• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Spearman and Thurstone: reading statements and classifying tasks

Identify Spearman's and Thurstone's theories from exam statements, classify test tasks into Thurstone's seven abilities, and avoid the common mix-ups.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

In the foundation course you met the two earliest answers to the question 'one ability or many?'. Exam questions on them come in two forms: a statement or observation, and you name the theory; or a test task, and you name the ability it measures. This lesson practises both and points out the pairs of terms that are most often confused.

Recognising the theory from a statement

Look for the key idea in the statement rather than the name. If the statement speaks of one common ability running through all mental work, of scores on different tests going together, or of a general factor plus specific factors, it describes Spearman's two-factor theory. If it speaks of several separate, fairly independent abilities that together make up intelligence, and especially if it lists abilities such as number, space or word fluency, it describes Thurstone's primary mental abilities. Statements about many abilities arranged by operations, contents and products belong to Guilford, which you will practise in the next lesson.

Worked example 1: statement to theorist

Statement: 'A pupil's marks in arithmetic, reading and science rise and fall together, but she is a little better at arithmetic than her overall level would predict.' Which theory explains both parts? Step 1: marks rising and falling together point to a shared ability, g. Step 2: being a little better at one subject points to a specific factor, s, for that subject. Step 3: a general factor plus specific factors is Spearman's two-factor theory. Answer: Spearman.

Classifying tasks into Thurstone's abilities

Ask what the task actually demands. Producing many words fast is word fluency; understanding what words or passages mean is verbal comprehension. Calculating quickly and accurately is number. Picturing or rotating shapes is space. Recalling pairs or lists is memory. Noticing small details or differences quickly is perceptual speed. Finding a general rule from examples is reasoning. The table below shows typical test items.

Typical items for each primary ability
TaskAbility
Write as many words ending in '-tion' as you can in one minuteWord fluency
Choose the word closest in meaning to 'ancient'Verbal comprehension
Add 47 + 38 + 26 mentallyNumber
Which shape is the mirror image of this one?Space
Learn ten name-and-face pairs, then recall themMemory
Strike out every 7 on a page of mixed digits, against the clockPerceptual speed
Look at these examples and state the rule they all followReasoning

The traps

Word fluency or verbal comprehension? Fluency is about speed and quantity of words produced; comprehension is about meaning. Number or perceptual speed? Striking out a digit involves numbers but no calculation, so it is perceptual speed. Number or reasoning? Calculation is number; discovering a rule is reasoning. Space or perceptual speed? Space involves picturing and transforming shapes; perceptual speed involves quick comparison of what is in front of you.

Spearman: g + s, scores go together. Thurstone: seven primary abilities: verbal comprehension, word fluency, number, space, memory, perceptual speed, reasoning. Ask what the task demands, not what it contains.

Worked example 2: a task that looks like one thing

Task: 'On a page of mixed digits, circle every 3 that is followed by a 5, as quickly as you can.' Step 1: does the task need calculation? No, nothing is added or multiplied. Step 2: does it need a rule to be discovered? No, the rule is given. Step 3: it needs quick, accurate noticing of details. Answer: perceptual speed, not number.

What each theory means for the teacher

Spearman's view suggests that a pupil who is quick in one subject will often be quick in others, so a general ability shows up across the timetable. Thurstone's view suggests looking at each child's profile: a child weak in number may be strong in verbal comprehension, so one overall score can hide real strengths. Later research found that Thurstone's abilities are themselves correlated, which is why both ideas still appear in modern models.

Key takeaways: identify the theory from its key idea (one general factor versus several primary abilities); classify a task by what it demands; separate word fluency from verbal comprehension and number from perceptual speed and reasoning; Spearman explains why scores go together, Thurstone why profiles differ.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. A test asks students to spot, as fast as possible, the one letter that is different in each row. Which of Thurstone's abilities does it mainly measure?

    1. Space
    2. Perceptual speed
    3. Reasoning
    4. Word fluency
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The task is about noticing details and differences quickly, which is perceptual speed. Nothing is rotated (space), no rule is found (reasoning) and no words are produced (word fluency).

  2. 2. 'Students who do well in one subject usually do reasonably well in others.' Which idea was built on this observation?

    1. Thurstone's word fluency
    2. Guilford's divergent production
    3. Spearman's general factor, g
    4. Gardner's naturalist intelligence
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Spearman noticed that scores on different mental tests go together and explained it with one general factor, g, shared by all intellectual tasks.

  3. 3. Which pair is correctly matched?

    1. Verbal comprehension: understanding the meaning of a passage
    2. Word fluency: understanding the meaning of a passage
    3. Space: remembering pairs of words
    4. Perceptual speed: finding a general rule from examples
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Verbal comprehension is understanding meaning. Word fluency is producing words quickly, space is picturing and rotating shapes, memory covers remembering pairs, and finding a rule from examples is reasoning.

  4. 4. 'Imagine this figure turned through a quarter turn. Which drawing shows the result?' This task mainly tests:

    1. Space (spatial visualisation)
    2. Number
    3. Associative memory
    4. Verbal comprehension
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Picturing a shape and how it looks when rotated is Thurstone's space ability.

  5. 5. In Spearman's theory, why might a student score clearly better in one test than in another of similar difficulty?

    1. Because the general factor g is different for each test
    2. Because Spearman held that there are seven independent abilities
    3. Because crystallised intelligence replaces g in some tests
    4. Because of differences in the specific factors (s) the two tests need
    Show answer

    Answer: D. In the two-factor theory, g is the same general ability used in every test; differences between a person's scores come from the specific factors (s) each test requires. Seven abilities is Thurstone's view; crystallised intelligence is Cattell's idea.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery