- Practice
- About 17 min
- 5 practice questions
Identifying methods from lesson descriptions: clues and traps
Identify language-teaching methods quickly from a lesson description by checking four clues, and separate methods that look alike.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The foundation course listed the features of six methods. In questions, the method is never named: you get a short description of a lesson and four method names. The difficulty is that methods share some features, so a description can look like two methods at once. This lesson gives a four-clue check and works through the pairs that are most often confused.
The four-clue check
- Clue 1, the mother tongue: not used at all (direct), used by the teacher only to make meaning clear (bilingual), or used as the medium with translation exercises (grammar-translation).
- Clue 2, rules: stated first and memorised (grammar-translation), or not taught as rules (direct, audio-lingual, communicative).
- Clue 3, repetition: fixed drills and memorised dialogues to form habits (audio-lingual).
- Clue 4, purpose of talk: exchanging real meaning, with fluency first (communicative), or reaching a task outcome, with language focus after (task-based).
Pairs that look alike
| Pair | How to tell them apart |
|---|---|
| Grammar-translation and bilingual | Both use the mother tongue. In grammar-translation learners translate and learn rules; in bilingual the teacher gives meaning in the mother tongue and learners practise in the target language. |
| Direct and audio-lingual | Both are oral and avoid translation. Audio-lingual relies on fixed drills and memorised dialogues; direct method relies on demonstration and question-answer with real objects. |
| Audio-lingual and communicative | Both may use dialogues. In audio-lingual the dialogue is memorised exactly; in communicative learners choose what to say to get real meaning across. |
| Communicative and task-based | Task-based is communicative in spirit, but is organised around a task with a clear outcome, and attention to form usually comes after. |
Why the methods differ
The methods differ because they rest on different views of what language is and how it is learnt. Grammar-translation treats a language mainly as a system of rules and words to be studied, often for reading its literature. The audio-lingual method treats it as a set of habits built by repetition and reinforcement. The direct method tries to copy the way a first language is met, through the language itself. Communicative and task-based teaching treat language as a tool for getting things done with other people. Knowing the view behind a method helps when a question asks which belief a practice reflects.
No single method is best for every class. Many teachers combine features, for example using the mother tongue briefly to clear up a difficult meaning, a short drill for a tricky sound, and communicative tasks for most of the lesson. A question that asks which method a teacher should always use is therefore usually a trap; the better answer matches the method to the learners and the goal.
Worked example 1
Lesson: the teacher plays a recorded dialogue at a shop. Learners repeat each line in chorus, then in rows, until they can say the whole dialogue from memory. Then the teacher says 'apples' and learners say 'I want some apples'; 'rice', 'I want some rice', quickly. Errors are corrected immediately. Working: Clue 1, no mother tongue; Clue 2, no rules stated; Clue 3, chorus repetition, memorised dialogue and a substitution drill with instant correction. Clue 3 decides it. Answer: audio-lingual. The trap option is direct method, which is also oral but uses objects and demonstration, not drills.
Worked example 2
Lesson: groups must plan a class party with a budget of 500 rupees. They discuss what to buy, agree, and present their plan. Afterwards the teacher writes some phrases they used on the board, such as 'We could buy...' and 'Let's...', and discusses better ways to make suggestions. Working: Clue 4: there is a task with a clear outcome (a plan within budget), language is used to reach it, and attention to form comes after the task. Answer: task-based learning. Communicative language teaching is the distractor; it is close, but the outcome-centred task followed by a language focus is the mark of task-based learning.
Speed method
Read the description once and underline only the clue words: translate, rules, chorus, repeat, drill, memorise, objects, pictures, pairs, information gap, role play, task, outcome, mother tongue. Usually two or three clue words settle the method in seconds. If two methods remain, use the table above to separate them.
Mother tongue? Rules? Drills? Real meaning or task outcome? Answer these four and the method usually names itself.
Key takeaways
Methods are identified by clusters of clues, not one feature. The mother tongue's role separates direct, bilingual and grammar-translation. Drills and memorised dialogues mark audio-lingual. Real exchange of meaning marks communicative teaching, and an outcome-driven task with language focus after marks task-based learning.
Check your understanding
-
1. Learners memorise a dialogue line by line through chorus repetition and then do substitution drills. Which method is this?
- Direct method
- Task-based learning
- Audio-lingual method
- Bilingual method
Show answer
Answer: C. Chorus repetition, memorised dialogues and substitution drills are the marks of the audio-lingual method.
-
2. What best separates the bilingual method from grammar-translation?
- Only grammar-translation uses the mother tongue
- In the bilingual method the teacher uses the mother tongue for meaning while learners practise in the target language; in grammar-translation learners translate and learn rules
- Only the bilingual method teaches reading
- There is no difference between them
Show answer
Answer: B. Both use the mother tongue, but in very different ways; the bilingual method keeps learner practice in the target language.
-
3. Pupils in pairs each have a different picture and must find six differences by describing their picture without showing it. This activity is typical of:
- the grammar-translation method
- the audio-lingual method
- deductive grammar teaching
- the communicative approach, using an information gap
Show answer
Answer: D. Each learner holds information the other needs, so real communication is required: an information-gap activity.
-
4. A teacher teaches 'on', 'under' and 'in' by putting a ball on, under and in a box, speaking only English, and asking 'Where is the ball?' Which method is this?
- Direct method
- Grammar-translation method
- Audio-lingual method
- Bilingual method
Show answer
Answer: A. Target language only, meaning shown through objects and question-answer, with no drills or translation, is the direct method.
-
5. Groups prepare a poster telling visitors how to reach the school from the bus stand; the teacher discusses useful direction phrases afterwards. Which method fits best?
- Grammar-translation method
- Audio-lingual method
- Task-based learning
- Direct method
Show answer
Answer: C. A task with a clear outcome, followed by attention to language, is task-based learning.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.