• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Krashen's hypotheses in practice: matching the case to the hypothesis

Identify which of Krashen's five hypotheses a classroom case illustrates, avoid the lookalike traps and choose the response that follows from the theory.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Questions on Krashen usually give a short classroom scene and ask which hypothesis it shows, or ask which teacher response follows from it. The five names sound alike to a tired candidate, so it pays to attach each name to a single memorable clue. This lesson gives the clues, then four solved cases and a list of traps.

One clue for each hypothesis

HypothesisOne-line clueTypical words in a case
Acquisition-learningNatural use versus conscious study'picked up', 'through play' versus 'memorised the rule'
MonitorRules edit output when there is time'corrects himself when writing slowly', 'knows the rule but slips in speech'
Natural orderStructures arrive in a predictable order'taught last week but still does not use it', 'same errors appear in all learners'
Input (i + 1)Understood message a little above level'story with pictures', 'understands most words'
Affective filterFeelings block input'frightened', 'embarrassed', 'confident', 'relaxed'

Picked up = acquisition. Edits slowly = monitor. Predictable order = natural order. A little above level and understood = input. Feelings = affective filter.

Worked example 1: four cases

Name the hypothesis in each. (a) Ananya knows every rule about 'a' and 'the' but omits them when she speaks quickly; in an essay she adds them correctly after rereading. (b) A teacher taught the third-person '-s' in week one, but even in week twelve many pupils say 'She like tea'. (c) Teacher reads a story about a farm with pictures; the pupils follow almost all of it and notice some new words from the pictures. (d) A pupil who was laughed at for a mistake no longer answers, though he understands the lessons. Working: (a) rule used when time and focus on form allow, so monitor. (b) a structure not acquired in the order taught, so natural order. (c) comprehensible input just above their level, so input hypothesis. (d) embarrassment blocking use, so affective filter. Answer: monitor, natural order, input, affective filter.

Worked example 2: acquisition or learning?

Decide: (a) A child learns Marathi by playing with neighbours. (b) A student memorises a list of Marathi verb tables before a test. (c) A teacher gives a fun cooking lesson in Marathi in which pupils follow instructions, and they begin to use the words in play. Working: (a) acquisition. (b) learning. (c) pupils attend to meaning and the situation is natural, so acquisition, even though it is in a classroom. Answer: acquisition, learning, acquisition.

Worked example 3: which teacher response follows?

A new pupil from another state is silent in English for three weeks but follows instructions correctly. The headmaster wants her tested orally in front of the class to 'make her speak'. Which response does Krashen's theory support? Working: she is understanding, so input is working. Forcing speech in front of the class raises the affective filter. A better step is to continue giving comprehensible input, invite her to take part in non-verbal ways, and welcome speech when she is ready, with pair talk first. Answer: do not force the oral test; keep input rich and anxiety low.

Worked example 4: is the claim true?

Evaluate: 'According to Krashen, learned rules are the main source of fluent speech.' Working: Krashen said the opposite. Fluency comes mainly from acquisition. Learned rules play the smaller role of monitor. The claim is false. Evaluate: 'Krashen suggested that i + 1 means one extra lesson per day.' False: it stands for input one step beyond present level.

Traps

  • Natural order is not about the order of the school syllabus; it is about the order of acquisition.
  • The monitor does not create speech; it edits it.
  • A high affective filter does not mean low intelligence; it means feelings are blocking use of input.
  • Input must be comprehensible; difficult input without support gives no benefit.
  • Krashen's ideas are hypotheses and have been criticised; the question may ask only what they say.

Key takeaways: attach one clue to each hypothesis; look for the signal words in a case; support responses that give understood input and keep anxiety low; reject claims that reverse the theory, such as learning being the main source of fluency.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A pupil knows a grammar rule but breaks it in fast speech and corrects it when writing slowly. This shows:

    1. The input hypothesis
    2. The monitor hypothesis
    3. The natural order hypothesis
    4. The affective filter hypothesis
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Conscious rule knowledge is used to edit output only when there is time and attention on form. This is the monitor.

  2. 2. A structure taught in week one is still not used correctly in week twelve. This fits best with:

    1. The affective filter hypothesis
    2. The monitor hypothesis
    3. The acquisition-learning hypothesis
    4. The natural order hypothesis
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Structures are acquired in a predictable order, not necessarily the order they are taught.

  3. 3. A pupil is embarrassed after being laughed at, and stops speaking though she understands. This shows:

    1. A high affective filter
    2. Comprehensible input
    3. The natural order
    4. The monitor
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Negative feelings raise the filter, blocking acquisition and use even when input is understood.

  4. 4. Which is the claim most opposite to Krashen's view?

    1. Fluency comes mainly from acquiring language by use
    2. Anxiety can block acquisition of a language
    3. Fluency comes mainly from conscious learning of rules
    4. Understood input slightly above level helps
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Krashen said that acquisition, not conscious learning, is the main source of fluency.

  5. 5. A new pupil is silent but follows instructions. Which response follows Krashen best?

    1. Test her orally before the class to make her speak
    2. Move her to a lower class
    3. Ban her home language
    4. Give rich understood input and let her speak when ready
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The pupil is receiving input; forcing speech raises the affective filter. Waiting and supporting follows the theory.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery