- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Piaget in the classroom and the main criticisms
Turn Piaget's ideas into classroom practice and state the main criticisms of his theory, including the contrast with Vygotsky.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Knowing Piaget's terms is only half the job for a teacher. Teaching exams also ask what a Piaget-minded teacher would do, and what later researchers found wrong or incomplete in his theory. This lesson connects the ideas from lessons 1 to 4 to everyday teaching and then gives a fair, simple account of the criticisms, including the most common comparison, with Lev Vygotsky.
What Piaget's theory means for teachers
- Match teaching to the child's stage. Young children need concrete, hands-on materials; abstract explanation alone will not work for them.
- Learning by doing. Children construct knowledge through activity, so use play, experiments, models and discovery.
- The teacher as facilitator. Arrange rich experiences and ask good questions rather than only telling.
- Use cognitive conflict. A surprising result creates disequilibrium and pushes children to accommodate.
- Treat errors as clues. A wrong answer shows how the child is thinking.
- Encourage peer interaction. Discussing with classmates exposes children to other points of view and helps them move beyond egocentrism.
- Respect individual pace. Children pass through the stages in order but not at identical speeds.
Worked example 1: planning a Class 2 maths lesson
A teacher must teach subtraction to seven-year-olds. Plan A: write the rule on the board and give twenty written sums. Plan B: give each pair a heap of bead strings, ask them to take some away and count what is left, record it in pictures, and only then write number sentences. Step 1: what stage are most of the children at? Around the move from preoperational to concrete operational thinking. Step 2: what do they need? Concrete objects they can handle. Step 3: which plan fits Piaget? Plan B, because it moves from concrete action to pictures to symbols.
Worked example 2: creating useful puzzlement
Class 4 students believe that bigger objects always weigh more. The teacher shows a large ball of cotton and a small stone and lets them hold both. Students are surprised the small stone is heavier. Step 1: what has the teacher created? Disequilibrium, because the experience does not fit their schema. Step 2: what should she do next? Let them test more pairs and discuss, so they accommodate their idea: weight depends on what an object is made of as well as its size. The surprise is used on purpose to drive learning.
Main criticisms
Underestimating children. Later researchers found that when tasks are made simpler, more familiar or less dependent on language, young children often show abilities, such as taking another person's view, earlier than Piaget suggested. Stages less neat. Abilities tend to appear gradually and unevenly across tasks rather than all at once at a stage change. Culture and schooling. Performance on Piaget's tasks, especially formal operational reasoning, varies with culture, schooling and experience, and not every adult reasons formally in every area. Too little attention to social learning. This is where Vygotsky comes in.
The contrast with Vygotsky
Lev Vygotsky, a Russian psychologist, agreed that children actively construct knowledge, but he put social interaction and language at the centre. For him, children learn through working with adults and more skilled peers, especially in the zone of proximal development, the range of tasks a child can do with help but not yet alone. Piaget saw development as largely individual and believed it generally comes before learning. Vygotsky argued that learning with others can lead development forward. They also read children's talk to themselves differently: Piaget called it egocentric speech, a sign of immature thinking, while Vygotsky called it private speech, a tool that helps children guide their own thinking.
Teach young children with concrete, active experiences, use surprise to create disequilibrium, and read errors as clues. Remember the criticisms: underestimated children, less rigid stages, effects of culture, and Vygotsky's stress on social interaction.
Key takeaways
A Piaget-minded teacher matches tasks to the child's stage, teaches through activity, uses cognitive conflict, values errors and encourages discussion. Piaget's theory remains very influential, but it underestimated young children, described stages more neatly than later evidence supports, paid little attention to culture, and gave less weight to social interaction than Vygotsky did.
Check your understanding
-
1. According to Piaget, the best way to teach number concepts to Class 2 children is through:
- long lectures on abstract rules
- memorising definitions
- hands-on work with concrete objects
- solving only written symbolic problems
Show answer
Answer: C. Most children of this age are moving into concrete operational thinking, so they learn best by handling real objects.
-
2. A teacher who follows Piaget treats a child's wrong answer as:
- a clue to how the child is thinking
- a sign that the child cannot learn
- something to ignore
- a reason for punishment
Show answer
Answer: A. Piaget built his theory on children's patterned errors, which reveal their way of thinking.
-
3. Which is a common criticism of Piaget's theory?
- He ignored the role of the child's own activity
- He said children are passive receivers of knowledge
- He proposed that development has no stages
- He underestimated the abilities of young children
Show answer
Answer: D. Simpler and more familiar tasks show that young children can often do more than Piaget's tasks suggested.
-
4. Compared with Piaget, Vygotsky gave much more importance to:
- reflexes and conditioning
- social interaction and language
- physical growth
- rewards and punishments
Show answer
Answer: B. Vygotsky saw learning with adults and peers, and language, as central to development.
-
5. A teacher shows a result that contradicts what students believe so that they rethink their ideas. In Piaget's terms she is creating:
- disequilibrium
- egocentrism
- object permanence
- animism
Show answer
Answer: A. A surprising result that does not fit the students' schemas creates disequilibrium, which pushes them to accommodate.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.