- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Thorndike, Thomson, Vernon and nature versus nurture: mixed matching
Match Thorndike's three kinds of intelligence, Thomson's sampling theory and Vernon's hierarchy to their descriptions, state the modern view of heredity and environment, and solve mixed theory-matching questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Besides the major theories, exams often use a few other names to make a matching question harder. Thorndike, Thomson and Vernon appear in this way, and so does the old argument about nature and nurture. This lesson describes each in a sentence or two, gives keywords, and finishes with mixed matching practice across the whole topic.
Three more theorists
- Thorndike described three kinds of intelligence: abstract intelligence (working with words and symbols), mechanical intelligence (working with objects and tools) and social intelligence (dealing with people).
- Thomson's sampling theory says that the mind is made up of a very large number of small, independent connections or bonds. Any test samples some of these bonds, and two tests correlate to the extent that their samples overlap.
- Vernon's hierarchical model puts general intelligence, g, at the top. Below it are two major group factors: v:ed (verbal-educational) and k:m (spatial-practical-mechanical). Below these are minor group factors and, at the base, specific factors.
Thorndike: abstract, mechanical, social. Thomson: sampling of bonds. Vernon: g at the top, then v:ed and k:m.
Nature and nurture
The question of whether intelligence comes from heredity (nature) or environment (nurture) has a settled modern answer: both matter and they interact. Heredity sets a range of possible development, and the environment (nutrition, stimulation, schooling, family) affects where within that range a person's development falls. Researchers study this by comparing similarity of scores among identical twins, fraternal twins and unrelated people, but no single study settles the question for an individual child. An exam statement saying that intelligence is 'only' inherited or 'only' learnt is almost always the wrong option.
Speed table for the whole topic
| Keyword | Theorist or term |
|---|---|
| g and s | Spearman |
| seven primary mental abilities | Thurstone |
| structure of intellect, 3 dimensions | Guilford |
| fluid and crystallised | Cattell |
| multiple intelligences | Gardner |
| triarchic | Sternberg |
| abstract, mechanical, social | Thorndike |
| sampling of bonds | Thomson |
| v:ed and k:m | Vernon |
Worked example 1: statement to theorist
'Intelligence is a large collection of independent bonds; a test samples some of them.' This is Thomson's sampling theory. 'A mechanic who understands machines quickly but finds essays hard.' In Thorndike's three kinds, this describes strong mechanical and weaker abstract intelligence. 'General intelligence at the top, with verbal-educational and practical-mechanical groups below.' This is Vernon.
Worked example 2: a nature-nurture scenario
Two children of similar ability grow up in different homes: one with books, conversation and good nutrition, the other with little stimulation. At school the first scores higher. The best explanation is that environment influences how far inherited potential is realised. It would be wrong to say that the difference proves ability is purely environmental, or that the second child cannot improve. A teacher should give rich experiences to every child.
Worked example 3: find the mismatch
Which of these pairs is wrong? Spearman: g and s. Thurstone: primary mental abilities. Cattell: seven primary mental abilities. Guilford: structure of intellect. The wrong pair is Cattell: seven primary mental abilities, because the seven abilities belong to Thurstone. Cattell is linked with fluid and crystallised intelligence.
Worked example 4: a two-clause item
Statement A: Vernon placed g at the top of a hierarchy. Statement B: Thomson claimed that intelligence is a single fixed amount. A is true. B is false, because Thomson proposed many independent bonds, not one fixed amount. So only A is correct.
Key takeaways: Thorndike names abstract, mechanical and social intelligence. Thomson says tests sample many bonds. Vernon's hierarchy runs from g through v:ed and k:m to specific factors. Heredity and environment interact; avoid 'only' answers. Use the keyword table for fast matching.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which theorist described abstract, mechanical and social intelligence?
- Thorndike
- Thomson
- Vernon
- Guilford
Show answer
Answer: A. Thorndike's three kinds of intelligence were abstract, mechanical and social.
-
2. Which theory says that tests are samples from a large pool of independent bonds?
- Vernon's hierarchical model
- Spearman's two-factor theory
- Thomson's sampling theory
- Cattell's fluid-crystallised theory
Show answer
Answer: C. In Thomson's theory a test draws a sample from many bonds, and tests correlate to the extent that their samples overlap.
-
3. In Vernon's hierarchy, what are the two major group factors below g?
- g and s
- v:ed and k:m
- fluid and crystallised
- verbal and numerical only
Show answer
Answer: B. Vernon's major group factors are v:ed (verbal-educational) and k:m (spatial-practical-mechanical).
-
4. Which statement best fits the modern view of nature and nurture?
- Intelligence is fixed at birth and no experience can alter it
- Intelligence is made wholly by schooling and the home setting
- Heredity matters only for physical traits, not mental ones
- Heredity sets a range, and environment shapes where a person falls
Show answer
Answer: D. Both heredity and environment matter and they interact. Heredity sets a range, and the environment affects development within it.
-
5. Which pairing is wrong?
- Thurstone with primary mental abilities
- Cattell with seven primary mental abilities
- Spearman with g and s
- Guilford with structure of intellect
Show answer
Answer: B. The seven primary mental abilities belong to Thurstone. Cattell is linked with fluid and crystallised intelligence.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.