• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Piaget on moral development: rules, intentions and fairness

Learn how Piaget used games and short stories to study children's ideas about rules, and how heteronomous morality gives way to autonomous morality.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Piaget did not only study thinking about objects. He also asked how children come to understand right and wrong, rules and fairness. His book on the moral judgment of the child is one of the sources for the common exam topic of moral development. This lesson sets out his two ways of studying morality and the two kinds of morality he described, with classroom examples.

How Piaget studied morality

  • He watched children playing games such as marbles and asked them about the rules: where they came from, whether they could be changed, and whether they were fair.
  • He told pairs of short stories about children who caused damage and asked which child was naughtier and why.

These methods followed his general approach of listening to children's own reasoning, and the results suggested two broad ways of thinking about rules and wrongdoing.

Heteronomous morality (morality of constraint)

Heteronomous means 'ruled by others'. Younger children, roughly from about five to nine or ten years, tend to see rules as fixed, as if they came from parents, teachers or even God, and as something that cannot be changed. Their ideas have these features:

  • Moral realism: a rule is a thing in itself, to be obeyed exactly.
  • Judging by consequences: the bigger the damage, the worse the act, whatever the intention.
  • Belief in immanent justice: punishment follows a wrong act automatically, so bad luck is the result of bad behaviour.
  • Belief in strict punishment: harsh punishment is seen as fair, since breaking a rule is wrong in itself.

Autonomous morality (morality of cooperation)

Autonomous means 'self-ruled'. Older children, from about ten years, see rules as agreements made by people for their common good, which can be changed if everyone agrees. They judge an act by the intention behind it, think about reciprocity and fairness ('how would I like to be treated?'), and believe the punishment should fit the act. Piaget thought the change comes from decentration and, especially, from cooperation among equals. Peer relations, in which children must negotiate, are more helpful than adult authority alone, which tends to keep children in the earlier outlook. The ages are rough, and children may show both outlooks.

FeatureHeteronomous (younger)Autonomous (older)
Source of rulesAuthority; fixedAgreement; changeable
Judging an actBy the size of the damageBy the intention
PunishmentHarsh punishment is fairPunishment should fit the act
Bad luckMay be a punishment (immanent justice)Happens by chance

Worked example 1: two stories

Story A: Meera breaks six glasses by accident while carrying a tray to help her mother. Story B: Raju breaks one glass because he threw it in anger. Question: who is naughtier? Younger child's answer: Meera, because six glasses is more damage. This judges by consequences and shows heteronomous morality. Older child's answer: Raju, because he meant to do wrong, whereas Meera was trying to help. This judges by intention and shows autonomous morality.

Worked example 2: rules of a game

A group of eleven-year-olds plays a ball game. A new child suggests that the goal be made wider so that smaller children can score. The group talks about it, agrees and tries the new rule for a week. Working: the children treat the rule as an agreement that they can change for fairness. This is autonomous morality. In contrast, a seven-year-old who says, 'You can't change the rule, it has always been like this,' shows heteronomous morality. A teacher might also hear a child say, after being rude to a friend and then tripping, 'I fell because I was bad,' which is a belief in immanent justice.

Heteronomous: rules are fixed and consequences count. Autonomous: rules are agreed and intentions count. Cooperation among equals leads from the first towards the second.

Key takeaways

  • Piaget studied morality through children's games and pairs of stories.
  • Heteronomous morality means rules are fixed, authority-based, judged by consequences.
  • Autonomous morality means rules are agreements and intentions matter.
  • Teachers help by giving children a voice in class rules and discussing intentions as well as results.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which feature belongs to heteronomous morality?

    1. Judging an act by the intention
    2. Changing rules by agreement
    3. Believing that rules are made by equals
    4. Judging an act by the size of the damage
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Younger children focus on consequences, not intentions.

  2. 2. A ten-year-old says, 'Raju did it on purpose, so he deserves a bigger punishment than Meera, who broke more by accident.' This shows:

    1. Heteronomous morality, because there is a punishment
    2. Autonomous morality, because intention is considered
    3. Symbolic play, because the story is pretend
    4. Practice play, because the story is repeated
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Judging by intention marks the later outlook.

  3. 3. What does 'immanent justice' mean for a young child?

    1. Justice is decided by a court of law
    2. Everyone gets exactly the same punishment
    3. Punishment will follow automatically for a wrong act
    4. Wrongdoing does not matter without a witness
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A child may think an accident, such as falling, is a punishment for lying.

  4. 4. Which classroom practice best supports the move to autonomous morality?

    1. Letting pupils discuss and frame class rules
    2. Announcing rules that may not be questioned
    3. Punishing every rule that is broken severely
    4. Avoiding all talk about right and wrong acts
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Cooperation among equals and discussion of rules help children see rules as agreements.

  5. 5. According to Piaget, what does most to move children from heteronomous to autonomous morality?

    1. Strict punishment given by adults
    2. Memorising a long list of school rules
    3. Cooperation and negotiation with equals
    4. Simply reaching a certain age or year
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Peer relations, where children must negotiate, encourage a view of rules as agreements.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery