- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Skinner in practice: consequences, reinforcers and schedules
Classify consequences quickly, tell primary from secondary reinforcers, use the Premack principle and token systems, and predict behaviour under each schedule.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Skinner builds directly on Thorndike's law of effect from lesson 2. Practice questions on operant conditioning have two favourite targets: the four types of consequence (especially negative reinforcement) and the schedules of reinforcement. This lesson gives a two-question method for the first and a pattern table for the second, plus a few classroom applications.
Two questions for every consequence
- Did the behaviour go up or down afterwards? Up = reinforcement; down = punishment.
- Was something added or removed? Added = positive; removed = negative.
Answer both before looking at the options. Negative reinforcement always involves removal of something unpleasant and an increase in behaviour. If the behaviour decreased, it cannot be reinforcement of any kind.
Be careful about whose behaviour the question asks about. In a single exchange between two people, the same event can reinforce one person and punish or reinforce the other. When a parent gives in to a whining child, the child's whining is positively reinforced by the sweet, while the parent's giving in is negatively reinforced by the end of the whining. Read the question to see which person's behaviour is being changed.
Kinds of reinforcer
A primary reinforcer satisfies a basic need without learning, such as food or water. A secondary (conditioned) reinforcer gains its power by being linked with other reinforcers, such as money, grades, stars or praise. A token economy gives tokens for target behaviour that can be exchanged later for privileges; the tokens are secondary reinforcers. The Premack principle says a more preferred activity can reinforce a less preferred one: 'Finish your maths sums, then you may play cricket.'
Schedules and the behaviour they produce
| Schedule | Rule | Typical pattern | Everyday example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Continuous | Every response reinforced | Fast learning; fast extinction when reinforcement stops | Praising every correct answer when a skill is new |
| Fixed ratio | After a set number of responses | High rate with a short pause after each reward | Payment per 10 items made |
| Variable ratio | After an unpredictable number of responses | High, steady rate; most resistant to extinction | Lottery tickets, games of chance |
| Fixed interval | First response after a set time | Little response just after reward, a rise as the time nears | Studying mainly just before a monthly test |
| Variable interval | First response after unpredictable times | Slow, steady rate | Surprise quizzes; checking for messages |
Partial (intermittent) schedules make behaviour harder to extinguish than continuous reinforcement. A sound teaching rule follows: reinforce continuously while a new behaviour is being learned, then shift to intermittent reinforcement to keep it going.
Worked example 1: classify the consequences
(a) A noisy class is told the extra assignment will be cancelled if they work quietly for a week; they work quietly. (b) A student loses his place as monitor after bullying and stops bullying. (c) A student is made to write lines for being late and comes late less often. Working: (a) unpleasant assignment removed, behaviour up: negative reinforcement. (b) privilege removed, behaviour down: negative punishment. (c) unpleasant task added, behaviour down: positive punishment.
Worked example 2: predict the pattern
A school holds a test on the last day of every month. A second school gives tests on unannounced days, on average once a month. In which school will students study more evenly through the month? Working: the first is a fixed interval schedule, which tends to produce little effort just after a test and a burst just before the next. The second is a variable interval schedule, which produces a steadier rate because the next test could come any day. So the second school should see more even study.
Up = reinforcement, down = punishment; added = positive, removed = negative. Teach a new behaviour with continuous reinforcement, then maintain it with an intermittent schedule; variable ratio resists extinction most.
Skinner in the classroom
Skinner applied his ideas to teaching through programmed instruction: material broken into small steps, an active response at each step, immediate feedback, and learners moving at their own pace. He also designed teaching machines to deliver it. Many computer-based practice programmes follow the same plan. Key takeaways: classify any consequence with the two questions; know primary and secondary reinforcers, token economies and the Premack principle; and know which schedule produces which pattern.
Check your understanding
-
1. A child's whining stops when the parent gives her a chocolate, so the parent gives chocolates sooner each time. For the parent's behaviour, the stopping of the whining is:
- Positive reinforcement
- Positive punishment
- Negative reinforcement
- Negative punishment
Show answer
Answer: C. From the parent's side, an unpleasant thing (whining) is removed and the parent's giving of chocolates increases. Removal plus increase is negative reinforcement.
-
2. Stars on a chart that students later exchange for extra library time are an example of:
- Primary reinforcers
- Positive punishment
- Unconditioned stimuli
- Secondary reinforcers in a token economy
Show answer
Answer: D. Stars have value only because they can be exchanged for something else, so they are secondary reinforcers used in a token economy.
-
3. 'You may draw pictures after you finish your spelling list.' This applies the:
- Law of readiness
- Principle of closure
- Zone of proximal development
- Premack principle
Show answer
Answer: D. Using a preferred activity (drawing) to reinforce a less preferred one (spelling) is the Premack principle.
-
4. Which schedule of reinforcement generally produces behaviour that is most resistant to extinction?
- Continuous
- Fixed interval
- Variable ratio
- Fixed ratio
Show answer
Answer: C. Under a variable ratio schedule the learner never knows which response will be rewarded, so responding continues for a long time after rewards stop.
-
5. Students study little at the start of each month and a lot just before a test held on a fixed date each month. This pattern is typical of a:
- Variable interval schedule
- Fixed interval schedule
- Variable ratio schedule
- Continuous schedule
Show answer
Answer: B. Reinforcement available after a fixed time produces low responding after each reward and a rise as the time approaches, typical of a fixed interval schedule.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.