fertilised egg and share nearly all their genes. Fraternal (dizygotic) twins develop from two eggs and share, on average, about half of the genes that vary between people, like ordinary brothers and sisters. If identical twins raised apart are alike in a trait, that suggests heredity. If identical twins raised together differ, that suggests environment. In adoption studies, children are compared both with their birth family, who share their genes, and with their adoptive family, who share their home.

Worked example 1: heredity or environment?

Classify each trait as mainly heredity, mainly environment, or both: (a) blood group, (b) the language a child speaks, (c) adult height, (d) skill at playing the sitar. Answer: (a) heredity, since blood group is fixed by genes. (b) environment, because a child speaks the language she hears. (c) both: genes set the range and nutrition and health decide where in it she reaches. (d) both, since talent may be inherited but skill needs practice and teaching.

Worked example 2: which comparison isolates what?

A researcher wants to separate heredity from environment. Option 1: identical twins reared in different homes. Option 2: two unrelated adopted children reared in the same home. Step 1: in option 1 the genes are the same but homes differ. Similarities then point to heredity and differences to environment. Step 2: in option 2 the home is the same but the genes differ. Similarities then point to environment. Answer: both designs are useful, but each tells about a different influence.

Worked example 3: read the scenario

Two identical twins are separated at birth. One grows up in a city with a rich library and plenty of tutoring, and the other in a remote village with no school nearby. At age 10 both have the same eye colour and a similar temperament, but the city twin reads fluently and the village twin does not. Step 1: eye colour and temperament are alike, which suggests the contribution of heredity. Step 2: reading differs, which depends heavily on teaching and opportunity. Answer: heredity best explains the matching eye colour and temperament; environment best explains the difference in reading. Neither alone explains both.

Nature sets the range; nurture decides where in the range. Identical twins reared apart test heredity; unrelated children reared together test environment.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Interaction is the accepted answer to nature versus nurture.
  • Identical twins share nearly all genes; fraternal twins share about half of the varying genes.
  • Genotype is the inherited make-up; phenotype is what is observed.
  • Locke and Watson are linked with environment; Gesell with maturation; Galton with heredity.
  • Read the scenario for which trait is alike and which is different.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A person's blood group is mainly determined by:

    1. Environment
    2. Training
    3. Heredity
    4. Nutrition
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Blood group is fixed by genes, unlike height or skills, which also depend on experience.

  2. 2. Identical twins raised apart show very similar temperaments. This most strongly suggests:

    1. A role for heredity
    2. No role for heredity
    3. That temperament is learnt only
    4. That they did not share genes
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The twins share genes but not homes, so similarity points to heredity.

  3. 3. Which thinker is associated with the idea of the mind as a blank slate at birth?

    1. Arnold Gesell
    2. Francis Galton
    3. Konrad Lorenz
    4. John Locke
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Locke's view was that experience writes on the mind, as on a blank slate.

  4. 4. The visible characteristics of a person, resulting from genes and experience together, are called the:

    1. Genotype
    2. Phenotype
    3. Chromosome
    4. Reflex
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Genotype is the inherited make-up; phenotype is what shows after genes and environment have acted.

  5. 5. Fraternal twins differ from identical twins in that fraternal twins:

    1. Develop from two separate eggs
    2. Develop from one egg and share all genes
    3. Always differ in every single trait
    4. Are always of different sexes
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Fraternal twins come from two eggs and are as alike genetically as ordinary siblings. They may or may not be of the same sex.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery