• Foundation
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Artificial selection: how people steer evolution

Compare natural selection with selection by breeders, and see how one wild plant gave rise to several vegetables and how traits shift generation by generation.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

People have been changing other species for thousands of years, long before anyone knew about genes. A farmer who keeps seed from the best plants, or a breeder who mates the fastest horses, is doing what nature does but with a different aim. Darwin used the work of breeders as one of his chief arguments: if people can make big changes in a short time, nature can make bigger ones over a very long time. This lesson shows how artificial selection works and what it teaches.

What is artificial selection?

In artificial selection humans choose which individuals will breed, based on traits they want, such as milk yield, grain size, speed, colour or gentleness. Individuals without the trait are not allowed to breed. Over generations the trait becomes more common. In natural selection, by contrast, the environment decides which individuals survive and reproduce, and the traits that win are the ones that help survival, not necessarily those that humans like.

Two kinds of selection
FeatureNatural selectionArtificial selection
Who chooses?The environmentHumans
What is favoured?Traits that help survival and reproductionTraits useful or pleasing to humans
SpeedUsually slowCan be fast, because the choice is strict
ExampleResistant bacteria after antibioticsMany breeds of dog from the wolf

Examples

All the breeds of domestic dog, from tiny to huge, descend from the wolf. Vegetables of the cabbage family show the effect even more strikingly. Cabbage, cauliflower, broccoli, kale, kohlrabi and Brussels sprouts all belong to a single species that grows wild near the sea. People chose plants with big leaves and got cabbage; chose big flower clusters and got cauliflower and broccoli; chose a swollen stem and got kohlrabi; chose large buds in the leaf axils and got Brussels sprouts. High-yielding crop plants and cattle that give much milk are also the result of repeated selection.

Costs of artificial selection

Selecting for a few traits and breeding closely related individuals reduces variation. Animals bred from very few parents may show harmful recessive traits more often, because both copies of a harmful allele are more likely to be inherited. Crops that are all alike can be wiped out by a single disease. For this reason, breeders try to keep a range of varieties.

Worked example 1: a shift in seed weight

As an illustration, a plant population has an average seed weight of 20 mg. A breeder saves seeds only from plants whose seeds average 30 mg. Suppose the offspring gain half of the parents' advantage. The parents were 30 − 20 = 10 mg above average, so the offspring average 20 + 0.5 × 10 = 25 mg. In the next round the breeder again picks parents 10 mg above the new average (35 mg), and the offspring average 25 + 5 = 30 mg. The average rises by 5 mg each generation. The numbers are for illustration only.

Worked example 2: natural or artificial?

State which kind of selection is shown. (a) Farmers keep calves from the cows with the highest milk yield. (b) Mosquitoes survive an insecticide and breed. (c) A pigeon breeder pairs birds with the fanciest tails. (d) Bacteria resistant to an antibiotic multiply in a patient. Answers: (a) artificial, (b) natural, (c) artificial, (d) natural. In (a) and (c) humans choose the parents. In (b) and (d) humans create the condition, but the survivors are decided by the environment.

Worked example 3: the cabbage family

Why can kale and broccoli, which look so different, still be crossed? Because they are one species, with a common wild ancestor. Different traits were selected in different populations, so the outward form differs, but the species is the same. This is evidence that selection can produce big changes in form without making a new species.

Artificial selection: humans choose the parents. Natural selection: the environment chooses. In both, the chosen traits become more common.

Key takeaways

  • In artificial selection humans choose the breeding individuals.
  • The cabbage family and dog breeds show how large the changes can be.
  • Natural selection favours survival and reproduction in the environment.
  • Narrow breeding reduces variation and can increase harmful recessive traits.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Cabbage, cauliflower and kohlrabi have all been developed from:

    1. Different wild species in distant countries
    2. A single wild species by artificial selection
    3. Hybrids of cattle and wheat
    4. Mutations in a single plant
    Show answer

    Answer: B. All come from one wild species. Different parts were selected by people, producing different vegetables.

  2. 2. In artificial selection, the parents of the next generation are chosen by:

    1. The climate
    2. Predators
    3. Humans
    4. Disease only
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Humans select the breeding individuals according to traits they want.

  3. 3. Which of these is an example of natural selection?

    1. Insects becoming resistant to a pesticide
    2. Breeding racehorses for speed
    3. Growing larger tomatoes from saved seed
    4. Producing dogs with short legs
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The pesticide kills the susceptible insects and the resistant ones breed; the environment, not a breeder, selects the parents.

  4. 4. A harm of breeding from a few closely related animals is:

    1. All genes in the herd are lost
    2. Variation among the animals increases
    3. Harmful recessive traits appear more often
    4. The animals can no longer breed at all
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Related animals are more likely to carry the same harmful recessive allele, so offspring may inherit two copies. Variation is reduced, not increased.

  5. 5. Darwin used artificial selection as evidence because it showed that:

    1. Features gained in life are inherited
    2. Species can never change in nature
    3. Fossils of old species look alike
    4. Heritable traits shift under selection
    Show answer

    Answer: D. If breeders can alter heritable variation in a few generations, selection by nature over a long time could do the same.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery