- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Kohlberg's stages of moral reasoning: identify the stage
Name Kohlberg's three levels and six stages and identify a stage from the reason a person gives, avoiding the common decision-versus-reason trap.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Lawrence Kohlberg, an American psychologist, extended Piaget's work on moral judgement. He presented children, adolescents and adults with moral dilemmas and studied the reasons they gave. In the best known, the Heinz dilemma, a man's wife is dying and he cannot afford a drug, so he must decide whether to steal it. Moral reasoning, like thinking in lesson 2, develops through an ordered sequence of stages.
Three levels, six stages
| Level | Stage | What decides right and wrong |
|---|---|---|
| Preconventional | 1. Obedience and punishment orientation | Avoiding punishment; obeying power |
| Preconventional | 2. Individualism and exchange | Self-interest and fair deals: what do I get? |
| Conventional | 3. Good interpersonal relationships ('good boy - good girl') | Approval of others; being seen as good |
| Conventional | 4. Maintaining social order ('law and order') | Duty, rules and laws that keep society working |
| Postconventional | 5. Social contract and individual rights | Laws are agreements that should protect rights and can be changed |
| Postconventional | 6. Universal ethical principles | Self-chosen principles of justice and human dignity |
The stages form an invariant sequence: a person moves up one stage at a time without skipping. Not everyone reaches the postconventional level; Kohlberg found that many adults reason at the conventional level, and stage 6 is rare.
The golden rule of these questions
Kohlberg classified the reason, not the decision. 'Steal' and 'do not steal' can both appear at every stage. A person who says Heinz should not steal because he will be put in jail and a person who says he should not steal because laws hold society together reach the same decision at different stages. So always cover the decision with your thumb and read only the 'because' part.
Worked example 1: six answers to the Heinz dilemma
- 'He should not steal, because he will be caught and punished.' Reason = avoiding punishment, so stage 1.
- 'He should steal, because he needs his wife to cook for him and look after the house.' Reason = his own benefit, so stage 2.
- 'He should steal, because a good husband would; everyone would think badly of him if he let her die.' Reason = approval and being a good person, so stage 3.
- 'He should not steal, because if everyone broke the law when they wished, society would fall apart.' Reason = law and social order, so stage 4.
- 'He should steal, because laws exist to protect people's rights, and the right to life should come before a property rule.' Reason = laws as agreements serving rights, so stage 5.
- 'He should steal, because human life has a value that no law can outweigh, and he must act on that principle whatever the cost to himself.' Reason = universal self-chosen principle, so stage 6.
Worked example 2: a classroom case
A teacher asks why one should not copy in a test. Pooja says, 'Because the teacher will give me zero.' Arjun says, 'Because the school's rules say so, and rules are needed so that marks mean something for everyone.' Imran says, 'I will help my friend copy, because then he will help me next time.' Working: Pooja fears punishment, stage 1. Arjun upholds rules to keep the system working, stage 4. Imran thinks of a deal that benefits him, stage 2. Notice that Imran is still preconventional even though he is being 'nice' to a friend: the reason is exchange, not approval or care.
Kohlberg judged the reasoning, not the decision. Preconventional = self (punishment, then exchange); conventional = others and society (approval, then law and order); postconventional = principles (social contract, then universal ethics).
Common traps
Stage 3 and stage 4 are both conventional, but stage 3 looks to the approval of people close to you while stage 4 looks to laws and duties for society as a whole. Stage 4 and stage 5 both talk about law, but stage 4 treats law as fixed, while stage 5 sees it as a social agreement that can be changed when it fails to protect rights. Stage 2 contains words such as 'fair deal', 'you scratch my back', or 'what is in it for me'.
Where Kohlberg's theory fits, and its limits
Kohlberg built on Piaget, who had earlier described younger children judging rules as fixed and set by authority, and older children seeing rules as agreements that can be changed. Kohlberg's stages extend that idea into adolescence and adulthood. Two criticisms are widely taught. First, Carol Gilligan argued that his scheme emphasised an ethic of justice and rules and undervalued an ethic of care and relationships, so reasoning based on care could be scored lower. Second, moral reasoning does not always predict moral behaviour: a person may reason at a high stage and still act differently. For a teacher, the practical message is to discuss real dilemmas in class, ask students to give reasons, and expose them to reasoning one stage above their own, which can help them move forward.
Key takeaways: learn the three levels in order, attach two stages to each, and identify a stage only from the justification. Watch the pairs 2-3, 3-4 and 4-5, where most options are built.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'I will not take my brother's sweets because Mother will scold me.' Which Kohlberg stage is this reasoning?
- Stage 3: good interpersonal relationships
- Stage 4: maintaining social order
- Stage 1: obedience and punishment orientation
- Stage 5: social contract
Show answer
Answer: C. The only reason given is avoiding punishment, which is stage 1 of the preconventional level.
-
2. Kohlberg classified a person's moral stage mainly on the basis of:
- Whether the decision was to obey or break the law
- The reasons given for a decision
- The person's age alone
- How quickly the person answered
Show answer
Answer: B. He studied the justification. The same decision can be reached at different stages, and age alone does not fix the stage.
-
3. 'Laws are agreements made by people to protect everyone's rights, so an unjust law should be changed.' This reasoning belongs to:
- The postconventional level
- The preconventional level
- The conventional level, stage 3
- No level, because it questions the law
Show answer
Answer: A. Seeing laws as social contracts that serve rights and can be changed is stage 5, within the postconventional level.
-
4. A student says, 'I helped Seema with her homework so that she will lend me her notes later.' This is typical of:
- Stage 3: good interpersonal relationships
- Stage 4: law and order
- Stage 2: individualism and exchange
- Stage 6: universal ethical principles
Show answer
Answer: C. The reason is a fair exchange that benefits the student, which is stage 2. Stage 3 would stress being seen as a good friend.
-
5. Which statement about Kohlberg's stages is correct?
- Everyone reaches stage 6 by adulthood
- The stages can be passed in any order
- Stage 4 belongs to the preconventional level
- People move through the stages in a fixed order without skipping
Show answer
Answer: D. Kohlberg described an invariant sequence. Many adults stay at the conventional level, stage 6 is rare, and stage 4 is conventional, not preconventional.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.