- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Identifying the named methods from lesson descriptions: TPR, Silent Way, Suggestopedia, CLL and the Natural Approach
Use a clue table to identify TPR, the Silent Way, Suggestopedia, Community Language Learning and the Natural Approach from lesson scenes, and to separate them from older methods.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Method-identification items give a paragraph from a lesson and ask for the method. Earlier practice covered grammar-translation, direct, audio-lingual and communicative teaching. This lesson adds the five named methods. The skill is the same: ignore the setting and look at three features - who speaks, what the learners do, and the mood of the room.
The three-feature check
| Method | Who speaks | What learners do | Mood or tool |
|---|---|---|---|
| Total Physical Response | Teacher gives commands | Act them out; speak later | Movement, objects |
| Silent Way | Teacher mostly silent | Discover, name, correct each other | Coloured rods, wall charts |
| Suggestopedia | Teacher reads or speaks calmly | Listen, relax, then play and sing | Music, comfortable room, new names |
| Community Language Learning | Learner speaks mother tongue; teacher gives target form | Repeat, record, reflect | Counsellor and group, security |
| Natural Approach | Teacher speaks target language with support | Show understanding, speak when ready | Comprehensible input, no forced speech |
Commands and actions = TPR. Silent teacher and rods = Silent Way. Music and relaxation = Suggestopedia. Learner says it in mother tongue first, teacher is counsellor = CLL. Understanding first, no forced speech = Natural Approach.
Worked example 1: five scenes
Name the method. (a) The teacher says 'Put the red pencil in the box' and pupils do it; nobody is asked to speak for the first weeks. (b) Pupils sit in a circle, a pupil says in Telugu what she wants to say, and the teacher whispers the English version for her to repeat. (c) The teacher holds up one rod, says 'rod', then hands it to pupils and watches in silence while they try. (d) Soft music plays and the teacher reads a story aloud while pupils relax in armchairs. (e) The teacher tells a picture story using gestures; pupils point to pictures and are not asked to speak until they volunteer. Working: (a) TPR, command and action. (b) CLL, because the mother tongue statement comes from the learner and the teacher is a counsellor. (c) Silent Way. (d) Suggestopedia. (e) Natural Approach, since it stresses comprehensible input without forced speech. Answer: TPR, CLL, Silent Way, Suggestopedia, Natural Approach.
Worked example 2: tell the lookalikes apart
Two descriptions seem similar. Scene A: pupils respond with action to teacher commands for the first month and speak later. Scene B: pupils listen to a picture story, point to pictures, and speak when they feel ready; the teacher also uses simple gestures. Both avoid forced speech. How to separate? Working: A has a specific technique - commands carried out by physical action - which is TPR. B is described by the principle of comprehensible input with optional speech, which is the Natural Approach. The Natural Approach often uses TPR in its early stage, so on a test with both options, choose the one that matches the feature highlighted: commands and action for TPR; the principle of understandable input and no forced speech for the Natural Approach.
Worked example 3: separate from the older methods
Which of these is not a feature of Suggestopedia? (a) A comfortable, attractive classroom. (b) Soft music. (c) Rapid drilling of memorised dialogues to form habits. (d) Positive suggestion to reduce fear. Working: (c) describes the audio-lingual method. The others are features of Suggestopedia. Answer: (c).
Worked example 4: the founder match
Match: Asher, Gattegno, Lozanov, Curran, Terrell. Methods: Silent Way, TPR, Natural Approach, Suggestopedia, CLL. Working: Asher - TPR; Gattegno - Silent Way; Lozanov - Suggestopedia; Curran - CLL; Terrell (with Krashen) - Natural Approach. Memory aid: Asher = Action; Gattegno = Guess with rods (silent); Lozanov = Lull (relaxation); Curran = Counsellor; Terrell with Krashen = Talk when ready.
Traps
- A silent teacher is not necessarily the Silent Way; look for rods and learner discovery.
- Mother tongue in a lesson does not always mean grammar-translation or the bilingual method; in CLL it begins from the learner's own statement.
- A relaxed class is not always Suggestopedia; look for music, comfortable seats and positive suggestion as a method.
- TPR suits beginners and children; it is hard to teach abstract ideas through commands.
Key takeaways: use the three-feature check; commands and actions point to TPR; silence with rods to the Silent Way; relaxation and music to Suggestopedia; learner statements with a counsellor to CLL; understandable input without forced speech to the Natural Approach.
Check your understanding
-
1. Pupils carry out commands such as 'Open the window' and are not asked to speak for weeks. The method is:
- The Silent Way
- Community Language Learning
- The audio-lingual method
- Total Physical Response
Show answer
Answer: D. Commands answered by physical action, with speaking delayed, are the hallmark of TPR.
-
2. The teacher models a word once, then stays silent while pupils use coloured rods to practise. The method is:
- Suggestopedia
- The Silent Way
- The direct method
- The bilingual method
Show answer
Answer: B. A mostly silent teacher, rods and learner discovery identify the Silent Way.
-
3. A pupil says something in her mother tongue and the teacher, acting as a counsellor, gives the target-language version. The method is:
- Total Physical Response
- Grammar-translation
- Community Language Learning
- The Natural Approach
Show answer
Answer: C. The learner's own statement and the teacher as counsellor are central features of CLL.
-
4. Which is NOT a feature of Suggestopedia?
- Fast drills of memorised dialogues for habit
- Soft music playing during the lesson
- A comfortable, attractive classroom
- Positive suggestion to reduce fear of failure
Show answer
Answer: A. Habit drills belong to the audio-lingual method. The other features belong to Suggestopedia.
-
5. Which pair is correctly matched?
- Gattegno: Suggestopedia
- Lozanov: Silent Way
- Asher: Total Physical Response
- Curran: Natural Approach
Show answer
Answer: C. Asher developed TPR; Gattegno the Silent Way; Lozanov Suggestopedia; Curran CLL.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.