• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Three kinds of knowledge and Piaget's clinical method

Distinguish physical, logical-mathematical and social knowledge, see why Piaget thought the first two must be constructed by the child, and learn how the clinical method finds out what a child thinks.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

If children construct knowledge, we should ask what kinds of knowledge there are and how each is built. Piaget gave a useful answer, and it explains why some things can be taught by telling while others need experience. This lesson also explains how Piaget found out what children think, a method that every teacher can borrow.

Three kinds of knowledge

Three kinds of knowledge
KindWhere it comes fromExamples
Physical knowledgeActing on objects and observing the resultsA stone is heavy and hard; a ball rolls; ice melts
Logical-mathematical knowledgeThe child's own mental relating of objects and actionsThese two stones are 'two'; one is heavier than the other; the sorted group is larger than its subgroup
Social (conventional) knowledgeOther people: language, customs and rulesThe word 'stone'; days of the week; how to greet an elder

Physical knowledge is found in the objects, but the child must still act on them to discover it. Logical-mathematical knowledge is not in the objects at all. The 'twoness' of two stones is not a property of either stone; the child creates it by relating them. Social knowledge cannot be found by thinking or by experiment, because it is arbitrary: nothing about a stone tells a child its name. Someone has to tell the child.

What this means for teaching

  • Physical knowledge needs materials, and chances to act, test and observe.
  • Logical-mathematical knowledge needs activities in which children compare, sort, count and arrange, and talk about what they did.
  • Social knowledge can be given by telling, showing and correcting: names, conventions, symbols and customs.

A teacher who tells a child that 'seven is bigger than four' in words alone may be giving a social fact, not building the logical idea. The idea is built when the child lines up seven and four counters and sees the difference.

The clinical method

Piaget wanted to know how children think, not only whether their answers are right, so he used a flexible interview called the clinical method. The interviewer starts with a task, such as two equal rows of counters, and asks a question. Whatever the child answers, the interviewer follows up: 'Why do you think so?', 'What would happen if...?', or a gentle counter-suggestion: 'Another child told me the opposite.' The aim is to see whether the answer is firm or shaky and what reason lies behind it. Unlike a standard test with the same questions for every child, the questions are shaped by the child's replies. Piaget also kept detailed observation notes of his own children in their daily life. The method is rich but depends on the skill of the interviewer, and results are harder to compare across children.

Worked example 1: sorting kinds of knowledge

Classify each: (a) a ball of clay sinks in water; (b) the number of sweets in a row stays the same whichever way they are counted; (c) the Hindi word for a dog; (d) a lump of wax is soft. Working: (a) physical knowledge, found by dropping the clay into water; (b) logical-mathematical knowledge, built by relating the sweets and the counting; (c) social knowledge, which depends on language; (d) physical knowledge, from touching the objects.

Worked example 2: a short interview

A teacher spreads out one of two equal rows of seven buttons and asks a six-year-old, 'Are there the same number in each row, or more in one?' The child says, 'More in this long row.' The teacher asks, 'How do you know?' The child replies, 'It is longer.' The teacher asks, 'What if I push them back as before?' The child says, 'Then the same.' Working: the follow-up questions show the reasoning, which is based on length (centration) and on the arrangement. The teacher learns more than a single right-or-wrong answer would show, and decides that the child needs further activities with counting and re-arranging, not telling.

Physical and logical-mathematical knowledge are built by the child's own action and thought; social knowledge is passed on by people. To learn how a child thinks, ask 'why' and follow the answer.

Key takeaways

  • Piaget distinguished physical, logical-mathematical and social (conventional) knowledge.
  • Logical-mathematical knowledge comes from relations the child builds, not from the objects alone.
  • The clinical method uses flexible questions that follow the child's replies.
  • Teachers can use 'how do you know?' questions as a small version of the method.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. That a stone sinks in water is an example of:

    1. Physical knowledge
    2. Logical-mathematical knowledge
    3. Social knowledge
    4. Operational knowledge
    Show answer

    Answer: A. It is found by acting on the object and observing.

  2. 2. Which of these is social (conventional) knowledge?

    1. A stone is heavier than a leaf
    2. Three sticks are fewer than five sticks
    3. The name of a day of the week
    4. Water takes the shape of a glass
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Names are arbitrary and have to be passed on by other people.

  3. 3. Why is 'twoness' called logical-mathematical knowledge?

    1. It is a name that is told to the child
    2. A relation the child builds between objects
    3. It is found in the weight of the objects
    4. It is learned only by memorising numerals
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The child creates the relation by relating the objects.

  4. 4. Piaget's clinical method is best described as:

    1. A written test with the same questions for all
    2. A timed test of speed
    3. A rating scale completed by parents
    4. A flexible interview that follows up the child's answers
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The interviewer shapes the questions by the child's replies.

  5. 5. What is a main limitation of the clinical method?

    1. It cannot be used with young children
    2. It needs a skilled interviewer and is hard to compare
    3. It gives only right-or-wrong scores for each task
    4. It requires a very large number of children
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Because questions differ between children, comparing results is harder.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → Final self-assessment: Piaget's theory

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery