- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Heredity and environment in intelligence: twins, reaction range and what teachers can do
Understand the nature-nurture question, how twin studies are used as evidence, the idea of a reaction range, and why both heredity and environment matter in school.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Is intelligence inherited, or is it made by experience? Teachers meet this question often, for example when a bright child comes from a poor home or a child from a literate family struggles. Psychologists call it the nature-nurture question. The sensible answer is that both matter and work together. This lesson explains the evidence and how it is used, in simple terms.
Nature and nurture
Heredity (nature) is what a child inherits from the parents through genes. Environment (nurture) is everything outside the genes that acts on the child: food and health, home, language, schooling, play, and relationships. No trait develops from heredity alone or from environment alone. Genes need an environment to work in, and the environment can only act on what the genes make possible.
Twin studies
Twins give researchers a natural way to separate the two influences. Identical (monozygotic) twins develop from one fertilised egg and share all their genes. Fraternal (dizygotic) twins develop from two eggs and share, on average, about half their genes, like other brothers and sisters. The logic is as follows. If twins are brought up in the same home, the environment is similar for both kinds, so if identical twins are more alike in intelligence than fraternal twins, heredity probably matters. If identical twins who were brought up apart are still quite alike, that also points to heredity. If identical twins differ, the cause must lie in the environment, because their genes are the same.
Reaction range
The idea of a reaction range describes how heredity and environment work together. Heredity sets a range within which a child's measured intelligence may fall; the environment decides where in that range the child ends up. A rich environment with good nutrition, stimulation and schooling lets the child reach the upper part of the range; a poor environment keeps the child near the lower part. Heredity is thus a set of possibilities, not a fixed outcome.
Environmental influences teachers can affect
- Health and nutrition, including regular meals.
- Language-rich talk, stories and books.
- Encouragement, expectation and emotional safety.
- Good teaching and chances to practise thinking.
- Play and exploration.
A teacher cannot change a child's genes, but can improve the environment the child learns in. A caution: studies of heredity describe differences within a group; they do not tell how much of any one person's ability is inherited, and they do not mean that a child's future is fixed.
Worked example 1: reading twin data
A researcher compares the IQ differences within five pairs of identical twins and five pairs of fraternal twins reared in the same homes. Differences for identical pairs: 4, 6, 3, 5, 7. Differences for fraternal pairs: 11, 9, 14, 8, 13. Means: identical (4 + 6 + 3 + 5 + 7) / 5 = 25 / 5 = 5 points; fraternal (11 + 9 + 14 + 8 + 13) / 5 = 55 / 5 = 11 points. Reading: identical twins are closer, which suggests that heredity matters. But identical twins still differ by 5 points on average, so environment matters too. (These numbers are made up for the example.)
Worked example 2: a teacher's decision
Two children have the same measured potential. Asha has books at home, regular meals and an encouraging family. Bina's home has little talk and she often misses breakfast. After two years Asha's scores are higher. Explanation: according to the reaction-range idea, Asha's environment let her reach nearer the top of her range, while Bina's kept her nearer the bottom. Teacher's action: a mid-day meal, library time, small-group reading and praise for effort can raise the quality of Bina's environment. The teacher does not decide that Bina is simply 'less intelligent' on the strength of her present scores.
Heredity sets a range; environment decides where in the range a child ends. Identical twins share all genes, and fraternal twins about half.
Key takeaways
- Both heredity and environment shape intelligence, and they interact.
- Twin studies compare identical and fraternal pairs to separate the influences.
- Reaction range: heredity sets limits, environment decides the position within them.
- Teachers can improve health, language, encouragement and teaching in the child's environment.
Check your understanding
-
1. Identical twins develop from:
- Two fertilised eggs
- An egg and a clone
- Two eggs fertilised on different days
- One fertilised egg
Show answer
Answer: D. They share all their genes.
-
2. If identical twins are more alike in intelligence than fraternal twins in the same homes, this suggests that:
- Only environment matters
- Heredity probably matters
- Intelligence cannot be measured
- Fraternal twins share all genes
Show answer
Answer: B. Identical twins share more genes, so the greater similarity points to heredity.
-
3. The reaction-range idea says that:
- Heredity alone fixes the final score of the child
- Environment alone fixes the final score of the child
- Heredity sets the range; environment fixes the position
- Scores of a child never change after birth
Show answer
Answer: C. Both factors act together.
-
4. Four pairs of identical twins differ in IQ by 2, 6, 4 and 8 points. What is the mean difference?
- 5 points
- 4 points
- 6 points
- 20 points
Show answer
Answer: A. (2 + 6 + 4 + 8) / 4 = 20 / 4 = 5.
-
5. Which action is within a teacher's power to improve a child's environment?
- Changing the genes the child inherits
- Setting the limits of the reaction range
- Giving language-rich activities and praise
- Choosing which parents the child has
Show answer
Answer: C. Teachers can enrich learning conditions but cannot change heredity.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.