- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Guilford's structure of intellect and Cattell's fluid and crystallised intelligence
Describe Guilford's three dimensions of operations, contents and products, explain divergent and convergent thinking, and tell fluid from crystallised intelligence.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
After Spearman and Thurstone, two psychologists took the question in new directions. J. P. Guilford built a much larger model in which intelligence is made of many abilities arranged along three dimensions, and he drew attention to creative thinking. Raymond Cattell divided general intelligence into two kinds that behave differently across life. Both ideas are useful to teachers: one for creativity, the other for understanding how learning and reasoning change with age.
Guilford's structure of intellect
Guilford proposed that every intellectual ability can be described by three things: the mental operation being carried out, the kind of content being worked on, and the product that results. He pictured these as the three sides of a cube, with each small block representing one ability. As he revised the model, the number of categories, and so the number of abilities, grew, so it is more important to understand the three dimensions than to remember a count.
| Dimension | Question it answers | Categories |
|---|---|---|
| Operations | What is the mind doing? | Cognition, memory, divergent production, convergent production, evaluation |
| Contents | What kind of information? | Figural (visual and auditory), symbolic, semantic, behavioural |
| Products | What form does the result take? | Units, classes, relations, systems, transformations, implications |
Divergent and convergent thinking
Two of Guilford's operations are especially important for teachers. Convergent production (convergent thinking) means arriving at the one correct answer to a problem, as in most arithmetic sums and multiple-choice questions. Divergent production (divergent thinking) means producing many different possible answers to an open question, which is closely linked to creativity. 'What is 15 × 4?' calls for convergent thinking. 'List as many uses of a brick as you can' calls for divergent thinking.
Guilford: every ability = an operation on a content producing a product. Convergent thinking finds one right answer; divergent thinking finds many possible answers and is linked to creativity.
Worked example 1
Task: 'Suggest as many ways as possible to save water in school.' Which kind of thinking does it require? Step 1: is there one correct answer? No, many suggestions are acceptable. Step 2: the task rewards the number and variety of ideas. Step 3: producing many varied answers to an open problem is divergent production. Answer: divergent thinking, linked to creativity.
Cattell's fluid and crystallised intelligence
Raymond Cattell, later working with John Horn, divided general intelligence into two broad abilities. Fluid intelligence is the ability to reason and solve new problems, see patterns and think logically in situations where learned knowledge does not help much. Crystallised intelligence is the knowledge and skills built up through education and experience, such as vocabulary, general knowledge and learned methods. Fluid intelligence tends to peak in early adulthood and decline gradually later, while crystallised intelligence tends to keep growing or stay steady well into adulthood, because people keep learning.
| Feature | Fluid | Crystallised |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Reasoning with new problems | Knowledge and skills already learned |
| Depends on | Mainly on current reasoning, little on schooling | Education, culture and experience |
| Example task | Completing an unfamiliar pattern series | Defining words, recalling facts |
| Typical change with age | Peaks in early adulthood, then declines gradually | Keeps growing or stays steady |
Worked example 2
Two tasks: (i) 'Find the next figure in this series of shapes you have never seen before.' (ii) 'What is the meaning of the word benevolent?' Classify each. Step 1: task (i) is new and depends on spotting a rule without prior knowledge, so it uses fluid intelligence. Step 2: task (ii) depends on a word already learned, so it uses crystallised intelligence. Answer: (i) fluid, (ii) crystallised.
Key takeaways: Guilford described abilities by operations, contents and products; the exact number of abilities changed as he revised the model; convergent thinking finds one answer, divergent thinking many; Cattell's fluid intelligence is reasoning with new problems, crystallised intelligence is accumulated knowledge; fluid tends to decline with age while crystallised tends to keep growing.
Check your understanding
-
1. Guilford's structure of intellect describes abilities along which three dimensions?
- Locus, stability and controllability
- Operations, contents and products
- Analytical, creative and practical
- Fluid, crystallised and general
Show answer
Answer: B. Guilford's model classifies every ability by its operation, content and product. The other sets belong to Weiner, Sternberg and Cattell.
-
2. 'List as many uses of a newspaper as you can' requires mainly:
- Convergent thinking
- Crystallised intelligence only
- Divergent thinking
- Perceptual speed only
Show answer
Answer: C. Producing many different answers to an open question is divergent thinking, linked to creativity.
-
3. Which kind of thinking does a question with only one correct answer require?
- Divergent thinking
- Convergent thinking
- Intrapersonal intelligence
- Self-actualisation
Show answer
Answer: B. Arriving at the single correct answer is convergent production.
-
4. Knowledge of vocabulary and general facts built up through schooling is called:
- Fluid intelligence
- Crystallised intelligence
- Divergent production
- A specific factor only
Show answer
Answer: B. Crystallised intelligence is accumulated knowledge and skills from education and experience.
-
5. Which statement about fluid intelligence is correct?
- It is the same as general knowledge
- It keeps increasing throughout old age
- It is measured only by vocabulary tests
- It is the ability to reason with new problems and tends to decline gradually in later adulthood
Show answer
Answer: D. Fluid intelligence is reasoning with unfamiliar problems; it tends to peak in early adulthood and decline gradually later.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.