- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Memory, forgetting and transfer in practice: classroom scenario items
Solve scenario questions on the memory stores, chunking, kinds of forgetting and types of transfer by asking the right diagnostic questions in order.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Memory and transfer items usually describe a classroom or study situation in two or three lines and then ask what is happening or what should be done. Success depends on diagnosis: ask the right question and the answer follows. This lesson gives a short question list for each of the two areas and then solves four scenarios.
Diagnosis for memory items
- Where in the system is the problem? If the pupil did not attend, the information never left sensory memory. If she attended but could not hold it, the trouble is short-term capacity. If she cannot recall something she once knew, the trouble is long-term storage or retrieval.
- Is it capacity? Many separate items, more than about seven, point to chunking as the fix.
- Is it interference or cue failure? If other learning blocks the memory, it is interference. If a hint brings it back at once, it is retrieval failure.
Diagnosis for transfer items
- Did earlier learning help, harm or do nothing? Positive, negative, zero.
- Is the helpful factor shared elements or an understood principle? Shared elements point to Thorndike; an understood principle points to Judd.
- Was it between levels or at the same level? From simple to more complex content is vertical transfer; between similar tasks of equal difficulty is lateral transfer.
Memory: attend - hold - store - retrieve. Where did it break? Transfer: help, harm or nothing - and why?
Scenario 1: the telephone list
A teacher reads out fourteen unrelated words once and asks pupils to write them down. Most recall only about six or seven. Why, and how can she improve it? Step 1: fourteen items exceed the typical short-term span of about seven. Step 2: reading once gave no time for rehearsal or linking. Step 3: remedies: group the words into meaningful chunks (for example four groups of three or four related words), allow rehearsal, and ask pupils to link words by making a story. Answer: short-term capacity limit; use chunking and elaboration.
Scenario 2: the pupil who attended but forgot
Aman listened carefully to a lesson on photosynthesis, could answer questions the same day, but two weeks later cannot recall the details. A hint, 'think of chlorophyll', brings it all back. Step 1: he attended and learned it, so it reached long-term memory. Step 2: the hint restored it, so it was stored but the retrieval cue was missing. Answer: retrieval failure, not total forgetting; practise recalling with cues and test himself from time to time.
Scenario 3: negative transfer
A pupil learnt to write dates as day-month-year. When she learns a computer program that expects year-month-day, she keeps entering them in the first order. Step 1: earlier learning is interfering with the new task. Step 2: the interference is caused by a clash of similar habits. Answer: negative transfer. The teacher should point out the difference clearly and give practice in the new format.
Scenario 4: planning for transfer
A mathematics teacher wants pupils to use the idea of ratio in science and in cooking. Which plan is best? (i) Teach ratio only through textbook exercises, since drill produces transfer. (ii) Teach the idea of ratio, then give varied problems from science, cooking and maps, and ask pupils to state what they have in common. (iii) Say that mathematics trains the mind, so transfer will happen automatically. Step 1: (iii) is the discredited formal discipline view. Step 2: (i) gives practice with very similar tasks only, so transfer to new contexts is poor. Step 3: (ii) teaches a principle and applies it in several settings, which supports Judd's generalisation and gives some identical elements as well. Answer: (ii).
Study-habit items
When an item asks for the best study advice, choose the option with spaced revision, self-testing and linking to known ideas, and reject options that rely on a single long session or on rereading alone. These match the forgetting curve and the idea of elaboration.
Key takeaways: diagnose where memory broke down; use chunking for capacity, spacing and self-testing for forgetting, cues for retrieval; classify transfer as positive, negative or zero and name the reason; choose plans that teach principles and vary the contexts.
Check your understanding
-
1. A pupil can recall a fact when a friend gives the first letter but not before. This is best called:
- Decay of the memory trace
- Sensory memory loss
- Zero transfer
- Retrieval failure
Show answer
Answer: D. The memory is stored and returns with a cue, so the problem is retrieval and not decay.
-
2. A list of twelve unrelated items is easier to remember when grouped into four meaningful sets. This is:
- Latent learning
- Chunking
- Extinction
- Spontaneous recovery
Show answer
Answer: B. Grouping items into meaningful units reduces the number of things to hold, which is chunking.
-
3. Using the old way of writing a date and so making errors in a new format is an example of:
- Positive transfer
- Zero transfer
- Negative transfer
- Insight learning
Show answer
Answer: C. Earlier learning interferes with the new task, which is negative transfer.
-
4. Which plan best helps transfer of the idea of ratio to other subjects?
- Teach the principle and apply it to varied problems in several settings
- Give only repeated exercises of one type
- Trust that studying mathematics automatically trains the mind
- Avoid mentioning other subjects while teaching ratio
Show answer
Answer: A. A principle practised in varied contexts supports transfer. The formal discipline idea has not been supported by research.
-
5. After a long gap, a pupil who revised in short sessions over several weeks remembers more than a pupil who read once the night before. This agrees with:
- Pavlov's law of extinction in dogs
- Hull's drive reduction theory of need
- Ebbinghaus's curve and spaced revision
- Rogers' unconditional positive regard
Show answer
Answer: C. Forgetting is fastest soon after learning, so spaced revision keeps memory strong. The other ideas do not address forgetting.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.