- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Bandura and Kohler in practice: modelling, self-efficacy and insight
Diagnose which of Bandura's four processes fails in a case, use vicarious reinforcement, self-efficacy and reciprocal determinism, and recognise insight and Gestalt principles.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Lessons 1 to 3 explained learning through the learner's own experience of stimuli and consequences. Bandura and Kohler showed that this is not the whole story. Practice questions describe a classroom case and ask which process failed, which kind of reinforcement is at work, or whether a solution came by insight. This lesson trains those judgements.
Bandura beyond the Bobo doll
Bandura's social learning theory, later called social cognitive theory, says people learn by observing others and that thinking plays a part between what we see and what we do. A behaviour can be learned by watching but not performed until there is a reason, which is why Bandura separated learning from performance. Three further ideas often appear in questions.
- Vicarious reinforcement and punishment: seeing a model rewarded makes copying more likely; seeing a model punished makes it less likely.
- Self-efficacy: a person's belief in his or her own ability to succeed at a particular task. It grows mainly through one's own successes, and also through seeing similar people succeed, encouragement, and a calm rather than anxious state.
- Reciprocal determinism: personal factors, behaviour and environment all influence one another.
Worked example 1: which process failed?
(a) A student copies the teacher's method for long division the same day but cannot recall it a week later. (b) A student remembers the method and could do it, but sees no point because 'marks don't matter to me'. (c) A student watching the demonstration was looking out of the window. Working: (a) retention failed; (b) motivation is missing; (c) attention failed. If a student understood and remembered but lacked the motor skill, as with a difficult dance step, reproduction would be the failure. Order the processes as attention, retention, reproduction, motivation and check each in turn.
Remember also that observation can teach without immediate performance. In the Bobo doll research, children who saw the model punished copied less aggression at first, but when later offered a reward for showing what the model had done, they were able to reproduce the actions. They had learned the behaviour all along; motivation decided whether it was performed. This is the basis of Bandura's distinction between learning and performance.
Kohler's insight, applied
Kohler's chimpanzees solved problems by suddenly seeing the relations between the parts, such as joining two sticks to reach a banana or stacking boxes. Insight has recognisable signs: a period of apparent inactivity or exploring, a sudden solution, a smooth performance once the solution is found, good retention, and transfer to similar problems. Trial and error, by contrast, shows gradual improvement.
Worked example 2: insight or not, and which Gestalt law?
A student who has been stuck on a geometry problem suddenly sees that drawing one extra line makes two congruent triangles, solves it at once, and uses the same trick on the next problem. Working: sudden solution, seeing the figure as a new whole, and transfer to a similar problem all point to insight. Now a perception item: on a chart, students see red and blue dots as separate groups even though they are mixed together. Working: grouping by colour is the Gestalt principle of similarity; had they grouped dots because they were close together, it would be proximity.
| Feature | Trial and error (Thorndike) | Insight (Kohler) |
|---|---|---|
| Speed of solution | Gradual | Sudden |
| Learner's activity | Random attempts | Perceiving relations in the whole situation |
| Transfer | Limited | Readily transfers to similar problems |
| Animal studied | Cats | Chimpanzees |
Bandura: attention, retention, reproduction, motivation; self-efficacy is belief in one's own ability for a task; person, behaviour and environment influence one another. Kohler: insight is sudden, whole-based and transferable.
For teachers: model the behaviour you want, praise good examples publicly so others learn vicariously, build self-efficacy with achievable successes, and set problems that allow students to see relations rather than only repeat steps. Key takeaways: diagnose Bandura's four processes in order, separate vicarious from direct reinforcement, and recognise insight by suddenness and transfer.
Check your understanding
-
1. A student watches a skilled classmate solve a puzzle, remembers every step, and has the skill to do it, but chooses not to because he sees no benefit. Which process is missing?
- Motivation
- Attention
- Retention
- Reproduction
Show answer
Answer: A. Attention, retention and the ability to reproduce are present; what is missing is a reason to perform the behaviour, which is motivation.
-
2. Self-efficacy, in Bandura's theory, means:
- A person's measured intelligence
- A person's belief in his or her ability to succeed at a particular task
- The speed of learning by trial and error
- A reward given for good behaviour
Show answer
Answer: B. Bandura defined self-efficacy as belief in one's capability to succeed in a specific task or situation.
-
3. Seeing a classmate scolded for cheating makes other students less likely to cheat. This is:
- Negative reinforcement
- Spontaneous recovery
- Vicarious punishment
- Insight
Show answer
Answer: C. Observing a model punished reduces the chance of copying the behaviour, which is vicarious punishment.
-
4. Which observation would best indicate insight learning rather than trial and error?
- A sudden solution that is then applied to similar problems
- A slow, steady fall in errors over many trials
- A response that appears only after a bell
- Random movements that gradually decrease
Show answer
Answer: A. Insight is marked by a sudden solution, smooth performance and transfer. Gradual reduction of errors and random movements indicate trial and error.
-
5. On a page, students see red dots as one group and blue dots as another, even though they are mixed together. This is the Gestalt principle of:
- Proximity
- Closure
- Figure-ground
- Similarity
Show answer
Answer: D. Grouping elements that look alike, here by colour, is similarity. Proximity would group elements because they are close together.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.