• Practice
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

What should the teacher do? Best-response questions across the theories

Choose the best teacher action in scenarios built on Piaget, Vygotsky, Kohlberg, Erikson and Bronfenbrenner, and learn the typical wrong options that examiners include.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many questions end with 'What should the teacher do?' The facts behind them are the theories you have studied, but the answer is a teaching decision. Wrong options are usually built on a few predictable mistakes, such as punishment, forcing, labelling, comparing children and ignoring the cause. Learn the pattern once and you can answer dozens of questions.

A four-step method

  1. Find the issue. Which theory or principle does the scenario illustrate?
  2. Match the child's level. The action should suit the child's stage, readiness or zone of proximal development.
  3. Prefer active, supportive actions. Explaining, guiding, discussing and giving a chance to succeed beat scolding, lecturing and rote repetition.
  4. Reject the usual wrong options: punishing, labelling the child, comparing the child publicly with others, and doing the whole task for the child.

Best move for each theory

TheoryIf the scenario shows...The best teacher move
PiagetA child who cannot yet reason abstractly or conserveUse concrete materials and activities; let the child explore; ask the child to explain
VygotskyA child who can do a task only with helpGive hints and steps that are gradually withdrawn; use peer helpers; aim within the zone
Erikson (school age)Repeated failure and a feeling of being 'useless'Set tasks the child can succeed at; praise effort; avoid public comparison
KohlbergCheating or breaking a ruleDiscuss reasons and effects; raise the level of reasoning; do not rely on punishment alone
BronfenbrennerSudden change in behaviour with no cause in classLook for causes at home and elsewhere; talk to the family; use counselling support
Individual differencesChildren progress at different ratesDifferentiate tasks; do not demand the same result on the same day

Worked example 1: Piaget

A Class 2 teacher finds that many children cannot understand division when she explains it only on the blackboard. Which action is best? (a) Repeat the explanation louder. (b) Give each group beads and let them share them equally into bowls, then record what they find. (c) Give extra homework. (d) Move the slowest children to the back. Step 1: young children in the early primary years reason best with concrete objects. Answer: (b). The others ignore the learners' stage or isolate children.

Worked example 2: Erikson

Sana, 9, fails several tests, is publicly compared with her brother, and says 'I am no good at anything.' What should her teacher do? (a) Point out her lower marks in front of the class so that she works harder. (b) Give her tasks she can succeed at, praise her effort and show progress step by step. (c) Tell her she is lazy. (d) Ignore her until the exam. Step 1: school-age children are in the stage of industry versus inferiority, and failure with comparison pushes towards inferiority. Answer: (b), because it builds a sense of competence. (a) and (c) increase inferiority.

Worked example 3: Kohlberg and Bronfenbrenner together

A usually honest Class 8 student copies in a test, after his father lost his job and the family moved to a rented room. What is the best first step? (a) Cancel his marks and say no more. (b) Speak privately with him, find out what has happened, discuss why copying is a problem, and involve the family and counsellor if needed. (c) Announce his name to the class. (d) Tell him the family has no future. Step 1: a sudden change points to an outside cause, a chronosystem change with exosystem origins in the father's job. Step 2: a discussion that explores reasons helps his moral reasoning grow. Answer: (b). Punishment alone, public shaming or hopeless statements ignore both the cause and his development.

Find the theory, fit the child's level, choose the supportive active option, and reject punishing, labelling, comparing and doing it for the child.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • The best answer is usually the one that is supportive, active and matched to the child's level.
  • Avoid options that punish, shame, label or publicly compare.
  • Look for causes outside the classroom when behaviour suddenly changes.
  • Scaffolding means help that fades, not doing the task for the child.
  • Discussing reasons builds moral reasoning better than punishment alone.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A child cannot yet understand a science idea explained only in words. The teacher's best move is to:

    1. Give real objects for the child to handle
    2. Ask the child to memorise the explanation
    3. Move on without explaining it again
    4. Put the child at the back of the class
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Concrete materials suit children who are not yet reasoning abstractly. Rote learning does not build understanding.

  2. 2. A child can solve a problem only when the teacher gives hints. The teacher should:

    1. Solve the problem for the child each time
    2. Wait until the child is older
    3. Give hints and fade them as the child improves
    4. Remove all help at once
    Show answer

    Answer: C. This is scaffolding within the zone of proximal development: help that is gradually withdrawn.

  3. 3. A school-age child often says, 'I am useless.' Which action best helps?

    1. Compare the child with the best student
    2. Provide achievable tasks and recognise effort
    3. Give only very hard tasks
    4. Say nothing about the child's work
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Success and recognition build industry, while comparison and failure strengthen inferiority.

  4. 4. A student cheats in a test. A teacher who wishes to support moral development should:

    1. Punish the student in front of the class
    2. Ignore it and say nothing to the student
    3. Tell the student he has a bad character
    4. Discuss why cheating harms and what to do instead
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Discussing reasons builds moral reasoning, while shaming, labelling or ignoring does not.

  5. 5. A quiet child suddenly becomes aggressive in class. The teacher cannot find any cause in school. The best first step is to:

    1. Suspend the child from school at once
    2. Talk with the child, then the family, about causes
    3. Tell all classmates to stay away from him
    4. Assume the child's character has changed
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A sudden change may have causes in the home or elsewhere, which Bronfenbrenner's model draws attention to. A caring conversation is the first step.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery