• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Guilford and Cattell: classifying tasks and spotting traps

Place any term in the right dimension of Guilford's model, measure divergent thinking by fluency, flexibility, originality and elaboration, and classify tasks as fluid or crystallised.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The foundation course introduced Guilford's three dimensions and Cattell's two kinds of intelligence. Exam questions on these theories test precise classification: is a term an operation, a content or a product? Is a task convergent or divergent? Does it draw on fluid or crystallised intelligence? Each question has one sorting rule, and once the rule is clear the answer is quick.

Sorting Guilford's terms

Guilford's model has three lists, and setters mix terms from different lists in one question. Remember the question each list answers. Operations are what the mind does: cognition (understanding or recognising), memory, divergent production, convergent production and evaluation (judging whether something is correct or suitable). Contents are what the mind works on: figural (shapes and sounds), symbolic (numbers, letters, codes), semantic (meanings of words and ideas) and behavioural (people's actions, feelings and intentions). Products are the form the result takes: units, classes, relations, systems, transformations and implications.

Operation = what the mind DOES. Content = what it works ON. Product = the FORM of the result. Anything ending in 'production' or naming a mental act is an operation.

Worked example 1: which dimension?

Classify: evaluation, symbolic, relations, memory, behavioural, implications. Step 1: evaluation and memory are mental acts, so they are operations. Step 2: symbolic and behavioural are kinds of information, so they are contents. Step 3: relations and implications are forms of result, so they are products. A common trap is to call 'divergent production' a product because of the word 'production'; it is an operation.

Measuring divergent thinking

Because divergent thinking has no single right answer, it is judged on four qualities of the answers. Fluency is how many ideas are produced. Flexibility is how many different kinds or categories of idea appear. Originality is how unusual the ideas are compared with others' answers. Elaboration is how much detail is added to develop an idea. A teacher who asks open questions, such as 'In how many ways could we reduce waste in the canteen?', gives students practice in all four.

Worked example 2: fluency or flexibility?

Rani lists ten uses of a brick, all of them kinds of building: a wall, a step, a well, a boundary and so on. Sohan lists six uses in five different categories: building a wall, a paperweight, a doorstop, a tool for exercise and a block for drawing on the floor. Step 1: count ideas: Rani 10, Sohan 6, so Rani has higher fluency. Step 2: count categories: Rani 1, Sohan 5, so Sohan has higher flexibility. Answer: Rani is more fluent, Sohan more flexible.

Convergent or divergent?

Ask one question: is there a single correct answer? 'Solve 3x = 12' has one answer, so it is convergent. 'Write a different ending to the story' has many acceptable answers, so it is divergent. Multiple-choice tests mostly reward convergent thinking, which is why teachers add open tasks to build creativity.

Fluid or crystallised?

Ask whether the task can be done with knowledge already learned. If yes, such as recalling a formula, defining a word or using a taught method, it draws on crystallised intelligence. If the task is new and must be reasoned out without such knowledge, such as an unfamiliar figure series, it draws on fluid intelligence. The age trap is common: fluid intelligence tends to peak in early adulthood and then decline gradually, while crystallised intelligence tends to keep growing or stay steady.

Worked example 3: grandfather and grandson

A grandfather beats his grandson easily at a vocabulary quiz, but the grandson solves a new mobile puzzle game much faster. Step 1: the vocabulary quiz uses stored knowledge, so crystallised intelligence, which holds up with age. Step 2: the new puzzle needs reasoning without prior knowledge, so fluid intelligence, which is usually stronger in younger people. Answer: the pattern fits Cattell's theory.

Key takeaways: operations are mental acts, contents are kinds of information, products are forms of result; divergent thinking is judged by fluency, flexibility, originality and elaboration; one right answer means convergent; learned knowledge means crystallised, a new problem means fluid.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In Guilford's structure of intellect, which of these is a product?

    1. Evaluation
    2. Semantic
    3. Divergent production
    4. Transformations
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Products are the forms results take: units, classes, relations, systems, transformations, implications. Evaluation and divergent production are operations; semantic is a content.

  2. 2. Kavya lists twelve uses of an old newspaper in two minutes. The number of ideas she produced is a measure of her:

    1. Flexibility
    2. Originality
    3. Fluency
    4. Elaboration
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Fluency is the number of ideas. Flexibility is the number of different categories, originality is how unusual the ideas are, and elaboration is the detail added to them.

  3. 3. In Guilford's model, the content that deals with the meanings of words and ideas is:

    1. Symbolic
    2. Figural
    3. Semantic
    4. Behavioural
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Semantic content is meaning. Symbolic content is signs such as numbers, letters and codes; figural is shapes and sounds; behavioural is people's actions and feelings.

  4. 4. Which task depends most on crystallised intelligence?

    1. Spelling words learned in earlier classes
    2. Solving a puzzle made of unfamiliar shapes
    3. Finding the rule in a pattern series never seen before
    4. Working out a new kind of problem with no taught method
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Spelling learned words draws on knowledge built up through schooling, which is crystallised intelligence. The other three are new problems, which need fluid intelligence.

  5. 5. Which statement is correct?

    1. Crystallised intelligence tends to keep growing or stay steady into later adulthood
    2. Fluid intelligence depends mainly on schooling
    3. Divergent thinking aims at the single correct answer
    4. Guilford's operations include units and classes
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Crystallised intelligence grows with learning and holds up with age. Fluid intelligence depends little on schooling; divergent thinking produces many answers; units and classes are products, not operations.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery