• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

One ability or many: Spearman's g and Thurstone's primary abilities

Explain Spearman's two-factor theory of g and s, list Thurstone's seven primary mental abilities, and contrast the two views.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Is intelligence one thing or many things? This question runs through the whole topic. The two earliest answers came from Charles Spearman, who argued for one general ability, and Louis Thurstone, who argued for several separate abilities. Both used a statistical method called factor analysis, which looks at how scores on different tests go together. Understanding these two theories gives you the base for every later theory.

What factor analysis does, in plain words

Imagine giving a hundred students ten different tests. Factor analysis checks which tests rise and fall together across the students. If students who do well on one test tend to do well on all the others, the tests seem to share one underlying ability. If the tests fall into separate clusters, for example word tests going together and shape tests going together, there seem to be several underlying abilities. Spearman and Thurstone read such patterns differently, which is why their theories differ.

Spearman's two-factor theory

Charles Spearman, a British psychologist, noticed that people who scored well on one kind of mental test tended to score well on others: vocabulary, arithmetic, reasoning and so on. The scores were positively correlated. He explained this by a general factor, which he called g, a common mental ability that enters into every intellectual task. He also saw that people did better on some tests than others, so he added specific factors, called s, each special to one particular task. Because the theory has these two kinds of factor, it is called the two-factor theory.

  • g (general factor): one general mental ability shared by all intellectual tasks; it explains why scores on different tests go together.
  • s (specific factors): many abilities, each special to one task; they explain why a person is better at some tests than others.

Worked example 1

Situation: Pooja scores high in mathematics, science and languages, but her score in music is noticeably higher still. How would Spearman explain this? Step 1: she does well across many subjects, which suggests a high level of g, the general factor running through all of them. Step 2: her extra strength in music is particular to that task, which Spearman would put down to a strong specific factor, s, for music. Answer: high g plus a strong s for music.

Thurstone's primary mental abilities

Louis Thurstone, an American psychologist, analysed test scores differently and concluded that intelligence is made up of several fairly independent abilities rather than one dominant g. He called them primary mental abilities and identified seven:

  1. Verbal comprehension: understanding the meaning of words and passages.
  2. Word fluency: producing words quickly, for example listing words that begin with a given letter.
  3. Number: working with numbers and doing calculations quickly and accurately.
  4. Space (spatial visualisation): picturing shapes and how they look when rotated.
  5. Memory (associative memory): remembering pairs of items, lists and information.
  6. Perceptual speed: noticing details and similarities or differences quickly.
  7. Reasoning (inductive reasoning): finding a general rule from examples.

Spearman: one general ability (g) plus specific abilities (s), the two-factor theory. Thurstone: seven primary mental abilities: verbal comprehension, word fluency, number, space, memory, perceptual speed and reasoning.

Worked example 2

Task: 'Write as many words beginning with the letter T as you can in one minute.' Which of Thurstone's abilities does this test? Step 1: the task is not about understanding meaning, so it is not verbal comprehension. Step 2: it asks for producing words quickly. Step 3: that matches word fluency. Answer: word fluency. By contrast, 'Read this passage and answer questions on it' tests verbal comprehension, and 'Which shape matches this one after turning?' tests space.

Comparing the two

Spearman and Thurstone compared
FeatureSpearmanThurstone
Name of theoryTwo-factor theoryPrimary mental abilities (multiple factors)
Main ideaOne general ability, g, plus specific factorsSeven separate primary abilities
What it explains wellWhy test scores go togetherWhy people have different profiles of strengths

Later research found that Thurstone's abilities are themselves somewhat correlated, which suggested that a general factor may sit above them. So the two views are not entirely opposed: many psychologists today accept a general ability together with more specific abilities.

Key takeaways: Spearman proposed g (general factor) and s (specific factors), the two-factor theory; Thurstone proposed seven primary mental abilities; both used factor analysis; g explains why scores go together, while separate abilities explain different strength profiles.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Spearman's theory of intelligence is known as the:

    1. Two-factor theory
    2. Triarchic theory
    3. Multiple intelligences theory
    4. Structure of intellect
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Spearman proposed a general factor (g) and specific factors (s), hence the two-factor theory.

  2. 2. In Spearman's theory, 'g' stands for:

    1. A group of seven abilities
    2. A general factor that enters into all intellectual tasks
    3. Growth needs
    4. Emotional intelligence
    Show answer

    Answer: B. g is the general mental ability that explains why scores on different tests tend to go together.

  3. 3. How many primary mental abilities did Thurstone identify?

    1. Two
    2. Seven
    3. Eight
    4. Three
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Thurstone named seven primary mental abilities.

  4. 4. 'Name as many fruits as you can in one minute' mainly tests which of Thurstone's abilities?

    1. Verbal comprehension
    2. Space
    3. Word fluency
    4. Perceptual speed
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Producing words quickly is word fluency; verbal comprehension is understanding meaning.

  5. 5. Which of these is NOT one of Thurstone's primary mental abilities?

    1. Number
    2. Perceptual speed
    3. Reasoning
    4. Musical ability
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Thurstone's seven are verbal comprehension, word fluency, number, space, memory, perceptual speed and reasoning; musical ability is not among them.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery